My friend didn't let my dog out for 2 days. what would you do or say?

We just got back from a hunting trip. My dog ran out and took a monster piss and had sloppy poop. (Sorry) I thought, "What the hell?!" A friend (I'm not so sure now) said he would come before and after work to let our great dane out to go to the bathroom. We left a note, a key in the BBQ, treats and a chew toy on the stove. We got home and the note was still in the door jam, the treats were still there and they key wasn't touched. We weren't sure if what we were seeing was true. We knew he was flakey, but not negligent.
My husband called and played it cool since he didn't want to jump to conclusions. He thanked him and started sort of quizzing him. But the more he talked and asked questions about how it went, we think we're sure he didn't come. He was very vague with answers, like "Oh yeah." or "nope". Turns out he was in the car with his wife who we could tell, she didn't know he volunteered to help us. I could hear her over speaker phone saying "Oh, they left? Where did they go?" He said "They went on an elk hunt" and she said "Oooh cool, did they get anything?"
They only have one car right now and she drops him off and picks him up from work so she would have had to have know for sure since she drives him. She is a vet tech and an animal lover and I know if she would have known she would have been more than happy just to take her to her house while we were gone.
There is more and more evidence proving he didn't come. Lucky she didn't go in the house. Poor dog!!
Knowing him (so I think) our thank you and gratitude will eat at him and he always eventually comes out with the truth of whatever it maybe...eventually. A couple hours after my husband called, knowing his wife would castrate him if she found out, I texted her...."Hey you two! Thank you so much for letting Lily out while we were gone. We really appreciate it!" I also texted it to him....because if he really did come (which I doubt) then he can't be mad at me for throwing him under the bus.
My husband said he thinks it will eat at him for a few days and he might call. If he doesn't call in the next couple days he said he would call him and ask him for the truth.

I am so mad. I am glad my dog is okay and she didn't make a mess. But if any of you have a dog and no kids, you know how much that really hurt our feelings. We don't want to jump the gun. We'll give him a couple days and them ask him pretty much...where our friendship should go after this. He's been a bad friend lately and neglecting an animal, and our 'kid' was the nail in the coffin. In a mean way I think it's funny I texted his wife. I know how nasty she can be.
When my husband calls him he's planning on saying "I know you were lying. I just wanted to see if you were going to be honest." And "Why didn't you just say 'no' if you didn't want to?"

When he was on the phone I yelled jokingly, "She POOPED IN THE HOUSE!" I heard him over the speaker saying, "oooooohhhh." In the 'I wouldn't be surprised' kind of way.

AAAAnny way blah blah blah...
We're both pretty sure we're done being friends with this guy. We don't want a huge confrontation, just an understanding why he would do such a thing before we sweep him under the rug.

What would you say if you were to call him back?
What would you have done?

Should we just leave it at "Hey thanks!" and let it eat at him? And then politely disconnect with him?

Just leave it at Thank You and detatch the friendship? 5
Don't talk to him again? 7
Find out why he would do that then 'nice knowing you'? 14
Pretend it's ok until his guilt sets, then tell him we knew he lied? 6
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 15 )
  • iEatZombies_

    There's really no need to talk to him about it, it clearly won't change anything. He knows what he did, if he were sorry he'd have said so already. If you confront him you'll get an I-got-caught apology. It's best to cut the friendship without awkwardness.

    Also, for future reference; Don't trust people with those kinds of responsibilities unless you're paying them or they're family. Otherwise they won't take it seriously- they'll feel they have better things to do.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • drumandpickchick

      You're right on! This is very good advice. Thank you!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • scrotum-parachute

      I would gladly do this for any of my friends and I wouldn't think I had better things to do. You just have to have real friends that you've known for a while and can trust- who respect you enough to respect the love that you have for your dog. I'm sorry that you think this is an unrealistic thing to expect of someone who isn't related by blood. No offense...

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • iEatZombies_

        I'm sorry that you don't think it's unrealistic.
        What makes you think everyone is capable of finding friends like that? Also, what makes you think those friends will be available?
        Why would you risk your animal's safety to someone who isn't liable for their actions just because you think you can trust them- especially when there are places that can are legally obligated to care, or family that can bring said animal into their home?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • shade_ilmaendu

      I'm glad I'm not people... I'd take care of someone's animals for nothing, it's just cruelty not to. :/

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • DannyKanes

    Ditch him, you don't need friends like that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • NotStrangeBird

    What would i say?

    "GET THE FUCK UP OFF THE GROUND SO I CAN PUNCH YOU AGAIN!!!"

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dappled

    I'd be really wary about who I'd entrust my dog's wellbeing to. It's something I would really fret about unless I chose someone I knew loved the dog and would do the right thing.

    I'm not saying you did the wrong thing. You gave someone the responsibility and they let you down. You could continue to be friends with them but never entrust them with anything important again, or you could tell them what they did wrong (they may be ignorant, or just lazy), but I don't think anger or confrontation are the way to go. It won't undo the damage and doesn't sound like it'd change this person's attitude.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • misca

    Ditch the dog.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      Why would anyone ditch a dog?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • drumandpickchick

      I don't want to leave you in the gutter. My great dane has better manners than you.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • misca

        What gutter?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • howaminotmyself

    I'm sad for your dog, the poor thing. Such an easy and fun chore to do. Please, never entrust your dog's care to someone who doesn't love your dog. If you can't find a friend who can do it, start researching doggie day care centers. Otherwise, don't go on your trip if you can't take your fuzzy friend with you.

    As for your friend, just let it go. Nothing can be gained from confrontation. Personally, I'd be civil and just ignore them.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • drumandpickchick

      That's what surprised me the most. He is the closest person to her besides us!He loves her like crazy when he's visiting. The inside joke is she likes him so much we think she has a 'crush' on him. :) I'm not taking a brown dane, the size of a deer on a hunting trip. You're just asking for trouble. I guess I'm more surprised that he would do that.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • sega31098

    Have fun having your home filled with excrement!

    Comment Hidden ( show )