Is failing to mention the entire truth a lie?

You have a girlfriend/boyfriend and you love them. Everything is going well with the relationship. Your previous relationships were open and you identified as polyamorous, and your significant other knows about this but they don't believe in poly and they want you to be monogamous with them. All that said, you still have poly urges that you do not act on. Would not telling your lover about these urges be a lie?

Voting Results
73% Normal
Based on 22 votes (16 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 11 )
  • charli.m

    If they specifically ask you and you don't tell them, it's a lie. If you just don't tell them and it isn't raised, it's an omission and technically not a lie.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • reminiscent

    I would say a little it is... its good you dont act on them as it would hurt the person you are with...
    But its good to be open with the person you are seeing and you should let them know how you are feeling but assure them you have not acted on such urges.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • wistfulmaiden

    If we all said what was in our minds, we'd all hate everyone.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • TimmyTheTurtle

      i say what i think an aint nobody like me... ._. except a few people like shuggy.. i think hes gay for me :x

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • megadriver

    It's a bit of a half truth, but as long as you don't act on your urges and stay true, I see no reason to share that.
    No reason in saying something that I'll have to explain later.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RainbowFlash

    The fact you are asking means you already know that you are being dishonest.

    You are clearly being deceptive, your partner wants to know if you are still having those urges, probably because they care for your wellbeing, and you are hiding that which you know to be the truth.

    You may not be directly lying, but you are lying by omission and intent.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Hedgehug95

    This is so weird because I am living this exact situation with my boyfriend right now. This is what happened (short version): he told me he wanted to try open relationship, I violently opposed to it, as he knew I would. I asked him tons of questions, he barely answered. We almost broke up, but I didn't want to. We talked and he finally told me that it was a misunderstanding and that he didn't absolutely want to bang other girls, but that he needed more out of this relationship. I still hope he told me the truth and won't act on those thoughts. So you don't need to tell her if you think it will do more harm than good. If you do talk to her about it, I strongly advise that you thoroughly question yourself about what is going on. Do you really want other girls or just other sexual experiences that you could get with your girlfriend? Ex.: My boyfriend is really into bondage, but is shy to act for fear of pushing me too far. Thing is, I love that stuff too. We just never really talked about it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KeepsakeDoll

    No, a lie is when you twist the truth around. If you don't even tell them then it's more like a secret.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • disthing

    No - by definition, not mentioning the entire truth is not a lie.

    It may still be deception and dishonesty, though, depending on the circumstances.

    In your case, withholding the truth wouldn't necessarily be dishonest, since your partner knowing you identify as polyamorous isn't really important or beneficial to your relationship.

    However, it does suggest you don't think your relationship with your partner is built on a solid enough foundation to hold up to this 'revelation'.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • It's a half truth which can not be as bad as a lie, as bad as a lie, or worse than a lie.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TimmyTheTurtle

    i think if you told them that you were polyamorous from the start but still choose to be with you. it is their own dumbass fault for getting cheated on.

    Comment Hidden ( show )