Is it normal that i am so confused about what i want?

I met my husband 4 years ago whilst travelling around New Zealand. I was completely infatuated by him for the first few months of our relationship. I'd found someone who completely understood me and saw things the same way I did, my soulmate.
We fell pregnant only 5 months into our relationship and nine months later after no warning from scans I gave birth to our beautiful daughter who has Down Syndrome and had a heart defect.
During my pregnancy I learned that my partner had anger issues and he would smash up the house and be verbally abusive. Soon after my daughter was born things started to get worse and he smashed a window.
Anyway my daughter was in heart failure pretty much from the day she was born. We were in and out of hospital and finally at the age of 3 months old she had open heart surgery which was successful.
We were still living in New Zealand at the time and I decided I wanted us to move back to my home country (UK) where we would get better support for our daughter. We decided to get married to help with immigration. Only 10 days after our marriage my husband hit me.
I left him in fear that he was losing control of himself. I flew back to England a week later and started setting up a home. He entered England 5 months later and only a few weeks later he threw a hot cup of coffee at me and as I ducked and the mug shattered it cut open my leg. He moved out and over time we tried to make it work again. We then fell pregnant with our second child who is now 20 months old. The abuse continued and I had to call the police on one occasion as my husband threatened to kill me. We later went to the States, which is where he is from and in front of his whole family he exploded at me and created an awful scene. Since then he quit drinking and started to going to AA each week, I also got him signed up with a centre for people mental health issues and he was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. He attended psychotherapy 2 times a week. He went 1 ½ years giving no physical and only occasional verbal abuse until just recently he headbutted me.

I decided to leave him and he now lives elsewhere but he refuses to believe its over and keeps wanting me to take responsibility for our failed marriage.

I started hanging out with my ex boyfriend as friends. He was always sweet, compasionate, considerate. I feel like I have experienced two extremes in relationships- one where I am treated like rubbish (as with my husband) and another where I am idolised (past boyfriend). I should be jumping at a guy with all the qualities of my ex. The only reason I broke up with him in the first place was because he was too nice. Have I learned my lesson and am I ready for nice now? I just want someone I can grow old and enjoy life with and I know I could have this with him. Part of me still can't let go of my marriage. Do people actually change? Has anyone ever known of anyone who all of a sudden stoped abusing their wife? I'm so confused. Help!

Voting Results
61% Normal
Based on 18 votes (11 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 7 )
  • wuddeva

    Sweet baby jesus... Why the hell do you girls (and guys) lack the ability to sense a terrible person? I'm a terrible person btw. Suddenly you realize that you should be with the nice guy you were with before.
    ...infatuation can only go so far...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • lsuccv

      Its been a few months since I wrote here so I do have an update. I did end up trying things out and going back with my ex ex boyfriend who 'treats me so nice'. Then I remembered why we broke up all those years ago... All of a sudden he was all over me. When I wanted to talk all he wanted to do was jump on me. I think I have a high sex drive but part of sex for me is about intimacy and this comes from more than just the physical. Some people don't have the capacity to think beyond basic need thoughts 'sex, food, drink, sleep'. We were different in that way and that is still what I miss so much about my relationship with my ex husband. I know now that it wasn't infatuation- there was something there and we connected on a level I have never connected with anyone else on. I need an intimacy that's more than just a physical chemistry and honestly I don't think there is anyone else out there that I will connect with on that spiritual level.

      My ex has BPD which is a mental illness that results in his uncontrollable rage and depression.

      I feel I found my soulmate when I met my husband and still now I feel the same way. He is and always will be my soulmate and the fact that he's not perfect and that I can't spend the rest of my life with him won't ever change that. I still feel that whatever happens in my life, whenever I finally move on, that the next guy will always be second best (lucky him eh? Any takers). Do we really have more than one soulmate?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • lsuccv

    Thank you for all your comments. It has given me lots to think about and clarified some of the things I was already thinking.
    It is sad that relationships have to end and I hate that mine was one of those relationships. Each weekend when I see my husband to hand over the children for a day, I just get more and more confident that I made the right decision to leave him. I think the truth is he will never change and I feel bad for him for that. He lost alot as a result of his behaviour and still blames everyone else.
    I'm still just friends with my ex boyfriend but I can't help but start to have feelings for him. We watched some home videos the other night and I couldn't help but think 'Why did I break up with this guy?'. I know its pathetic but I think when I was young I always thought I could do better, turns out I think he's one of the best ones out there. I do know though that if we were ever going to try again I would have to be 100% sure and it would be a decision for life. I care about him too much to hurt him again.

    As for the comment about me 'thinking it good to have a child after a bad episode', of course that's not why we had a child. There had been time after the storm and we had another child because I loved him and thought he loved me. People make mistakes, I take responsibility for mine but I would not change my kids for the world. I'm glad I have two wonderful children, and like the other comment so cleverly said, 'my babies are the better, he is the worse' in my marriage.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • opal-leaves

    It's normal to feel these emotional symptoms of confusion because first off you;re in an emotional wreck.
    I think you need time apart from your husband & be firm about what you say to him! IF he doesn't treat you right you better let him know (& understand that you're not going to take it!) I know it's hard because you probably love him but think of your children. You don't want them growing up in an environment that can possibly may end up hurting them or make them grow up to be aggressive like their father. SO be strong & leave him for a while (as much as he begs & pleads: you have to let him know that until he get's his shit straight then you will come back) & honey, that isn't going to be in a day or 2 that will probably take months or years. So that's what I would do. THEN about the EX, well keep your distance. You probably feel close to him & all but you really need time for your own. yes you want comfort because of all this pain but you need to know what you REALLY want to do because you don't want to end up leading him on again :/ It's normal to feel "attached" to someone we weren't as attached before because we've been hurt. So please just give it time with your ex.
    In summation, you need time apart from your husband (& if you're scared he's going to find someone else then WHO CARES?!) If he does find someone else, it's because he doesn't love you. & In reality no offense he doesn't love you to begin with (he's treating you miserably & trust guys & anyone will do just about anything for the one they love) For example you, you love him so much to endure his shit but yet he doesn't love you to stop doing it. So stop thinking with your heart!! (The heart is the MOST treacherous this ever!). Think with your brain, think of your kids! DON'T get into any relationships & just move on. Thank God you're in the States in which you can get child support or money from the government to help you out for now.
    So please be strong, he's not worth it :/ until he proves that he's changed then no. You're putting you & your kids in danger & as a mother you must not want that.
    Please move on... :)
    I wish you the best in your journey, I know it must be tough but God never gives us anything we cannot bear.
    Take care & feel free to message me if you ever need a friend :)
    <3
    S.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • shuggy-chan

    GO, go with the nice guy, please. if not for your, your kids, and his sake, but for all the nice guys out there that are feeling like they are finishing last.

    i could use the hope i guess, im tired of feeling like im in last place. =P

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • prettyladykee

    I think you are making the right choices. My ex-boyfriend is 37 and we have 4 kids together and he is so stuck in his ways. I've moved on to better (my new love) he misses the hell out of me and is trying to come back but I can't deal with him and his mean ways. I suffered, and the kids suffered behind his quick temper and long punishments. So what I am trying to say is don't you think you have gone through enough? Look at it that way. You shouldn't have to have gone through what you've gone through already. So to sub-ject you and those babies to that again just because he is ur husband ....no,no,no,....is not good. Damn that marriage license or for better or worst. You've got your babies that is the better and the worst is him. Take those babies and let them feel happiness not suffering, hurt and pain. They deserve it and so do you. Give you a chance...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • georgienne

    I think that deep down you're wishing your marriage would work out, at that's perfectly normal. But you've given him countless chances, and support but he's either disrespecting it/you or he simply can not handle this relationship and lifestyle.
    In the story it sounds like you moved, he hurt you then you had another kid, I'll assume there was a long period of calm here, because if you thought it good to have a child after a bad episode then I'm afraid that's your poor judgement.
    It's hard to say whether you want a super nice guy, or that you're just relieved they exist. Give it time and hopefully you'll find out.

    Comment Hidden ( show )