Here is the solution to the syria/refugee crisis. what do you think?

Here it goes. (Very idealistic, I know, but why not aim high?)

First, export all civilians from the dangerous regions and place them in a non-overcrowded territory (big fenced place in the Central Asia).

Capture all ISIS-members. Don't harm them, if possible. Measure their radicalization on a scale from 1 to 10. If the radicalization is above 'two', let them go back and establish their caliphate.
Those who are being held there against their will or whose radicalization does not transcend 'two' will join the civilians in Central Asia.

Let all sympathizers of ISIS and their narrative from Europe, Australia, North America and elsewhere go and join the caliphate.

Back to Central Asia. Feed these people facts, facts, facts. Educate them on EVERYTHING. Give them information on reality. Drill common sense into them, if needed.
After a period of that, carefully filter the people from this Central Asian place. Let the sane ones immigrate into whatever country they want. Let the rest go back to the caliphate.

Now there is this caliphate. Do not attack them first, at all. As soon as they will try to invade some other country (kh-khm Israel) - as they inevitably will, since in their minds that is what their prophet expects them to do- annihilate all of them with numerous air-strikes.

Many of the 'Western' refugees will now want to return to their home countries and start building a civilized society. Help them as much as possible. Those who want to stay - it is absolutely fine, too, since they have been filtered and known to be not radicalized.

I am a troll. 5
Bad idea, but still better than the nothing we are doing right now. 7
Good! Let's roll! 2
Good idea, but I have a couple of improving proposals... 1
I don't know enough about the situation to evaluate your proposal. 4
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 8 )
  • AbnormallyAwesome

    Bad idea.
    It includes mass kidnapping, mass imprisonment, mass indoctrination and last but not least: genocide.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Education and facts = mass indoctrination?

      Let's see. What does the IS do?

      Mass kidnapping? Check. Mass imprisonment? Check. Mass indoctrination? Check. Genocide? Check. Additionally: rape, destruction of historic monuments, spread of an insane ideology throughout the world.

      So yeah, my proposal, while subpar, is still an improvement to the status quo.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • AbnormallyAwesome

        The worst reasons to do anything is: "Because THEY do it too."
        There's no point in fighting the IS if we have to become just like them. Life is not a videogame. You haven't won, once you've killed all the bad guys. When you kill masses of people you only give them one more reason to hate us and the next army will rise up. It's not an easy black and white issue and there's no easy solution.

        Some people over here sound much like the hatemongers over there. And many of the kids fighting for IS were probably thinking in a similar way: "We'll be cool action heroes killing all the evil infidels and build a utopia." Then they got over there and realised that reality is way more fucked up.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • You are making it sound as if the IS had a legitimate point of view. Just a difference of opinion, two sides of a coin: people trying to follow a 7th century manuscript to a barbaric society on the one and people trying to prevent them from doing so on the other hand. I don't share that view.

          Are you implying that all of these people are reintegratable into society? You do know that from a certain point of radicalization on it is not possible, right?

          Some people won't sleep until they have dragged the whole world back into the 7th century, and apologists (of whom you seem to be a part) are accomodating their delusions.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • AbnormallyAwesome

            I'm not an apologists. What they do is disgusting. I also think a lot of what America has been doing is disgusting. Not the same, but still horrible. I mean, for f*cks sake, that country uses drones that kill hundret of thousands of civilans and children. How fucked up is that?
            A lot of people from a lot of countries deserve to die. Should we kill them all? We better kill ourselves the next day.
            But all ethics aside, even from a purely strategic point of view, your plan makes no sense. Because as I said, you can't kill hate. The next wave of damaged psychopaths would rise up who hate you even more.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • thegypsysailor

    Why on earth would you let a single member of ISIS (IS) live, if you had them all rounded up?
    Have you forgotten the atrocities they have committed against perfectly innocent civilians AND historic archaeological antiquities?
    Every single one of these madmen and women must be eradicated from the face of this planet with no more care than taking out the garbage. They are truly monsters, every bit as horrific as the Nazis.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • D'lirium

    Kill everyone. :3

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • flyingnostalgia

    Why central asia and not usa? ...i mean it would be easier if they were in usa cus they are more civilized, intelligent, ethical people there then in any other place on earth. ....dont you think?

    Comment Hidden ( show )