Is this a normal result of years of problems?
I love my husband; he's funny as hell, intelligent, we enjoy the same activities, he helps me around the house, we share the same sense of humor and we love spending time together. I'm more social than he is - I'm often staying out later than him when he wants to go home early because he has some social anxiety. We've discussed this and we're both okay with it, although I'd prefer he stay out and have fun with me.
Our sex life has been stop and start for the whole 8 years we've been together. In our first few years together, I was an emotional mess and hurt him pretty badly. As a result of that hurt, he withheld sex from me for about a year. We worked through it, got things back on track, and moved on. About four years ago, things started going south again sexually due to lack of communication on both of our sides. This went on for about three years off and on - sometimes it'd be better, sometimes worse.
Last year, I finally sat down with him and told him how I felt and what I wanted/needed from him sexually. It was a really hard conversation for him to have, but he tried his best to participate. He said he needed me to tell him more things I liked sexually so that he could make sure he was doing everything I wanted. So I started making lists for him of things I like, I found bdsm quizzes online for both of us to take to get an idea of what we both want, but I told him most importantly, I needed to feel wanted.
For one reason or another, he didn't follow through on any of those things. He never did any of the things I told him I liked or wanted and eventually I just gave up. We didn't have sex for six months. Then we a pretty bad argument about it, he said he understood that he had let me down by not doing the things I had told him I needed [side note: I was still doing things for him that he wanted/needed during this time]. He promised to be better.
It did get better for about a month. Then he stopped again, and it went another 6 weeks without anything from him, with me still trying to initiate things and have an encounter we could both enjoy. It didn't work.
Now, again, we had another argument about it and he's trying again. But my body just isn't responding. I tense up when he touches me, and part of me knows it's because I'm waiting for him to fumble around and do things he thinks feel good but just annoy me. Then, when I try to move his hand where I want it, or ask him to do something differently while we're in the middle of foreplay, he gets upset. So now I just don't feel like it's worth it at all.
Is this normal? Is this just the result of years of ups and downs because of this?