Is it normal to not be able to judge people on physical appeal?
This type of thing is impossible for me to do. A lot of people would stay away from certain people because of how they look but even if that deterred everyone else I would never notice. I also categorize people as threat vs non-threat and I don't really make assessments about people. Many people judge based on looks and will say "well he has a nice ass" or "he she must be great in bed" but I don't usually do that.