Is it normal to have so many deal breakers?

If I ever have another relationship there are many requirements I have for a potential partner. Any one of these deal breakers results in an automatic loss of interest. I think my list is pretty reasonable but it seems nobody meets my standards. I will list some of my standards to give a better idea.

-Must give me my own space regularly.
-No nagging
-Must be sexually attractive and compatible to me. (I'm not too picky with this one though.)
-Cannot be jealous of my female friends or have other unrealistic jealousy.
-Must be assertive. Dominate and submissive personalities both piss me off. I will not tolerate controlling behavior nor will I tolerate someone who cannot think for themselves.
-Cannot be religious. Spiritual is ok, but must come up with own ideas. Followers will not be tolerated.
-Must like similar music. I am a musician and music is a big part of my life.
-Cannot be lazy.
-No poor hygiene or slob habits.
-If has kids must be a good parent but give me lots of space from them as well.
-Stories of being shitty toward past partners is a bad sign.
-No current hard drug habits.
-No prejudice judgments towards people for things they cannot help.
-Must like to do similar things as me.
-Desperation for relationships is a turnoff.
-Must love animals.
-No getting upset over things that don't matter.

Voting Results
54% Normal
Based on 48 votes (26 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 14 )
  • MFyfe

    Forgive the judgemental tone, but i would suggest you might approaching relationships all wrong. There's nothing wrong with having high standards, and knowing what you want is also good. But having a specific list of criteria blocks you off to the possibilities that people that may have one or two of these flaws might entail. What if someone comes along who is perfect for you, but can have a tendency to nag when worried about you (this is normal human behaviour). Perhaps they don't always put their dishes away after eating. What if they like different music, but are incredible in every other way. Does music need to be the basis of your relationship? How can you be planning out a relationship in that detail with someone you don't know yet?

    What about your own flaws? Do you think if everyone had an extensive list like this that you would fit someone's criteria perfectly? Let's say the perfect person came along and did somehow fit your own criteria perfectly, and you fell for them... Wouldn't you want them to overlook YOUR flaws and love you as you are rather than be coolly measured to a set of standards?

    The reason no one meets your standards? They are almost impossible. They are essentially just another you. You cannot hope to find such a person, and if you did, i suspect that with this attitude they would only get on your nerves anyway. What's to love about someone exactly like you? That's boring.

    Falling in love is about loving someone unconditionally, no matter how infuriating some aspects of them might be. They need to make you happy (and visa versa) but them loving you and you loving them back should not be dependant on any criteria. Loving is about celebrating your differences and loving one another all the more for them; helping each other to work on their flaws; working towards a common goal of closeness… It's hard to explain if you've never truly been mutually in love, but respectfully i have to concur that you haven't.

    If you meet the right person (trust me, if you are remotely open to the possibility, they won't look anything like the person you've imagined, or be anything like this list dictates), then you will know, and your list will be necessarily forgotten.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Certain things I can tolerate to an extent, for example I'm not going to get upset over someone leaving a dish out, but if someone is a slob I cannot and will not live with them.
      With the music thing, liking other music isn't bad, but as a musician I would want somebody who will enjoy what I do as well and support me at my shows and give me motivation. I cannot imagine being with someone who isn't into what I do.
      With nagging and leaving me alone, I require a lot of space and while I enjoy socializing, I do not like being intrupted during my time.
      There are a lot of traits that many people cannot stand that I am just fine with, such as I don't mind people who most other people find obnoxious, because I'm quite obnoxious myself. I don't mind rudeness or most other crazy behavior either and don't care if they have money or a job. So there are a lot of things I am ok with but I cannot be with someone who just pisses me off all the time or I have nothing in common with.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • MFyfe

        I take your point about the music, but you can't truly expect this. I love playing sport but i've never expected my partner to share that passion and play with me/go with me to all my games (except out of pure support of me, which IS reasonable to expect from time to time).

        Do you define yourself by your work? It's obviously a big part of your life but do you want your relationship to be focused around that, or on you as a person. If it's the latter, then specifically sharing your love of music (and your performance of it), shouldn't be essential.

        While your thinking is rational, i think you should try to do less of it. There is little rationality in love, at least in its truest form. I know it's hard to let go of that control, especially if you've been hurt in the past, but i think it's important.

        Not wanting to be with someone who pisses you off all the time or you have nothing in common with is absolutely fine and right. But why not leave it at that? Ultimately it's your choice but if you open yourself up, who knows what you could find out there with a person completely different to what you expected.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • I actually do see my music as such a big part of my life that I consider it an extension of me.

          As far as most those other things go, I wouldn't be interested in anyone who didn't meet my standards in the first place.

          It's important to have standards. I don't know why so many people will just get with anybody as a partner. Many things on my list are intolerable to me.

          Everyone should have requirements for those things and not settle for less just because they are desperate.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • MFyfe

            i think you've missed the point. Good luck regardless

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • henryjohnny

    You are way too judgemental. Especially considering you're just as flawed as anyone else. It's ok to have some standards, but one day you will find there's more to two people getting along than meeting criteria on a list. If you try to live by a list of criteria for your partner then it works both ways. Eventually you will fail to meet up to your partner's list and they'll leave you and you'll wish you never made up lists to live up to.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KeepsakeDoll

    The no nagging one might be a problem.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • handsignals

    Fitter, happier, more productive
    Comfortable, not drinking too much
    Regular exercise at the gym 3 days a week
    Getting on better with your associate employee contemporaries

    At ease, eating well
    No more microwave dinners and saturated fats
    A patient better driver, a safer car, baby smiling in back seat
    Sleeping well, no bad dreams, no paranoia
    Careful to all animals, never washing spiders down the plughole

    Keep in contact with old friends, enjoy a drink now and then
    Will frequently check credit at Moral Bank hole in wall
    Favors for favors, fond but not in love
    Charity, standing orders, on Sundays ring road supermarket

    No killing moths or putting boiling water on the ants
    Car wash also on Sundays
    No longer afraid of the dark or midday shadows
    Nothing so ridiculously teenage and desperate
    Nothing so childish

    At a better pace, slower and more calculated
    No chance of escape, now self-employed
    Concerned but powerless
    An empowered and informed member of society

    Pragmatism, not idealism
    Will not cry in public
    Less chance of illness
    Tires that grip in the wet
    Shot of baby strapped in back seat
    A good memory

    Still cries at a good film
    Still kisses with saliva
    No longer empty and frantic
    Like a cat tied to a stick
    That's driven into frozen winter shit

    The ability to laugh at weakness
    Calm, fitter, healthier and more productive
    A pig in a cage on antibiotics

    Read more: Radiohead - Fitter Happier Lyrics | MetroLyrics

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      Thanks, that's just what I needed.
      ;-)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Seems pretty realistic to me.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • gorillaphant

    You sound like a friend of mine. These all sound like very reasonable requests. But be wary of sounding too demanding. And don't assume your date is going to break them.

    I'd love to lay it out simply for my friend, however I risk pushing them away if I speak too much about it. The problem my friend has that sounds like something you may suffer from is not knowing how to lay down proper boundaries. They say they are willing to make sacrifices because they care more about the person than the thing they gave up. That isn't a boundary, that's a concession. The second they do something that annoys you, you will resent that sacrifice.

    But maybe that isnt you. Ultimately, communicate your boundaries and learn the fine art of compromise. Both partners should easily slide into these roles without requiring a discussion on the concept of deal breakers.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • I don't really understand your comment.

      I think I'm pretty good at setting boundaries. That was the whole point of this topic I thought. Isn't having standards similar to setting boundaries?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • gorillaphant

        Sorry, I think I was just rambling in frustration of a friend always picks high maintenance girlfriends and then wonders why they can't appreciate the simple things in life.

        Standards and boundaries are similar. I think it depends on how you present them, and when. Don't tell someone on a first date that they aren't allowed to do (insert request)if they want to date you.

        I think your "standards" are fairly commonplace and understanding. I unconsciously set these with all my friends, but I would never lay them down as a check list.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • I would never tell someone not to do something. I simply wouldn't be interested in the first place to someone who I have nothing in common with or has habits that I don't like.

          Expecting people to change is one of the dumbest things people do.

          Comment Hidden ( show )