Should a husband want to buy stuff for himself?

Okay, my wife and I constantly argue about this.
I've told her that I get to keep overtime pay I make and she gets to keep bonuses she earns. That comes out to about $200 a month for my pocket and $1500-$2000 a month for her pocket.
Here's the problem, she wants us to use every last penny for home stuff, replacing curtains every few months, new chairs, candles, etc. (We have replaced our comforter 5 times in one year) It’s not like we don’t have them already, she just likes changing colors. I’m always telling her its fine, but I won’t pay for it. She makes way more than me, she can pay for it.
Well, she tries to guilt me every time, “This is not stuff for me, this is stuff for US, you should contribute. It’s not fair I have to pay for all improvements by myself.” She thinks she has a solid argument by saying it’s “us” purchases but I simply feel it’s “her” purchases. -by the way, I always pitch in equally to pay for broken or needed items and sometimes even for cosmetic stuff we don’t need. But she wants it all.
My argument is, “You have way more than me and I am a nerd, I like to buy the occasional game or new speaker. I do not care about home renovation; if it works don’t touch it” I can spend $500 on a new door that looks better and quickly forget about it or I can spend $50 on a toy/game/tech/tool and enjoy it for months. –She spends about as much on her shoes and clothes as I do on tech.
I simply will not budge. I believe unless something is broke, ruined, or just disgustingly old, that it doesn’t need to be replaced.
Is it normal for a guy to want to keep some money for himself for his own selfish desires?

Voting Results
85% Normal
Based on 85 votes (72 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 12 )
  • Paul

    It sounds like your wife is obsessed with consumerism. It may be an indicator of a vacuous inner world. Try to introduce her to art, literature, or some other form of creative self-expression as opposed to thoughtless consumerism. Good luck to you!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • moomus

    She sounds selfish and I'm a
    Girl !!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Every1 wants tech tools :P

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • combatgal856

    Well guy's are humans too, we all have desires which money buys so its normal

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Ur fine dude

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • a_blonde_paradox

    You're not being selfish for not wanting to spend $500 every 3 months on furniture or home decor because your lady likes to change colors. And for her to justify it by saying it's for "US", when in reality she's using that as an excuse for you to contribute to her selfish habit of wanting to change up the house every other week. There is no reason to spend that much money on something when there is no defect or fault. You have every right to want to keep your money and not spend it on dumb shit, and it seems that she's just being self centered and greedy. Don't fall for her guilt trips, its just her way of conning you into throwing money away for something SHE wants, but says you both need. You don't NEED to buy new curtains, or sofa's because one or the other doesn't match the carpet. That's stupid. It's fine to spoil yourself every now and then, but then to expect your partner to give up everything is a bit much.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • f16boiler

    Seems like the issue is this weird extra pay thing. You are married why is the extra money mine and yours. You are a team and should share money equally regardless of how much each males. Set aside a little allowance cash for each other that you can use without each other questioning it's use

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • zed

    Hey you really should deserve to pamper yourself! Buy what ever you want! Go on a shopping spree NOW! She can't do anything after you've bought it right. :D

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • aussiewolf

    its one thing to do renovations on the house but to buy things every few months is ridiculous. that is not fair on you at all. if she wants all that extra crap then she should pay for it herself. you earn you own bonuses so you shouldnt have to pay for her obsession. and the fact that she earns so much more than you do, she can afford to buy all that for herself if she wants to. tell her to stop spending her money on useless crap and save it all up for a round the world holiday for both of you if she wants to try to say its for both of you. i get a small amount of my pay put into my own account every week and put the rest in a joint account with my hubby. we both work so we are both entitled to spend a bit of our own money on ourselves. but you do realise that soon you are going to have to build an extra room in your house to store all that crap that she keeps buying and you know she is going to demand half the money from you. i really dont like people like that, guys or girls.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • spen731

    If it happens the way you say it does then you are right, it also sounds as if she is incapable of understanding your side

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • kellstar

    By your story I think it's fine for u to buy yourself those things u enjoy.u say she buy shoes and clothes and things she likes so it's double standard for her to not want u to buy things u like such as games/ speakers etc.
    Buying 5 comforters in a year is extreme and I hope u give the old ones to people in need instead of just throwing them away because I'm sure that by the amount u replace them there would be nothing wrong with them.
    I agree about if it works leave it be unless it's ugly. Sounds like a waste if money to me.
    Your normal in my view and if it's ok for her to buy things for herself like clothes and what not then it should be ok for u to spend your money on something u like.
    As for the money she spends on home improvements, then I think u should both contribute unless what she wants is ridiculous like new curtains or bedding when there is nothing wrong with what's already there.
    I'm a girl by the way

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • O ya so normal! Sha you should even buy yourself a treat for being so careful of spending your money! She is selfish for thinking you cant

    Comment Hidden ( show )