If you have kids some day will their religioun be important to you?

I'm an atheist, and I'm worried about this situation. If I married a Christian I would be totally fine with my children being a Christian as well if they wanted. But I'm worried about having a partner that would be pushy about it or a family that is pushy about it, and that would make the kids go to church and things like that. I'd like them to have both sides of the story, and be able to make their own choices about their faith, which is something many Christians I know would have a problem with...

Yes 22
No 27
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 31 )
  • anti-hero

    As long as they could spell their RELIGION, I would be okay.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TrustMeImLying

    refreshing post. I can't remember the last time I canme across an atheist who wasn't hell-bent on belittling every aspect of religion and spirituality. which is why I avoid associating myself with that label

    for a while I've had the same mindset as yours i.e. giving my kids spiritual freedom regardless of my own beliefs. the only dilemma that's lingered on my mind is: kids = undeveloped minds. while it's good to encourage them to make their own choices, could freedom of choice in something as complex as religion/spirituality be potentially overwhelming? I dont believe in absolute freedom of choice. not everyone can handle it. I've observed countless examples of people who had that freedom and got consumed by it, so to speak.

    this is something that you would want to discuss with the person you end up with. based on my own upbringing, I'm likely to encourage at least a spiritual upbringing in my kids. definitely helps having a grounded/disciplined/strong foundation (and that's considering that everyone's different). once their mind matures they are free to find their own way, no matter what way that is. obviously I still need to give this more thought myself

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • kingofcarrotflowers

      I think you've just known some bad athiests that have left a negative stereotype in your mind, even athiests who are against religion aren't like that, I do actually sometimes womder if the world would be a better place without religion. But I also understand that I have no right to belittle others faith, nor would I want to, or argue with someone over their religion, and that everyone has a right to believe in what they want without feeling like they have to defend that belief from someone else

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • kingofcarrotflowers

        And I think I have a fairly strong opinion when it comes to religion, most of the people I know are atheists but completely fine with religion in every way, its just not what they believe

        Comment Hidden ( show )
    • NeofelisNebulosa

      I loved your response! I honestly didn't think any atheist would ever allow their kids to have a spiritual upbringing... So your response surprised me (and the OP's post did too.)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • TrustMeImLying

        I think more of them could be more accommodating, as long as the basis of their belief is not emotional (i.e. fuck religion because God: didn't give me X // is responsible for all this chaos // did X to someone I loved etc) but instead logical or philosophical. emotional will almost always fuel that spite/revenge towards all religions

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Unimportant

    I'd just play with all the cards on the table.

    I'd say: there are people who believe X, people who believe Y, people who believe Z, et cetera. You can think for yourself and decide what you believe.

    If my child asks me what I believe, I'm going to answer truthfully. But only if they ask me.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • modernism

    I grew up with a ton of different religions around me, without being forced into any one, and I feel like that helped with ultimately allowing myself to be very aware of the options out there.

    I feel like way too often, religion isn't actually a choice - it's just whatever you were born into. It's like showing someone a whole array of different kinds of foods, but telling them they must eat _____ - and when you're young, that really sticks with you.

    Personally, I would simply educate my children about religion itself. Teach them about all the major ones, about what my partner and I believe in, and leave the rest up to them while still giving guidance.

    I'll let them know that when asked the question "what's your religion?", saying, "I don't know yet" is a valid answer.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • normalek

    So many problems because of lame stories written ages ago, and no progress at all....

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Freedom_

    That's an important factor to consider when choosing a mate for marriage, anything to do with raising children is, really. Don't worry too much about it, just communicate openly with your partner about it, observe their example and get to know their family well (or at least how involved they will be in your life) before you decide to settle.

    I'm spiritually open minded and I started talking openly about God to my daughter since she could talk, maybe sooner, but she's only been to church once. She believed in God so readily that it was somewhat uncomfortable for me at times. But she's also kind of questioned God's existence already, which also made me uncomfortable (turns out it was because of the whole God can't be seen thing). If my beliefs were more rigid, teaching her would probably be easier, but they are loosely defined and subject to shift with reason. However, consistency is very important to children, so sometimes you have to fake it a little. I never really wanted to give my daughter the conventional idea of God, but I've had to at times. I try to never give her the idea that I've ever questioned God's existence or that there is any reason to, even though it seems unfair. She will question it on her own soon enough and we'll have some great discussions then. In the meantime, God is a comfort to her, such as when she's afraid during a thunderstorm and prayer is a great way for kids to learn to organize their thoughts/not worry about unnecessary things.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • kingofcarrotflowers

    I'm an athiest and if I ever hypothetically ever had kids I believe it's their choice to believe whatever they want and I'd support that decision 100%, the only time I'd have a problem with it is if a religion is imposed on the child before they have enough cognitive ability to decide for themselves

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • kingofcarrotflowers

      Or if they weren't fine with me being an atheist and tried to convert me, that would get to me, but hopefully I would have been able to have raised the child into someone who is respectful of others opinions and ideals

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • NeofelisNebulosa

    This is one of the reasons I don't want to have children. On one hand, I'm sure my religion would expect me to teach the child about the religion. On the other hand, is that ethical? Is that fair? At what age are children capable of understanding all of the facets of a religion? So I'd rather not have to deal with this difficult decision.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Short4Words

      Your religion?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • NeofelisNebulosa

        Yes, like one of the expectations is that you'll teach your children about it. Or so I've been told. But it kind of takes away the power of choice for the child.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Short4Words

          I was actually just curious about your religion

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • NeofelisNebulosa

            Ohh :P well... I suppose I am a Christian, but I must be a pretty bad one because the behavior of my fellow Christians shames me. I don't go to church anymore either.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • linchpin

    As a nihilist, I understand your predicament and sympathise. We just do the best we can, I suppose.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dahztoyevskeet

    Atheist here. So long as it isn't hurtful to themselves or others, no. I would be disturbed if my kids became fundamentalists of any sort, but I wouldn't make any grand attempts to stifle their religious or philosophical development.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Blackstarxd

    Religion is very important to me so yes I would love for my future husband and kids to have and believe the same faith as me.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • mauritius

    Cualquier religión menos el islam

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Short4Words

    I imagine I would open the conversation up when they're around 8 or 10 and see where they're at, or earlier if they asked about it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Shrunk

    No

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LizardSkin

    Lets be honest if I ever get married and actually have a kid the woman will be deciding everything about the child.

    We're a generation of men raised by women. I'm wondering if another woman is really the answer we need.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • deshikd

      This is so funny.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • LizardSkin

        I want you to hit me.. as hard as you can

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • deshikd

          I'm not much for violence.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • LizardSkin

            Tough crowd. I guess no one has seen the movie "Fight Club."

            Comment Hidden ( show )