Ask Your Question today
I was reading about a man who wanted the ring back. Google Man suing ex-fiancée who refuses to return $30K ring. Do you think she has to give the ring back? I think in a court they will say its a gift and people don't have to return gifts.
Bad thing is he only met her 3 months and proposed to her and bought her a $30,000 ring.
| Give it Back | 23 | |
| Keep it | 12 |
If she broke off the egagement then she needs to return the ring. If he broke off the engagement then it's all hers.
An engagement ring is a contract. He gave it to her with the understanding they are to wed. If she doesn't hold up her end of the contract, she is not entitled to keep the ring.
I really don't know at this point. I guess can see both sides. He went out of his way to save money for it, so I think he should be able to sell it and get some of that cash back. I can also see it as it being a gift and her having no obligation to give it back. I've seen so many people fight over what happens to their engagement ring, it's just annoys me now.
This is probably the lack of sleep talking, but I don't understand the point of an engagement ring. Is it weird that I'd take a homemade engagement snack over a ring? Sure, the food is gone in like 3 minutes, but it's homemade, full of love, and so much cheaper. Heck, I'd even take something else that's handmade. Maybe I want to be the one to propose instead.
He was foolish to pay so much for it. She is money grubbing for not wanting to give it back or at least 50/50.
the trick is to give er a 30k ring and after a week or 2 swap it for a fake and return the real one
I never understood the point of getting an expensive ring. Wouldn't a simple wedding band with some thoughtful words be just as great as diamonds?
Well he's dumb and I don't think she has to. I don't see why anyone would want to keep a ring that represents a failed relationship. She probably wants it for the money. Hell I would sell it