Is it normal to love a song at first but hate it when it becomes overplayed?

There will be some songs I love when they first come out on the radio. However, after a while of them being released, I end up disliking them because the radio plays them practically every other hour. One of the radio stations where I live plays mainstream music (Katy Perry, Pitbull, you get the idea) and is especially notorious for playing the same songs over and over. I try to get out of listening to that station as much as possible. Unfortunately, it is my sister's and my cousin's favorite radio station and I'm stuck listening to it whenever I go places with them. Anybody else feel the same way about good songs being ruined by being overplayed?