Is it normal to feel like you were born the wrong gender?

For the larger part of my life I've been confused, but recently I've finally been able to articulate that confusion. I'm very much in the closet, but now I know what's been bothering me. I'm biologically a male, but I feel like I'm female. It's a strange disconnect that's difficult to describe, but basically I feel no attatchments to any sort of male stereotype and hate almost everything associated with them. I hate how I can really only wear jeans and a t-shirt and I hate how people judge me thinking that I'm a guy- a "bro"- that acts a certain way. Everyday I feel like I'm playing dress-up, playing a part, putting on a mask. It's horrible, but I can't tell anyone I know, save for my therapist and my psychiatrist. I don't think I'm trans because it implies that I want to transition, which I never will. All I want in life is for someone to tell me I'm beautiful.

Voting Results
53% Normal
Based on 32 votes (17 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 37 )
  • NeuroNeptunian

    I felt this way in the earlier part of my life.

    I was always a tomboy. I played mainly with boys, outside, getting dirty, playing war games, sneaking into junkyards and other dumb shit boys tend to do. Girls thought I was very strange for it and I just could not conceive of doing the stuff that they liked because it all seemed so boring. I told my Dad that I didn't want to be a girl because girls were boring and wimpy and I didn't want to be associated with that noise.

    I'm 23 now and I have realized a few things. For starters, being boring and wimpy is no where near a "girl" trait. My definition of "boring" is not shared with 100% of the world - my definition of fun is shooting, war games, obstacle course runs, racing and working on cars, comic conventions etc. I've found that even though most females don't share my interests, a lot of males don't either.

    At the same time, I'm into "feminine things". My tattoo on my wrist is a pretty green and purple vine, I look like a woman and I work with kids and do a lot of counseling work in the education field which is something that is considered feminine. My Psychology professor loved using me as an example of what it meant to be androgynous.

    Yes, there is a point to all of this. The point is that gender is an illusion. Gender is a classification that we reinforce by saying that a person or trait has to be one or the other. Think about all of the "real men" out there who don't know what the hell a head gasket is. Think of all of the "real women" out there who have no idea who or what Louis Vouitton is (I know I didn't spell that right).

    A lot of your confusion can be alleviated by accepting that gender is a social construct. Even from a neurological standpoint, the differences between men and women are, more or less, restricted to the physiological (uteruses vs. penises, hormones etc.). While the physiological has *some* effect on behavior and temperament, both sexes exhibit pretty much the same neurological events even if they are for slightly different reasons.

    That and there are plenty of girls out there who wish someone would tell them that they are beautiful. Not being beautiful or seen as beautiful doesn't make you any more of less of a person. It makes you normal, it anything.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Riddler

      Very well put. :)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Crusades|

      Gender is not a social construct. Being a politically correct moron who doesn't have the cognitive ability to understand that gender traits are innate, is.

      Want an example of a social construct? The ideology that gender is a social construct, is a social construct.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Redcoats

        Incorrect, gender is a social construct. It is not socially accepted to be a man and like "girly" things and visa versa. Society has very gender specific roles.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Crusades|

          Oh my god...

          Just because society tends to judge people who don't act according to their gender doesn't mean that everybody would suddenly become androgynous if those standards were removed from society. People generally act instinctively most of the time, based on their genetic structure. Men and women are inherently different compared to each other. Men are more aggressive due to their high testosterone level, women act more passive due to lower testosterone. Sure, there are exceptions, but those make up the minority.

          Why do people feel the need to totally dismiss obvious biological facts?

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Redcoats

            You raise good points, but biology isn't the issue. The issue is the OP feeling they were born the wrong gender.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • Crusades|

              Just because it causes issues for some people, still doesn't make it a social construct.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
          • NeuroNeptunian

            Yeah, so the emerging data that increasingly proves that women display aggressive tendencies under the same conditions as males provided that the women are not being observed by males and the increasing happenstance of women being arrested for violent crime in all countries worldwide... It's an illusion, it never happened.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • "Increasing"? It's still relatively uncommon. In fact, crime statistics go a long way in validating the claim that glaring discrepancies exist between genders. Exceptions do not negate rules.

              Signed, an agender person often mistaken for a tranny.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
            • Odeen

              I am liking this discussion so far, but could you provide a source? (Ex: a survey) This seems interesting.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
      • NeuroNeptunian

        The evidence says that most innate behavioral nuances between the sexes are negligible at best. Don't call my political beliefs into this when I'm attempting to simply be informative. Yes. There are physiological differences. Yes. They do affect the general appearance and neurological makeup of an individual. Are those neurological differences of the caliber that we like to say they are? Not by a long shot, pun intended.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • chained_rage

    No, I don't think I was born the wrong gender. I do, however, think that I was born the wrong species.
    I wanted to be an ostrich.

    The ostrich doesn't follow that birdbrain pack mentality.
    The ostrich was like NO, I WILL NOT FLY AROUND LIKE A STUPID FAIRY!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • BlueBerryFieldsForever

    No. You're beautiful the way you are and you just need to find ways to help appreciate yourself. To be content with your biological body.

    I wish everyone that felt like you could do this. There would be alot less unhappy people in the world and they wouldn't have to throw away their true selves.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Pika-girl

    Sometimes, I think I'm a genderless blob of junk until I look at myself in the mirror and remember that I'm human and female. XD

    I can't really imagine myself being either gender! Maybe I consider myself genderfluid? I dunno.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • modernism

    Transgendered people don't necessarily transition, despite the name implying it. There are many people that still have their biological genitals and just outwardly appear the opposite gender.

    Don't let people tell you to act or stay socially male because they have no right to do so. They aren't you and gender roles are completely up to interpretation, if not non-existent.

    But despite this, society thinks otherwise.

    Ask yourself: would you ever be content with living your life as "socially" male (meaning what society thinks a male should be like)? Walking down the street as a male, dating as a male, looking in the mirror as a male?

    If the answer is "no", then whip out that dress. Be feminine if you want. Be masculine if you want.

    Basically, do whatever the hell you want.

    Your sex shouldn't determine how you act and people certainly shouldn't tell you how to live your life. If you're not causing anyone valid harm, and it makes you happy, the do it - whatever "it" is.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Ellenna

    I will never understand how anyone can genuinely believe they are the other gender, because they've never been the other gender so it's about them IMAGINING what it would be like to be the other gender (sorry for the repetitiveness of that phrase). I could imagine I were a black person trapped in a white body, but I don't really know what it's like to be black, because I'm not.

    In this case, I reckon what it really means is that OP doesn't feel he fits the male sterotype and why should he anyway?

    "Changing gender" involves surgery to the genitals and hormone therapy no person who cared about their future health would expose their bodies to. I foresee many health problems in the future for people taking huge doses of sex hormones which don't occur normally and the body can't cope with.

    By all means, dress and behave as you wish, but it doesn't make you other opposite gender my friend. Of course, this is harder than "changing gender" but much more honest and realistic in my opinion.

    Surgeons and shrinks are hormone manufacturers are making a fortune out of exploiting people's mistaken ideas about what is a "real man" or a "real woman" - be whoever you are, but you're a bloke, you were born one and have grown up as one, nothing can change that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Odeen

      It seems that you are misunderstanding what I mean. I definitley never want to undergo a sex change, and it's not that I don't fit the stereotype. I know this is an exageration of your point but for example: just because I don't like sports doesn't mean I was born with the wrong genitals. It's more complicated, so I'll try to explain it better. When I say I feel like I was born the wrong gender, I don't mean I AM female, not at all. I understand that nothing can change the fact that a greater portion of testosterone flows through my body. I simply have a great DESIRE to be female. Everybody has their problems with society's expectation for them to perform their respective gender. But there comes a point.

      At that point you're far past the primitive name-calling. You are not simply a sissy or a pussy or a tomboy or queer. You have passed the threshold of disconnect onto the other side.

      I'm not just fond of girly things and playing dress-up. I have a deep, guttural desire to be part of that group that identifies as female. I want to wear skirts and dresses and put on make-up and hit on and boys and be called beautiful. I want to be led in a waltz, I want to be able to braid my hair, I want to shave my body hair, I want to play the leading role in the relationship. I want all of these things and more separately and together. Collectively as a society we call these things female. That is what it means to have this kind of disconnect.

      I'm not trying to "debunk" your interperation, I'm just providing mine. I'm glad you have shared your opinion, which is why I have opened up this discussion. However, I don't want this to turn into an argument, so let's not get heated here.

      Thank you.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Ellenna

        Thanks for the expansion of your original post and no, I don't want any arguments about it either, it's not something to argue about but it's valuable to share views because it's becoming more and more common and I truly believe has potential dangers

        Good luck with however you live your life, but I'm sorry I don't see how you can be part of the group that identifies as female, because you're just not female. If you think being a woman is playing the lead role in the relationship I think you're mistaken, relationships are much more variable than that.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • deadfishfollowthestream

    If it makes you happy, and doesn't harm anyone, it's normal. The norms of society don't define you, go do what makes you happy! (Unless it involves murder. Don't do that.) I have a couple of transgender friends, and some of them aren't straight when they have changed gender. Remember, what you feel biologically doesn't dictate your sexuality. :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • nothing2

    Roll with what you got

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Flc2019

    It's your life do what you what.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Aliceee93

    People used to bully me cause I was a girl that loved farming :( always questioned myself.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Riddler

    Its called Transgender

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • JD777

    You're normal and natural. We're made to think we're biologically either 100% male or 100% female. Truth is most people have varying degrees of both genders even if their genitals are 100% one gender.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • HauntedHalos

    Yeah it's normal, the th I,g you need to find out is if you want to invest in a gender switch surgically (Lots of money) but many, many people keep themselves how they are. There are many support groups and I don't think you should feel pressured by stereotypes to be a certain way either. There are a lot of forums you can join online that are trans or lbgt friendly and there are so many people that would support and give advice from their experiences. Also online, I personally was so touched by a YouTuber, Gigi Gorgeous. She went through multiple surgeries and they were all taped and her experience in changing is all on her profile.

    I wish you the best of luck with everything, hoped I helped a tad!! c:

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Avant-Garde

    Yes, it's normal. There have been Trans people who have no desire to transition, either completely or partially. Justin Vivian Bond decided to keep her penis, while everything else became a woman. Its fine. I suggest in joining Empty Closets, they have a gender identity and expression part on that forum. There are a lot supportive people on there who understand what you're going through. :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Ellenna

      That doesn't make sense

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • green_boogers

    This should not be hard to fix. Put on a lacy panty thong under your blue jeans to feel prettier. Get pierced earrings. You can wear pretty ones at home and only a stud in your left ear when you are out of the house. Masturbate to lesbian porn. In this way, you are blending with society that has the wrong expectations for you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )