Most transgendered people i know are basket cases?

I have nothing against transgendered people, or their right to be transgendered. But I'm suspicious about whether a lot of people who claim to be transgendered really are.

The first transgendered person I met seemed mentally normal; I have no trouble believing that he's felt this way his entire life, and I have no problem with him getting a sex-change or identifying as male. More power to him, honestly.

But a few years down the road, two friends of mine wound up declaring themselevs "transgendered," and in both cases it didn't add up, and they both had mental problems before.

The first one, "Susan," was a friend from high school. Throughout high school it was clear something was wrong with her; she believed she was possessed by demons, and had "memories" of a dog-headed demon casting a spell on her as a child. The "demonic posession" she described sounded a hell of a lot like the symptoms of Dissociative Identity Disorder. (Memory blackouts, journal entries she didn't remember writing, etc.) She also had a huge ego; she believed she had a special "destiny," was convinced she would grow up to be a world-famous artist (she gave me a picture once and said "keep this, it'll be worth something someday"), and she told everyone her "secret" (the demon thing). For the record, she also seemed to be attracted to men (we both had a crush on the same boy at one point). After high school I thought she'd grow out of her demon-thing, but then Susan posted online about how angry she was with a friend who called her "crazy" when she revealed her "secret" to her. That was when I stopped following Susan on DeviantArt. A few years later I learned from a mutual friend that Susan was now "male" and had changed her name to (sigh) Damien.

The second person is "Jim." Jim was my first boyfriend from college. He seemed eager enough to make out with me, and we broke up because of his obsessive crush on his female "best friend." He had high-functioning Autism, and admitted to also having auditory hallucinations (which he refused to get help for, for fear that meds would slow his brain down). A year or so after our relationship ended, he flunked out of college (having previously been a straight-A student) because he was "destroyed emotionally" by his "best friend" not returning his "love." This guy also had a flair for the dramatic. When I was dating him, he claimed to have 12 near-death experiences under his belt; dressed like Van Helsing 24/7 in a trench coat, fedora, and all black clothes; and had recently undergone a "life-changing" conversion to Christianity. A few years after college, he underwent another "life-changing" revelation, announcing he was transgendered. He specifically said that making out with me had made him realize that he "wasn't psychologically male." Now he's lamenting about all the "bullshit" he's had to put up with being transgendered. Oh, and he claims he's had another near-death experience.

Then there's the transgendered girl on YouTube, who makes videos about her Dissociative Identity Disorder, where her "alters" talk about themselves. She/they have stated that "the body" used to male. Kind of suspicious, that a person with D.I.D. ends up getting a sex-change. I wonder if it was really her decision, or if one of the alters wanted it.

Finally, there's a transgendered person on a website I frequent; she's been a regular there for years (so have I). She was always notorious for her immaturity and irrational rages, and always had a very cutesy, girly avatar when posting on the forums. Now she's "male." However I'll admit I don't know her well; I honestly wouldn't even think anything of it, if not for the other people I mentioned.

Ironically, the one of these four who seems most likely to actually be trans (IMO) is the obnoxious girl; it could explain her rages and her overly-girly avatars (if she was in denial or something). But the other three seem to be people who either want attention, or crave a change in identity, or both.

Is this trend common in people who are transgendered? Is it common for people to seem completely heterosexual before announcing they are trans? Is it common for trans people to have such serious mental issues? Or am I just a magnet for weirdos?

Voting Results
78% Normal
Based on 18 votes (14 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 10 )
  • 8=====D~~~

    Yes, it's an undiagnosed mental illness. Switching genders doesn't fix that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Gaspipe

    They are mentally ill without question.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Honestly I do think wanting to be the opposite sex is a mental disability. I think it needs to be looked into more to find out why it happens to people and if it can be prevented. Wanting to have your body parts mutilated so you can pretend to be something you're not, nor will ever be is a mental dissorder.

    That said, if there is no possible way to make the person suffering from it happy without the operation then I think it's best to let them have it, it is their choice afterall.

    I think people who dress as the opposite sex but not wanting an operation is something completely different though. They confuse being a man/woman by what attire is prominently wore by the sexes is our culture. As in they prefer the image of the opposite sex and want to look similar. Basically a clothing and image choice than a gender choice.

    I know a guy who's gay who fits in with what I explained in the last paragraph and I asked him about it. He looks like a girl, when I first seen him I thought he was a girl. Became good friends and asked him what the deal is with how he looks, if he's transgender and so on. He basically said no, hes a guy and identifies as a man but has an appreciation for the female image in society such as their clothing, hair, and make up. So made sense.

    Anyway, I'm rambling. Haha.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • IMissMary

    In my experience most people who have gender identity issues have some sort of latent mental problem. Granted most are high functioning and can pretty much go about life without problems but they still have mental issues.

    Gender Identity Disorder

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LoveMyCottonShirt

    Being a tranny is a certifiable mental illness.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • helpful_demon

    being trans does not, in and of itself, make someone mentally-ill. however, lots of trans individuals end up suffering from mental illness due to trauma they suffer at the hands of people that do not understand what it means to be trans/want to "fix" or "cure" them/etc. the rate of depression and suicide is incredibly high, and depression is often comorbid with anxiety disorders (and vice-versa). also, PTSD and dissociative disorders as a result of trauma are also pretty common. not that trauma is the only reason why people develop mental illnesses. some people have a high chance of developing mental illnesses due to genetic/familial components and, for some people, it just comes completely out of the blue. mental illness doesn't discriminate: anyone holding any identity can have one, including anyone of any gender identity. although there is a higher chance of mental illness in the trans community, it's not inherently because they're trans, it's because of how they're treated, and the myriad of different ways the human brain can react to that sort of treatment. what your friends need is understanding and love and someone to support them, because the rest of the world doesn't seem to be doing that great of a job. the fact that you posted this question is already a step in the right direction - maybe i'm reading the intent wrong but, to me, it seems like you're concerned. sorry this is such a wall of text, but I REALLY hope it helps, and feel free to contact me/respond if you want any more info. best of luck, friend and, if you made it this far, godspeed to you, and thanks for reading! :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Terence_the_viking

    Shims are scary.

    Worse than feminazis.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Ok so none of you faggots answered my fucking question. I didn't ask your fucking opinion on transgendered people. Read the god damn title: is is normal that so many trannies I know are cuckoo for Coacoa Puffs? Who have issues OTHER than being trans? As opposed to a person who is trans but otherwise mentally stable?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • ThatOneOfMe

      It is completely normal that they're mentally abnormal. Psychologists officially recognize the phenomena as gender disphoria, which is a disassociative disorder. It's normal to know so many of them that have mental issues because what qualifies them as transgender is a mental disorder in and of itself.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Fugazi,again

    Duh

    Comment Hidden ( show )