If you saw me would you think i was fat?

your body mass index is 31.5
this is in the range called "obese"
I've never seen an obese person that doesn't "look fat"
http://www.aarp.org/health/fitness/info-05-2010/bmi-obese-results.html
you need to lose 10 lbs in order to barely get below obesity and into the range called "overweight"
you would need to weigh about 150 in order to barely reach the range called "healthy". You would look good at 160, and great at 140.

Well, at first I voted yes you are fat...but I saw the picture and I would say you're just a little chubby. I hope you reach your goal!

Lol if that picture is really you then your perfect. Not fat or even a little chunky you really do look good. Theres nothing wrong with you at all and you shouldnt worry about being insecure about that. Cause really like you do look beautiful haha :P

You don't look fat to me. More in the department of people I would cuddle.

You are chubby, but in my opinion you are not fat. Chubby is not unattractive either. I admire that you have lost so much weight and are getting healthy. If you loose too much weight you will look emaciated and sick. I hope you keep your curves and motivation. Good luck!

people feel like shit on the inside if they feel like others think they are fat or ugly. besides, obesity is a health risk.

duddette, I weigh 195 as well, I for one am getting a gut. but you pull it off like a real champ.
if I were in your shoes, I would keep up the good work and keep eating healthy.

i know this must sound mean but i have to see u to judge you.

you look good. Keep up the good work of losing weight. You should probably lose another 30 lbs for health reasons, but you do not look "fat" right now - you look like someone who exercises regularly.

Rock that shit girl! You look just fine :)

Take it off, then I'll tell you

Yes I would think you looked fat.

U spund pretty tall so i ouldnt worrie about ur weight

You are relly relly relly relly relly relly butiful

I think i would have 2 c u 1st silly goose~!!!!!

Youre gonna be considered fat until
You lose another 60 pounds... Sorry to break it to you but In todays society unless youre underweight
Youre fat. Sad but true

I've only done it once

You do seem overweight by your photo. No, you don't look morbidly obese, but yes, you look bigger. You're trying to appear thinner than you are by the way you're standing. I know this because I used to do that too when I was fat. I'm only 5'3", but my top weight was 170 a few years ago. My whole family is bigger, but I was a skinny kid, so I wanted to go back to being comfortable with my weight. So I dropped down to a steady 115-120 through high school and I'm actually at the point where I'm comfortable in a bikini, because it looks so much better than I thought I would. Basically, all I'm saying is that if you *feel* like you're fat, then yes, you probably are fat. My sister is a little taller than you and at 200, she is definitely considered obese. But keep working hard at it and when you feel happy with your body, stop losing. Don't be anorexic, but if you're smart and know your body, you'll know it when you feel like you look great.

http://www.aarp.org/health/fitness/info-05-2010/bmi-obese-results.html
you are considered obese, but your pic looks "just a little chubby". I think your body is attractive.

your not fat nice pic

I didn't see a picture, but I honestly don't really judge in that way and I know I'm not the only person who is that way. If I saw you on the street, I would not assume you were 'fat' or that you were lazy. I'd assume that you are you and you are happy with it, if you aren't, you're fixing it and thats all we can do right? This is just me asuring you, not all people are assholes, not everyone is picking you apart as you walk past, some might, but who gives a damn about them anyway?

you don't look bad. You have 30 mins a day to excercise but need to put more effort into this area cause your currrent program isn't working. 4-5 1 hour high intensity work outs per week could do the trick, you will be looking hot in no time.

When i read the poll, i thought you would be a little fat, but after i saw your picture, you look nowhere near fat. i think you look good :)

nope, not fat. little plump or a little chubby maybe. i say thats a good thing, you look what i call normal, and if you've lost what you say, congrats - you did a hell of a job!

In your picture you just look a little over weight, but I can definitely tell that you have been working hard to lose it. I can see that you have a lot of muscle soon to be showing and I think that if you keep up with the weight watchers and exercising, you will look great in no time! Your weight is beautiful, it's just unhealthy. Never let anyone tell you that you don't look good because you are little heavier than a skinny bitch. Love the skin you're in for the moment and just make sure you always keep your goals in mind.

and based on the comments your getting, and the votes, your not fat

you look ok dont change if yr happy

From the numbers I would have said you would look fat but now I've seen a picture of you I would say you're not even chubby. Well done on how much you've lost by the way, I know you can get to whatever weight you want, let me know how it goes :)

You're not fat, u look great, really attractive. BUT, the one thing to keep in mind is that you are young, and as you get older you don't get any thinner usually. So continue to lose weight. Even though you are athletic, at 5'6 you should not weigh more than 160 lbs.

I was like you - I'm 5'8" male and for years and years i weighed 200 lbs, which is about 50 lbs more than i weighted in college . I worked out all the time, hiked mountains, could bench 300lbs,do 100 push ups in 2 minutes, etc etc. so i didnt think i needed to lose weight.

Now in the last 6 months on advice of my doctor i lost about 30 lbs, and realize i would have been better weighting this much all along. I feel like 200% healthier. I know you already know all this, but that's just my 2 more cents.

I've seen your photo and I think you look perfectly normal. I thought you would've been bigger as my sister is your height and weight but she is 40 and has had children - so her weight is in fat. I agree with the poster who said you look as though you work out. I would know that you were a young girl from your figure and not my sister. Keep up the good work for the sake of your health and self-esteem :o)

Well done :) Your body looks quite toned to me and slimmer than I would've expected (based on the weight). I'm no expert, but it could be because muscles weigh more than fat and your muscle definition looks good.

Just saw your picture and you look great! If anyone calls you fat or even thinks your fat they are retarded. Don't worry about your weight, your fine where you are now

You lost a lot of weight and that is amazing. I say keep it up. From MY perspective you do sound chubby but on your way to having the body of your dreams

well i'd have to c yuh 2 kno if u were fat or not XD!

You're not fat. I consider myself a little chubby, I weight 10 lbs less than you. So I think you are a little chubby but I find your body figure very attractive (from what I just saw). Continue doing your work outs and reach your goal :) Great work!

I don't think you're fat, but wow you lost 51lbs?? Don't worry about your weight, it seems hardly anyone ever is happy with their shape. Learn to be more confident =)

So here's a picture of what I looked like, it's a from the spring when I was about 200lbs but it's still about the same. I won't keep it on long because I think it's kind of weird to just have a picture of your body on your account. :)

Yes you are fat. Nuff said. Else why would u be so concerned? :o

Your BMI is 31.5 which means that you are overweight.

how would i know! I cant see you!

I would