Is it normal to "talk" for a year or more?

This guy I've been seeing explained that he was talking to his last ex Gf for the first two years of their five year relationship. It started by me questioning where me and him are taking our thing next because its going to be a year that we've been talking. Then he said he likes taking things slow and doesn't jump into any relationship then explained his last one. I understand he wants to get to know me and he's doing the right things but its just the timing like it's been so long already. I'm not waiting for him to ask me to be his Gf because I can easily ask him to be my bf if I wanted to be official but the way he does these things is really mellow, slow and he just goes with the flow. Its weird because it has been long but I also feel like I'm taking things slow too. Like its been about a year but it doesn't feel like a year. In that case we are on the same page but the problem is when i realize it has been this long and does he realize it or care. And when pple are like "really its been a year and you guys are still not official?" I'm like yeah that's true but time is so irrelevant that I honestly feel the things weve been through for a year is something an average couple goes through for 3-4 months before being official. He doesn't speak up on it he just let's it flow kind of like how I do too but then i realize its been long and I'd like to know where things are going. So I asked and he says that; it takes him a while to get to know someone and see if he wants to be with her. For me, it doesnt even feel that long but it has been so should I be concerned? is that normal? Is it normal to "see" and "talk" to someone for a while? If ya who can relate?

Voting Results
33% Normal
Based on 27 votes (9 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 27 )
  • Fall_leaves

    Has he done this in all of his relationships other than his last gf, that seems like a long time. I could understand if you're just friends and getting to know each other and maybe eventually you'd date but if not no hard feelings type thing and you'd remain friends. Has he been monogamous during this time?

    Could he be hesitant about getting into a new relationship after his five year one?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • He's only had two relationships, not sure about the first one but his last one, yes. I believe we are "dating" we just call it "talking" and that includes going out together and sex. He recently met my whole family and thats why I also brought up, why would you do that if we're still nothing exclusive? and thats when he explains hes interested in getting to know me on that level but then I think it has been a year so? Yet, I don't feel like its been a year.
      And we have brought up if we have been with other people and he says he hasn't which I believe but in terms of interested in someone else? he says he's not but that I don't believe. In the end, he comes to me. For me, I have been with one guy but I don't feel as bad since we're not together but sometimes I do because he makes it seem like its something serious, SOMETIMES.
      And yeah I think he is hesitant plus the way he does things such as taking things really slow. It was about two years ago since that ex gf. And so, about a year ago, we met. So I guess its understandable if he's hesitant but at the same time, he looks perfectly fine without her. Sometimes I forget he was with someone for five years because it doesn't show at all.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Fall_leaves

        Yeah, you shouldn't feel guilty if he hasn't been consistent about the seriousness of your relationship.

        Has he been open about seeing you right off the bat with his family and friends?

        If he had a bad experience in his last relationship that could definitely make him more wary about starting a new one.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • He has mentioned me to them and so they know who I am and has said he would like to take me to one of their parties but he hasn't really made the effort into actually introducing me. I guess its because of the whole seriousness thing. He doesn't want to make it look like it's serious since were both not ready.
          And yeah I think a lot of it has to do with his last relationship. They tried having a long distance one at the end when he moved for college but he says he didn't like it. So now that were living apart, he's even more hesitant. But I think were both on the same page that were not ready to be that serious for our own reasons but the only concern for me is our boundaries. And thats to stay loyal even if not exclusive. I think its about respect so if he does want to be free to talk to other girls then okay but he will need to let me go.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Fall_leaves

            Ohhh so you guys are around my age 20-23 lol you know for some reason I was picturing late twenties to thirties? Which yeah I guess he could be older ang just started college later so I could be inaccurate.

            All of what you mentioned sounds familiar to a relationship (not sure I should call it that) that I had in the beginning. He wouldn't want me to come over unless his roommate was gone, because we weren't dating but we were? He told his friends about me and never made an effort to introduce us which sucked because he met all of my friends. Now I see it as a waste of time, and I wish I ended it sooner. Just be careful about falling for him, he may never intend to take that next step with you which is wrong on his part to prolong something for his own selfish purposes.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • Yeah I'm 22 but he's 27 but he still acts/looks like 24 ish but not in an immature way. And we're both done with school, too. Finished at the same time.

              So he treated you "lowkey?" It sounds like he just wanted his cake and eat it, too. I have confronted him about that before, and he apologized that he didn't mean to portray whatever we have that way and that he won't "have his cake." I think I just am on the same page as he is, though. As much as we don't want a relationship right now, we like each other that we want to stay in touch and not lose each other. So rather than ending it, I really am just gonna let it flow especially that I don't live around him anymore. That's gonna make it easier to move on. But like I said, we like each other and I see it as taking it this slow and not in a rush can build a great foundation for a future relationship. Kind of like in the end, we'll be best friends and they say "marry your best friend."

              Btw, I thought you were older. You seem to have mature responses for a 20-23 year-old. You can't find many like that our age.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • mountain-man82

    A year without making anything official is just odd. Thats far too long to not even be bf/gf. Sounds like its just a close friendship to me.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • It is long but the thing is it doesn't feel like it. It feels like 4 months the most but we have hung out very often. And its def more than a friendship considering we do couple things, we're "dating" or "seeing" each other. I just wonder if that has happened to anyone else cause I feel fine until I see that its not normal. Our interest in each other hasn't faded away, if it has we would easily stop talking. Our interest in each other is whats been keeping us going. But we obviously still keep going and going and going and I wonder until when. I want to believe we're building a good foundation for a successful relationship by taking things slow but not really sure. It's like we are becoming best friends slowly and then its those cases where in the end "you marry your best friend."

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • mountain-man82

        With it being that long I would say "piss or get off the pot." Meaning make it official or make it known that its only fwbs. Define it in some way. Its been too long.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Were both just not ready to be serious but we like each other. Hmm I don't know exactly what to define it as. Were more than fwbs but not exclusive. The only thing I would define are the boundaries and thats to be loyal. So if we happen to see ourselves interested in someone else we would let each other know and do as we please rather than talking to that person at the same time as talking to each other.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • mountain-man82

            Sounds like a relationship.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LAR23

    I feel like if no one ever called me out on my shit I'd be like your "bf" or whatever you want to call him.. But I admit it's not normal. Which is okay, but only for as long as you're fine with it. The moment it starts bothering you you need to move on or give him a reality check

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • What do you mean? You'd just be going with "the flow" because you're supposedly "getting away with it?" until someone calls you out?
      Like I said, I don't feel like its been a year and its because the things we have done have taken a year when it takes a few months to do. So its like mutual. Plus, we had other priorities so those would be other distractions or setbacks on our dating. But it seems like some people think the guy will always have a different side to it such as, him fooling around which idk I don't think so because of all the factors that have played into it like his five-year relationship and his way of doing things.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • LAR23

        Oops I replied in the wrong place

        I mean I tend to do things at my own pace, which is usually super laid back and extremely slow, until it becomes an issue and the other person complains or something. If this is what you want, there's nothing wrong with it. You trust him, you think it's worth it and/or enjoyable then cool. I'd probably appreciate a relationship like that myself, but usually one person or the other (in my case the other) gets impatient. If that's not true for you then you have no problem!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RainbowDischarge

    I was "talking" to my boyfriend for a year before he officially asked me to be his girl.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • indie_scorp

    Everyone here is being polite about it, but he's playing you and you're allowing it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • The difference between him playing me and not playing me is the fact that were both on the same page. No one is playing each other. If I wanted to be his Gf already then maybe you can think all those typical assumptions. But not in this case. Were both not ready and taking it slow, there's not really a hurry

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • derpyderp

      How do you figure?

      I'm more than happy to be blunt with someone but it sounds like this girl knows what's going on & where it might end up for them, for better or worse...

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ilovetoiletrolls

    I'd say it's fine but only if you don't get to see each other often. If you're seeing each other or communicating frequently, this is not healthy nor is it normal.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • derpyderp

    So you two see each other often?
    But you just talk & never anything more?
    How do you define this as a relationship & not a friendship?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • We did but not anymore since I moved about two hrs away and recently met to hang out. So we're trying to make the best of it?
      We don't just talk, we have had sex if that's where you're going, and we go out as an item, sometimes we like staying home and we don't have sex.
      I guess from what I just said above distinguishes us as a relationship and not a friendship. I think we're more than friends w benefits because we are loyal to each other despite one time. But we do consider each other as our own, so its not like I can be with anyone else without considering him first and vice versa.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • derpyderp

        OK, it was a little hard to tell.

        Look I would say if you are both comfortable & happy with how things are then it's fine.
        If you're not comfortable & would prefer to know exactly where you stand then you need to have a talk where you both voice your concerns.

        If he's been badly hurt (& I would think that's likely after a 5 year relationship) then he may fear being hurt again.
        That's totally understandable of course but it's a bit unfair to leave you guessing because of it.
        That's if you're unhappy of course...
        & I assume you are, at least a little, if you're on here questioning it

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • I think I am fine and don't want to cause any problems that could destroy a possible, good future with him. He has told me in a way that he's not ready after a five yr relationship plus like you said he might have gotten hurt which idk but in five years yeah that's possible. Now that were living far from each other, he's even more hesitant to make it official since he said he tried that with his ex once he moved to college and didn't like it.
          As for me, I think I'm just bringing up these concerns cause of the fact I really like him. But I have to remind myself I'm not ready for a relationship either whih is why im also fine taking it slow. So with that being said, my only concern is our boundaries. I think we should at least respect each other and not talk to anyone else; all about loyalty even if were not serious. If he wants to be free to talk to other girls then I think thats when I draw the line because I don't mind sticking to only him even if he's not my bf. I'm not interested in anyone else so until I might see myself interested in someone else then I would let him know and see what happens.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • kayleeberry101

            This definitely sounds like commitment issues. Maybe he's not over his ex?

            Comment Hidden ( show )
          • derpyderp

            It's a tricky situation &, as you say, being apart is likely a configuring factor.

            If you're happy, even for now at least, then yeah, stick with it & see where it leads.

            Your view on boundaries is quite fair.
            At the moment you sound like a couple, just without the title.
            & that's fine, just like people who are together for years & years without being married.
            Words & rings don't change feelings...

            IMO the important thing is that you are both on the same page with your expectations of each other

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • Exactly. I always looked at it like those couples who just don't want to marry each other. Not because they don't love each other enough but because it's not necessary and they're fine the way they are.
              But yes, in a way, its always the girl to care a little more and speak up. So I just have to let him know those boundaries and if we're not on the same page with that, then I'll let it go. I'm afraid he's going to say something like "why should I stop talking to other people if I'm technically single?" Which he is right but it's about respect and feelings. If we don't have strong enough feelings to not see other people, then it makes me put way less effort than I have been putting. And he might just not know what he wants. Even though he's not the type to get around and flirt, it might hit him that he's in a committed "thing" and it'll scare him off.

              Comment Hidden ( show )