Is it normal to believe that the rich should give away their money?

Seriously though- As a sense of enlightenment gained, or something.. Anyway. I KNOW that if I were a millionaire, I would love to embark on an experiment in which I would travel around Los Angeles for a day giving out $100 to 100 homeless people in hopes of bringing a glimpse of happiness for those in moments of hopelessness and despair. Whether they used it on drugs or starting a better life, that action would have brought relief to 100 people for at least one day.. And well: Isn't that worth it? Is it normal to want to do this?

Voting Results
55% Normal
Based on 89 votes (49 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 41 )
  • jess22

    Obama, you're on IIN?!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RomeoDeMontague

      HAHAHAHAHAHA

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • margeriewise

    i think its normal for most people to have a grudge against the super rich and want them to give it all away. even if theyre not giving it all away, many do give out large sums of money. i don't think it's right that anyone's hand should be forced when it comes to their hard-earned money, but if you wanna do it when you get rich, then that would be a nice blessing for those less fortunate :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • soccer593

    People who earn their money should be able to do what they want with it. Otherwise why let them earn it anyway. If you want to give away money to make people feel happy that's great. But you shouldn't have to.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • BfingIToucher

    This is so overly simplistic on so many levels.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SassyFrassyLassie_old

    But that would just be ONE day, wouldn't you want to do something that could do good for decades?

    Good for you for wanting to do something to help.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TheConsciousElectron

    Socialistic bastard

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      And do you have nothing else to say other than repeating yourself? Mindless-TOOL: I wouldn't expect a compassionate response from someone who has obviously been labeled as God's reject in life. You poor thing! (im talking to the poor baby you'll probably end up eating...)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • TheConsciousElectron

        You really have a lot of negative things to say.

        In a nutshell, because I AM NOT GOD'S REJECT, I work really hard, harder than most people do, and I don't feel obligated to give any of my money away to others who don't deserve it as much. I am passionate about what I want to do with my life and if people need more money, then they should also have to invest more time, effort, and creativity into their work.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RomeoDeMontague

    No you are lazy and should get off your ass, off the computer, and make your own money. If someone is owner of a rich business they built from the ground up they did something to make that money themselves. They do not ow you anything.

    Just because you are too stupid and lazy to make any yourself does not mean they are obligated to take care of you. How old are you 12? Mommy and daddy are not always going to take care of you and going to others demanding cash is not showing any kind of responsibility or maturity.

    Yeah some people are born lucky and born into money but that does not mean they ow anything to you either. If someone gives to the poor that is very generous of them. DEMANDING they give you cash is not going to do anything. SO STOP MOOCHING OFF EVERYONE AND GET A JOB YOU LAZY IDIOT!

    Oh I wish we could thumb down questions. I hate people who are lazy and wont earn anything for themselves. That expect the world NEEDS TO PAY FOR THEM. THEY DONT! THEY REALLY DONT! I really despise people like you. LEARN TO GROW UP AND BE RESPONSIBLE!

    You know I don't normally say this since its hard right now. I really have to and your mindset is irritating. You must be a child because if you are an adult I really have lost all faith in this world GET A JOB YOU LAZY MORON!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ManaX

    Your naive to think money will solve all their problems, there are a lot of reasons why people live on the streets.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      Yea obviously.. Thanks, pal. My bad for thinking they'd like a little help- that's all!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • ManaX

        Well, you are half right. Some people who live on the streets do need a 'little' help, and the money given to them will go towards their welfare. Alcoholics and drug addicts don't need money, they need psychological help. Watch 'Intervention A&E' on youtube, it's all about the lives of drug addicts living on the streets.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • spen731

    Apology accepted, honestly I think you're a complete idiot but you are intelligent and gracious enough to admit when you're wrong which in my book makes you better than the other idiots on here

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Mastersash

    *k, so the math is all wrong here and I look like a dumbass because even a trillion dollars wouldn't make us all millionaires.. We'd all get a fat reimbursement but would NOT be millionaires.. WOW I apologize and am now kicking myself for appearing as dumb as the hideous electron & etc. while making comments about what is "just".

    But I can't take back my statements (otherwise, believe me I would considering I berate others MINDLESS comments all the time..)so I'll apologize once more about that comment, because my only point was to raise facts about issues concerning those who have the money versus entire countries that are struggling. So I'll correct myself once more with the REAL legitimate fact that a man named David Ellison can raise $350 million dollars to co-found movies with Paramount pictures yet the United Nations was struggling to find $900 million for an entire country known as Pakistan, which is now heavily underwater! I'm sorry for sounding so ignorant- and f.y.i. this is WHY math is necessary people (I'll be moving onto statistics soon enough, and now realize I really need to check my own common sense before hating on others idiocracy.. again, I'm sorry..)So I really hope those can look past my mistake and see what I meant about how much our own Hollywood media can produce yet the League of World leaders seem to be on a tight budget when distributing emergency funds.. I hope you see my point, and I'll do everything I can to disregard others mindless statements before agreeing with them. Thanks..

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • F34RTH3HUNT3R

    It would be great to have people around like Robin Hood. I just might do that...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • spen731

    Ok first of all no one on the planet is nearly rich enough to give everyone in America a million dollars, I think the richest person has around 70 billion, a billion is a thousand million, so that would give 70000 people one million dollars, no where near the 350000000 Americans, there are few people who have over a billion dollars out there. I don't like it when people inherit that much money but if someone earns it no one should be able to take it from them, people used to say the idle rich, now it's more the idle poor, if you think rich should be forced to give up their money do you think welfare bums who don't even try to work should be forced to get a job, the governments giving them a check, they should at least make them do some work for it

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      yes, maybe the bums SHOULD be forced to get a job.. unless they're handicapped in some way or have a legitimate disability (mental illness, etc..), it doesn't make any more sense to hoard money when people are starving, whether earned righteously or not. But because that argument will never end due to the stereotypical communist fear versus a real Utopian society, it will NEVER make any sense to take from the rich (regardless of taking from the poor every single day) because it is the same "right" America was stolen (ahem, "founded") upon when originally settled. Manifest Destiny; which people still believe that for some reason we all had the "God-given right to expand and conquer," so hallelujah and amen.. I guess..

      Anyway, to repeat myself in regards to the statement about there being people in America who are wealthy enough to make everyone dwelling here also a millionaire, I have since corrected myself by pointing out that even if Bill Gates or whomever couldn't actually pull of that sort of contribution, it is our own government that very well COULD have achieved such a stint as making us all millionaires, at one point or another, in the past... Referring to: the FACT that we're now over 13 trillion dollars in debt due to the decade-long war we're currently tied in to, if we had invested only ONE trillion dollars into the lives of the American people back when our debt was in a surplus in 1998(we apparently had the money!), then we EASILY make every one of us 350 million individuals a millionaire, without a doubt. So my apologies for assuming 70 billion from one man could pull that off, but I had corrected myself by re-framing the idea around the possibility that our one GOVERNMENT could pull it off.. we could! If we had the cash to spare when we removed Hussein for the invisible weapons of mass-destruction, then we most certainly had the money at one point to make every American working or living on the streets a millionaire, too. THE POINT IS: We had the money to end poverty in our country at one point, but never did!

      So we're still waiting on Robin Hood to help out every hard working or poverty stricken person out there.. and we'll keep on waiting til the cows come home.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • cowgirl352

    IIN that I dislike Mastersash so much even though I've never met him?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TheConsciousElectron

    And it's one thing to donate to charity, it's another to give money out to random homeless people and to be forced into it. I agree that if you are rich enough, and have all that money, that there comes a point where you don't need it all. That is a personal choice though. If I had billions, of course I would help out charities but I wouldn't give it to random poor folks.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • deepthought33

    I just recently heard that there are a few trillionaires/millionaires who have agreed to give half of their fortune to charity. That is pretty cool but I couldn't help thinking how weird it was that even after they did that they'd still be millionaires. I don't think we realize JUST how rich some of those ultra-rich people are.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      wow, man.. I know it's my own fault for listening to you, but why'd you set me up like that?? You should go back to school and take a few math classes as well.. just saying :P

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Mastersash

      The saddest part of all is knowing that our troops are really fighting for us like the brave soldiers they are, but they DON'T KNOW that we're the actual bad guys! To quote many intelligent U.S. citizens I'll refer to the fact that the best reasoning most people believe the taliban hates us is because they're jealous of us and they hate our american pride/dream.. Well YEAH it's a shitty dream. Climb to the top and if u avoid politics as ur source of power, than owning a corporate monopoly/oligopoly might pay off the dividends of feeling inadequate with only owning material wealth. Sure chinese workers are committing suicide in Apple factories but hey, at least a part of that multi-billion dollar fortune will donate some money BACK to the charities which hath built up the CEO's noble name and reputation. NO ONE EVEN READS THE NEWS LONG ENOUGH TO KNOW THERE WERE NEVER ANY WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION IN IRAQ, but everyone seems to KNOW that an entire sect of radical extremists are just so indignant with OUR own patriotism that they believe they must retaliate by proving us wrong with their own competitiveness through THEIR life-dream of committing a public suicide. NOT BECAUSE THE PEOPLE OVER THERE KNOW THEY ARE ON THE KING'S LAND WHILST BEING ROBBED BY PIRATES OVERSEAS WHOM HAVE ALREADY WON BECAUSE THE REST OF THE WORLD BACKS US UP?? It's not right what the taliban are doing, of course, but it's even worse sending our own troops in without even knowing what they're fighting for! It's just like America's foundation that we fought off the "Indians" in light of none other than manifest destiny! That's it, and now millions of people were slaughtered by the same minds that are trying to reestablish a new gold standard. IT'S NOT RIGHT TO KILL but with July being the bloodiest month so far, we are killing our own people for an illusion.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Mastersash

      so the government borrows money from it's CITIZENS and then stuffs it into the greedy pockets of bailouts that gave such failing AIG execs their $1000 per/night vacation package on us! that's the shittiest trickle-down theory if i've ever heard one considering the flow is running back up the waterfall (impossible). So it pours for them like it did when the bankers ripped us all off, and then WE GO EVEN MORE IN DEBT TO THE PEOPLE WE OWE MONEY TO?? The debt is viewed as our problem at an $8/hr rate when why doesn't any average american look up and question why we owe more those who borrowed from us in the first place?! This is their fault!! The elite who took their sweet ass time to be selfish up until the end of the world so they can blame their charity on some crippling disease? Ya okay WHATEVER no. I don't give an I.O.U. to someone (take out a loan from a bank) and then when the person asks to borrow money from me before I have repaid said person(banker), I don't suddenly owe that person twice as much money- what happens is WE ARE EVEN!!! But because our entire system has laid down it's foundation on a bed of quick-sand, I can ONLY assume that these tools are now realizing that the their invisible money which we have turned over for loans to other countries along with accumulating even more debt from others for our 2nd Vietnam war in Afghanistan.. where all the real money with any actual substance is hiding. $1 trillion+ in gold and i-pod goodies should explain a war or two..

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Mastersash

      I would love to believe more than anything that Paul Allen gave away his $13.5 billion out of the goodness of his heart, but seeing as this is such a rare event among many others, I'm just not buying it. It's either one of two things, or both: 1. He's spending the to protect himself and his family from apocalypse in the slim chance that 2012 is anything at all like the movie where the world's richest elite pay for their place on the safety ship. Can't be proven, yet it still seems much more reliable than charity. OR 2. I'm not sure which is worse but if a comet doesn't hit us then our own financial system should provide as an ample substitute. Meaning: that when our markets collapse (which they will), every single person indebted to our monetary system, a.k.a. the federal reserve, will be held accountable for what is owed to every other country. So give your money away or you might end up in jail when the rest of the world wakes up and notices that every human on this planet is a slave to money, and those who own the invisible bank claim dominion over other territories that don't want our "help" in the first place!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • It's their hard earned money they don't have to give drug money to hobos if they don't want to :P

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      hard earned money or stealing from everyone in America?? THERE IS NO MONEY INVESTED IN AMERICA- THE RICH WHO HARBOR MOST OF THIS COUNTRIES WEALTH ARE GOING TO BE THE MOST IN DEBT, AS WELL! So I hope you all have great credit so you can take out a loan and sell your soul to the devil: WAY TO GO!

      *please wake up, people.. YOU'RE MISSING MY POINT!

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • goFUCKyourself

    well thats their money they made it. the hobos would just spend it on crack lol

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Mastersash

      yes, but if actually READ what i wrote right above you, you would realize you just fucked yourself..

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Mastersash

    You shouldn't HAVE to do anything- it's a free country.. But I am astounded to realize how such a religious and conservative "christian nation" always manages to find every loophole that helps profit the materialistic American Dream, when Jesus himself said, "If you want to be perfect, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me." BUT NOOOO.. EVERYONE WANTS TO KEEP THEIR MONEY AND DO WHAT THEY PLEASE BECAUSE THAT WILL STOP JUDGMENT DAY FROM COMING. Have fun with that.. you can't breath paper.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • starkmanfan28

    They or someone they're related too worked hard for that money. Yeah it would be nice if they have to charity but it shouldn't be required

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Juanita023

    Your idea sounds nice, but the drawback of that is the fact that some of those people would come back, begging for more and more...and more. It's good that you would want to help others who are less fortunate, but there's a certain way to go about doing it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • deepthought33

    There are some individual people who alone are rich enough to give every person in the United States a million dollars and still be millionaires themselves. I can only imagine that world *sigh*

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Are you talking about God beacause thre aint nobody that rich.....

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Mastersash

        And yea, there are people that rich.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • No there not, 1 million to each person in the us would be trillions, and no man has anything neer that

          the richest man in the world has 60 billion, not 60 trillion

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Mastersash

            well considering our national debt is well beyond the trillions, I believe the statement still holds true.. could you imagine our country if we used 1 trillion out of the 13 trillion dollars as charity for every American? Now i know the word charity scares the crap out of every conservative who cant wrap their head around any idea other than achieving personal growth through wealth.. getting rich is the only dream most people have, and even when they do they don't dream much further. Even though the president is just a figure head, if the government could prioritize it's spending in constructive way than giving a million to each American could have been a very real possibility before this war started; when the debt was in a surplus! Whether with one man's checkbook or through one leading figure-head's persuasion, the amount of money we lost towards this war in hope's of gaining a new gold standard (located in Afghanistan)would definitely have been an actual possibility at one point.. But has never been a REAL possibility, however, because man has always believed that victory is gained through conquering rather than giving.. always. Except JESUS, by the way... the Buddha was an amazing man, too. I could only imagine what his city would have been like if he knew how his princely riches could help solve all the poverty and pain that he originally left his palace for. Of course in the end, the Example is what lasts longer than the man or the money.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • diabolic_mushroom

    Erm... I don't think that you're going to help many homeless people by giving them 100 dollars each.

    However, it is perfectly normal to want the wealthy to share their money.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • tori

    I think large corporations should give to their community more. Instead of take and take. Most CEOs are way tooooo greedy. So are politicians.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • soccer2

    It's grea that u want to help people and if u get the chance to do so then go for it.

    But the rich should not be forced to give away their money whether it was hard earned or not.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ~L~

    I think rich people should be made to give something back to the community. I think they should pay for a hospital or school to be built.

    Comment Hidden ( show )