Is it normal for my aunt and uncle to hide this secret from my cousin?

My cousin, an only child, is 10, and will be 11 in December. He is the replacement child. About 14 years ago, his mother gave birth to twins. One was stillborn, the other was born ill and died after a week or so, but she was named Catherine and was still alive for some time. My cousin was born as the replacement, but I found out from his mother to this day that he has never been told about Catherine and her stillborn twin. It has been hidden from him... personally, I think he should be told about it at some point, and I think hiding this from him is wrong. But is he too young to know? I want opinions is it normal to not tell him that he had a sister (or two depending on what you count)?

Voting Results
59% Normal
Based on 49 votes (29 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 12 )
  • Solophonic

    It's horrible but it's normal that fetuses and infants die. A child that was had after that isn't considered a replacement, just another kid. He could have but he never did have any siblings. He should be told about it some day, but that is for the mother to decide in my opinion.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • emilydoll

    Don't tell that's none of your business to do so. Trust me. You could do a lit of harm. The child does Not need to know this they might not understand.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Inspector019

    Why would you feel it is important to say something devasting to another human being like "they are a replacement"? What are you trying to accomplish? Ruininh their self esteem just because you are a busy body? Grow up. Sometimes you need to mind your own business rather than get involved in something that has no purpose other than devastation. Maybe at the time the child was a replacement for all the loss suffered but not a literal replacement of another child. Tgat can never be replaced. Saying something like that can only rob your cousin of self worth and ruin tgem emotionally when you can't possibly understand what you are talking about. Another sad example of someone feeling the need to create drama and ruin someone elses life because you arent happy with your own.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dom180

    I wouldn't feel traumatised if I was told. I would feel glad that my parents cared enough to try and have another kid or I wouldn't have even been born. For the same reason, I wouldn't feel offended if I wasn't told until I was in my 30s, or even if I was never told at all.

    However, I am also a very strange person. I am sure that most people would care, in the same way that most people would care if they were adopted or not, when I wouldn't care at all.

    Don't tell him though. Ffs, the kids only 10. Wait 5 years, then he'll be mature enough to know how to take it in context, if his parents haven't told him already.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • He should be told. Why shouldn't he?

    It's not like it's going to impact him or turn into some kind of soap opera.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • emilydoll

    That to me would've traumatizing. It's really none of your business.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • AngAnders112

    it depends on the maturity of your cousin. Some 10 y.o. may be able to handle and comprehend. but it's definitely not your place to tell him. me personally, if I were 10 I don't see why I would need to know that information at that age.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • jucedaguy

    Don't be an interfering fucknuckle. It is none if your business

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • its non of your business if the parents wish to tell him then they will if not then its not for you to tell him.

    no offence its between the parents and the child.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • empty.heart

    It isnt like theyeve killed someone its just like that theyeve had childrens before whwen i was kinda 10 too i founded out that my father had another child that died and i wasnt mad on him. so he should know its the best , because its not souch a big deal

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Sweetz

    They will tell him when they think the time is right. It wouldn't be so great if he heard it from someone that wasn't his parents.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LOUi_CUDi

    Hopefully u dont tell him.. N ya his too young

    Comment Hidden ( show )