The problem with representativeness on iin. what do you think?

I was reading some story on is it normal and caught myself committing a logical fallacy the other day.

The story itself doesn't really matter. It's the reactions of users that were interesting.

Only 7 people had commented on the story at that point. 2 of them were trolls or semi-trolls. The other 5 users, all of them transparently female, had expressed a very similar point of view. And I caught myself thinking: "Well, it must mean that most women feel that way about this situation."

But it does not necessarily mean that, right?
- We don't know how many female users had a different point of view and decided not to comment.
- We don't know how many users decided not to comment because they don't like controversy for example.
- We don't know how many female users weren't interested and didn't even read the story.
- And, probably the most important point, the female users on IIN, even if most of them did have this view, are not a representative sample/selection of women in this country, much less women all over the world.

Have you ever caught yourself committing this logical fallacy? I.e. have you ever considered the opinions of IINers to be representative of the views of humankind in general?

Yes, I have caught myself committing this logical fallacy. 6
No, I haven't caught myself committing this logical fallacy. 4
I don't think it is a fallacy. IINers do represent the world. 2
Troll option (please be funny). 1
I don't understand the story. 3
Other (please share) 2
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 11 )
  • thegypsysailor

    Are you saying that you don't think those who comment on IIN aren't representative of the broader culture that they come from?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • I'm saying that it is possible that all 5 comments come from a minority.

      If 60 per cent of all people hold position A and 40 per cent hold position B, all 5 comments could have come from the 40 percent faction. The majority (in this case, 60%) of all people could hold the opposite view from the 5 commenters on IIN.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • iEatZombies_

        There's a very good chance that this is the case, as IIN is a site for a relatively specific demographic. I've been on other sites that are kind of like this one and each of those sites have slightly different acceptable and unacceptable responses based on the readers that are attracted to those sites. IIN isn't much different.
        Though you may be surprised to know that IIN isn't as liberal as some other sites. It also isn't as crazy.
        Go figure, huh?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
      • thegypsysailor

        I iz thunkin that you needs be more simplifyin this all. Us poor lil IINers jus ain't not gots the smarts for all your fancy mathmatiks.
        Is that be normal?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Have you been drinking, sailor? :P

          But yeah. I'm simply saying this:

          Even if most comments express one opinion, it doesn't mean that most IINers have this opinion.

          And even if most IINers have this opinion, it doesn't mean that most people in the world share this opinion.

          And yet I instinctively thought this way. This was my logical fallacy.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Freedom_

    When I first joined this site I started to get a little paranoid that everyone I knew was secretly incestuous and that my bf at the time wanted to suck his male friends off. There were soo many posts about that, I just started thinking woah, what are the people closest to me really hiding??

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • NeofelisNebulosa

    Is this ItDuz? Lol. What story are you talking about?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Nope. Can't say I disagree with this person though. :)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • NeofelisNebulosa

        I'm just really curious what the story was

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Maybe they'll respond to you and tell you whenever they're back on. Maybe it's in the recent stories.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
  • rimjob

    I bet this is in reference to the Penis Size post. Déjà vu. My Big Dick giving the womans vagina an orgasm is relevant. Her opinion is not a deciding factor. It doesn't produce babies.

    Comment Hidden ( show )