Should i even give this a try?

Sorry about the long story, but anyways, I got into a gay relationship with a guy a few years ago, fell deeply in love with him (I was the 'man' in the relationship), but increasingly frequent and intense arguments necessitated our breakup three summers ago.

A bit over a year ago he came back into my life and things seemed to be going well, then he dropped a HUGE bombshell on me and told me he felt that he was really a girl. I was shocked but not altogether surprised, and agreed to give a relationship a try anyways because I still loved him deeply.

We were together for about a year, went on vacations and spent massive amounts of time together but our relationship was once again plagued with intense arguments, though we always got through them. She started hormone replacement therapy and got breast implants, dyed her hair platinum blonde and began to dress in revealing clothing, wearing lots of makeup and perfecting a flirtatious, hyper-feminine persona that fooled almost everyone she met into thinking she was born female (though most who knew her knew she was transgender).

Over time, however, she began to notice that I wasn't as attracted to her as when she was a male (I became reluctant to kiss her, and she had a hard time turning me on), and eventually it came to be a point of contention between us. She has her own house on campus at the college she attends, so I would drive up and stay with her for weeks at a time (her college is two hours away from our hometown).

A few months ago, while she was home for a few days, she came over and we had a long talk about the issues between us, most importantly the fact that I wasn't fully attracted to her as a female, and it ultimately resulted in me ending the relationship. It wasn't an angry break-up, but it was obviously very sad and upsetting for both of us.

A few days ago she called me and told me that she had had a sexual encounter with one of the girls in her circle of friends, and that this, among other things, was causing her to heavily consider de-transitioning.

One of the main reasons I had broken up with her was because I didn't think it was fair to her for me to stay in a relationship with her if I wasn't fully attracted to her and able to give her the full amount of love and attention that other guys who actually wanted her as she was could. She's coming home for Christmas break and wants to see (and have sex with) me, and possibly rekindle the relationship.

Should I even give this a try?

Yes, give it a try 3
No, leave it alone 15
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 10 )
  • reminiscent

    Personally I wouldnt...I dont really like on again off again relationships ...they seem to go nowhere.
    But it seems he/she doesnt really know what they want...changing sexes twice seems to me like they are unsure of themselves.
    and all this changing has to come with some medical issues? Doesn't seem safe to be switching a lot...id be worried about surgical problems that could arise.
    and what if he/she changes their mind again?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    Let it be, (s)he's your ex for a reason.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Ellenna

    I'm probably going to cop heaps of shit for this, but personally I don't believe the appropriate remedy for someone who believes h/she was "born in the wrong body" is surgical mutilation, dangerous hormone therapy and almost invariably a parody of stereotyped femininity or masculinity.

    I don't doubt their sincerity, but I don't understand how a person born male can "feel like a woman" because he's never been a woman, so he's feeling how he IMAGINES a woman would feel - usually based on sterotypes. Same thing in reverse for women who believe they're men.

    To be aware in oneself of feelings and attitudes usually associated with the other gender does not mean one IS that other gender: what's the problem with people being what and who they are without going through dangerous and expensive surgery and taking lifelong doses of dangerous artificial hormones?

    I believe people wanting to "transition' are confused and mistaken and this person seems any more confused than most - I don't mean OP but his partner.

    I wouldn't be getting further involved with someone who is so mixed up.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • ferriswheelonfire

      We're on the same page about this, trust me. If it were up to me, I would have never had her do any of this shit in the first place. Another important thing I failed to mention, for the sake of brevity, is the fact that she's kind of a slut.

      There was a one-week period about five or six months ago in which we put our relationship on hold (though this wasn't made entirely clear to me). She ended up fucking three or four guys that week. She also sucked off one of her sixteen year-old brother's friends while we were without-a-doubt together at a completely different time, supposedly because we had had an argument and she wanted revenge (though she didn't tell me about it until months later.

      Fuck. Even typing this shit out and seeing all the terrible crap she's done, I still can't bring myself to completely cut off all contact with her. She told me the other night on the phone (she was shit-faced) that she actually fucked her cousin over Thanksgiving break. They're not blood-related, but still. She said she felt bad about it. Am I insane? I mean, does anyone have any experience they can share to make me feel like less of a fucking idiot?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Ellenna

        To start at the end of your post, you're not a fucking idiot or you wouldn't be questioning this situation, and you're not insane but you're moving in that direction if you stay in this situation. I think you're hooked on her and you need to break free somehow - I don't know how because everyone has to find their own escape hatch, but if you really want to get out of this, you'll find a way. Do you have family and/or friends who will support you in getting away from her and staying away? It's hard to do this stuff alone, believe me.

        Speaking from experience, it's the messy dangerous relationships which are addictive, not the affectionate respectful ones.

        Take care of yourself eh? And PLEASE let us know the rest of the story!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Gavin0420

    well now she is completely different and not the same gay as what you were in love with I was in a similar situation my boyfriend was going to propose to me, but I said no because he wanted to get a sex change.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ferriswheelonfire

    Update: She's back for X-Mas break, and we're fucking again, still saying "I love you", in a relationship in all but name. I don't know why I'm putting all this on here, I guess I just need to make a record of the craziness that is my relationship with this person. Somebody please tell me I'm a fucking dumbass.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Nokiot9

    Wow. Got implants, then changed her mind? Lol. What a shot show. I wouldn't get involved with someone that indecisive about such huge life changing things. That's not something you do half heartedly. It's not the drunken tattoo in Vegas.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dom180

    If it wasn't right then, it's not right now.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Pseodonihm

    I have no advice to give you, as this is out of my league. I think reminiscent has the right idea. Anyway, I wish you well.

    Comment Hidden ( show )