Have wanted to f**k my sister for years, still do

OK, I need feedback on what to do here. For about 7 years I have really wanted to f**k my sister. We used to play games with eachother all the time, and I think she wants me to f**k her too, but I am not sure. Things started out as her just sitting in my lap or watching a movie with me and stuff. Then we started cuddling, etc. Eventually it would be kind of a ritual where she would come in my room and I would rub her back and kiss on her and we would talk sweet to eachother. She eventually started asking me to come say goodnight to her and we would do this sh*t. It was a big tease, really. BTW, she is 4 years younger then I am, so she is now 18. But back then she was like 11 when I was 14, and things were most intense when she was 16 and I was 20. Anyway, I used to watch her in the shower and jack off to her. She knew about it I think, and used to kind of enjoy it. Eventually the cuddling at night led to me rubbing her legs and up to her ass and pussy. She would pretend to be asleep the whole time, but I know she was awake. But I never just f**ked her. Now, about a year ago, she basically had a mental breakdown. She and I discussed our relationship, talked about how our family was insane and how we thought this had led to what had happened. However, throughout this entire ~coming to terms~ with one another (and it was good natured, not resentful) she adamently denied every actually having interest in me. My question is this. 1: do you think she's full of sh*t? 2: I still want to f**k her. But now she has a boyfriend. Should I still try to f**k her?
Feedback appreciated. Particularly from girls who can give insight into the psychology of what she's thinking

Voting Results
68% Normal
Based on 473 votes (324 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 29 )
  • hazeltopping

    Ye maybe she did like it when she was younger, when she was still exploring new emotions, and discovering the opposite sex and its pleasures. BUT she is over this now, and it is well obvious from the fact that she spoke to you about it. I think your just very horny, and taking on the first opportunity. Shes over it, you have to get over it too. Just find someone else to do it with. Please, I think you need to leave her alone, and move on.
    Good luck

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • darkprince

    OMG your a sick fuck.. she was 11 no way she wanted u to screw her..

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • It sounds to me like you had a serious talk and she said she didnt want to. Maybe she might really but you missed your chance Id say

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • spidzeedoo

    I'm impressed with the responses you have gotten so far. Was expecting to have everyone telling you you should be burned at the stake or something. Look, it sounds like you had a rough childhood. Dysfunctional family and what not. I think that if it were going to happen (and probably a good thing it didn't happen) that it would have happened when you were much younger and in bed rubbing on her while she pretended to be asleep. You, for whatever reason, didn't fuck her then and now she is not interested. I think that given she is in a really fragile situation mentally.. and sounds like you might be also.. that its a good thing and that you just kinda move on. But yet at the same time don't let it come between you to where its awkward for you to have a normal relationship. Fall in love with someone you're not related to. Good luck with everything.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Millermiller<3

    That's disgusting.... How could you think of your sister that way!!! And how could she like it!!?? That's sick you guys are supposed to treat each other like family not sex partnersO.o

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • abadboy

    Mate i ALWAYS want to FUCK my sister

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • youngman71

      is she agree

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • fiveoneseven

    um well i really don't think its a big deal that you jacked off to her but in the shower is a little to much and the touching and everything and really wanting to fuck her i have to say no

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • BadMood23

    This is the most revolting story i have ever heard! DO NOT DO IT! It's madness. You need to take care of your sister not to try to bang her. Make a strictful decission not to do such a thing with her and you'll pass this dilemma. If you keep this thing up, i'm sorry to say but, you'll regret it till the last day of your life! DO NOT DO IT!!!!!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • stinky55

    The statement you made "She adamently denied every actually having interest in me". That should tell you how she feels. You can ask. But be prepared for the let down.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TheBlowjobArtist

    Babe it looks u left it to late hunny bun why didn't ya fuck her a few years ago bub xx

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Severus_Hiro

    I've completed extensive research in the field of human sexual psychology.. Cognitive science is kind of my hobby. It's normal to want your sister-- biologically, you're pretty much supposed to.

    Now, courtship and romance is another matter entirely! While I have a lot of experience with this, I think you should just trust your instincts. (Yes, hands-on experience. I'm not a total nerd).

    I should also add that I can relate to this personally. I have a sister, she's seven years older than I am. (I turn fifteen this December.. our age difference can vary.)

    We've never had sex, but we both want to. We decided that It would be better to wait until I'm eighteen, because that's when It would be legal. I live in Ohio, so I can do it without worrying.

    We make out a lot, and there's some cuddling, too. Whenever she can come over, she always brings something sexy to wear. (She just wears it under her normal clothes, so our parents can't see. And also so that I can rip her normal clothes off!)

    My advice? Again, if you're good at this sort of thing, you should try to romance her first. It depends on how mature she is.. Definitely wait until you're sure she's into you, too. Then fuck her.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Cheerleader1040

    She wants to b fuc'ed

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Mattteach

    Go for it!!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Alex_Gee

    Yeah I have to agree with the general opinion and say that I think u missed your opportunity to take it further a few years ago. I think your sister is in a fragile place right now and yeah, I also think that shes probably bullshitting you about her feelings. She wont be able to know whats right and wrong right now and she definitely wont want to admit to wanting to have sex with u if she's feelling any guilt about stuff. However I also see where u are coming from and I know it must be frustrating. I dont think talking about it is gonna get u an answer so I have a solution but I'd rather u message me and I'll chat privately. Either way, when u get your answer, u have to respect her and back off if she isn't interested. At least that way you'll have a fantasy to cling on to and that wont harm anyone. Msg me though! Ax

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • 3timesbiggerthenu

    I fucked 4 of my sisters and sucked 2 of my brothers

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • EdWall234

    You and your sister were curious back then. Her being your first sexual experience is probably why you are still hooked to her; she isn't interested because she's got a boyfriend and has realised that there's plenty of other guys to fuck. Follow her lead and find another intimate partner.

    P.S If you're still having trouble just go for someone that resembles her.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • hotty123

    fuck her

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Zapoix

    Its not that descusting
    Like the egyption queen cleopatera did this and she was the most famous and powerfull person of her era

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • alf2010

    Fuck her and forget about it or let me fuck her and you lose out on great sex.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • billyboy

    I'm from the South, btw. My advise is do NOT try to fuck her. She has had a breakdown. She is damaged goods. You can only make things worse for the both of her if you try to push sex on her now, Ordinarily, I am not opposed to a little incest, as long as no one gets hurt. I think you could hurt your sis a LOT, and thereby hurt your own self too, by pushing sex on a sick girl. So beware!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Anthonyw17

      I agree

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • heather49

    I'm a girl...
    and I found it Hot... XP

    I actually had fantasies like that with cousins (not my brother, 'cus I don't like him XP) (even so I've dreamed with him too 'XP).

    Even so, I agree that at the age of 11... it's not impossible, but very not probable that she wanted it.
    I meen, at that age most of the girls don't even know what is female masturbation, and she probably inocently thought that if you weren't doing sex with her, then it was ok.

    (Maybe I'm saying this too late 'cus you hasked two years ago, but oh well XP)

    Maybe now that she've grown up, and is more conscious of what you have been doing to her she is some kind of repulsed or confused.
    And maybe that comes from she having a boyfriend, who more than enyone may've introduced that theme to her.

    Don't force those things to her please, then it will become more complicated.
    I agree with hazeltopping, when she said "Ye maybe she did like it when she was younger, when she was still exploring new emotions, and discovering the opposite sex and its pleasures."

    I don't know what kind of relation you have exacly, but, if it is that open and stuf... maybe you should think of opening talking to her you wanted for that long time to fuck her.

    From one side she will be repulsed I think, but from the other maybe she will melt a bit I think...

    Is your sister that inocent? :P
    It's a thing that probably can be better understood due her personality :P

    I don't know if your going to have a chance to f*ck her, but maybe talking with her wouldn't bring that much problems...

    GOOD LUCK FOR YOU!!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Anthonyw17

      Do you have a brother?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • james3918

    I would say that this really isn't normal. Most people don't have incest related fantasies. However, if you guys ever do have sex, and its consensual, then to each his own man. Whatever makes you guys happy.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • faisoly

    lol

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TheBeastlyBurrito

    Fondle with her in her sleep lol

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • phillipphung94

    I'm willing to bet you are from the south.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • redcomb

    I don't think you should have sex with her. If it gets out, you WILL go to prison. As far as "revolting" as one histrionic poser said, ni99er, please! Our bodies don't know about morality. You will literally have to endure the suffering of wanting something you CAN'T HAVE yet. And I know this will sound like bullsh*t but when you get to heaven, all your dreams come true. They HAVE to so you can advance even further past them. It's just a cosmic law.

    Comment Hidden ( show )