Girls: reaction to unattractive male's moves on you?

Girls, how would you react if a not-very-handsome guy tried to strike up a conversation with you? I feel that the time has come for me to approach a member of the opposite sex (not necessarily in a flirtatuous manner), but I am afraid of what rejection would do to my self-esteem. Just trying to get an idea of what reactions to expect. Please answer as honestly (even if that means brutally) as possible, and base your answer on past incidents if possible.

I'd try to ignore him. 6
Other. 4
"Sorry, you're not in my league." *tosses hair* 2
I'd leave as quickly as possible. 3
I'd jeer at him. 1
I'd smite him with the palm of my hand. NOT INTERESTED! 1
I'd feel flattered, and willingly start a conversation. 22
I'd respond coldly, making it obvious that I do not wish to talk. 11
I'm a guy who didn't want to tamper with the results. 23
I'd try to look past his appearance and give him a chance. 25
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 51 )
  • A couple weeks ago I was sitting in a lounge area at the college and there were two physically unattractive boys sitting there as well. We all struck up a conversation like it was no big deal. I knew nothing about them and am nice enough to give nearly everyone a chance. No one is really "beneath" me and I think anyone who doesn't want to simply talk to someone physically unattractive is kind of a stuck up bitch.

    On the flip side, another unattractive guy came and talked to me. I had seem him around the campus and knew he was just a strange guy, so I probably appeared very disinterested in our conversation because his personality was off putting.

    Just be confident. I cannot tell you how critical confidence is. Conversations are a million times better when the guy is confident and very likable, and physical appearance matters little. Just be hygienic and seem approachable.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • randomperson1000000

      Confidence doesn't come easily for everyone. When you suffer from social anxiety, developing confidence may be as hard as a dyslexic person studying shakespeare, for example. Or, if you've been rejected a lot, it's hard to feel comfortable reaching out to a girl you don't know real well. And, of course the media doesn't help either. But, thank you for giving an honest and thorough answer. Hopefully, I'm in the minority here.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • VirgilManly

        I'm a man with Manly advice...

        Try starting brief conversations with girls just for the sake of starting a conversation, passing the time. Like in check out lines or whatever. Forget about trying to get a date or getting laid. If it makes it easier to begin with maybe start talking to girls who aren't beauty queens.
        Talk about ANYTHING! (Ok, maybe not sexually graphic stuff, kidnappings, dismemberment, ax murders, etc...)

        You'll get to find out just from that if you have any chemistry between you, if anything 'clicks'. Sometimes ordinary girls become more attractive while others seem to become less hot or appealing. If you are compatible on a friendly level then things just naturally flow. Good luck.

        PS- If a women just won't talk to you, Fuck it...it's her loss now move on.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • randomperson1000000

          But, even with small talk, I still predict that rejection will follow. Now, if it's all in my head, then that's my own problem. But, if she does have the audacity to not only reject me, but judge me harshly, then I hope for karma's sake that she gets hurt by whatever asshole she chooses to associate with instead.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
      • cuppycake1228

        It may help your confidence to improve your appearance in any way you can. Get a haircut, buy a new outfit or pair of shoes, try a good cologne that women like (ask friends if you aren't sure which to pick). Even the smallest change can refresh your outlook and help you radiate the confidence you know is in there! Good luck!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
      • You are right, being confident can be very difficult. I am just saying that it is a valuable trait to have when approaching the opposite gender! I agree with cupcake, you can always improve your looks if you are not satisfied physically.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • cuppycake1228

    A few months ago I met a guy (through work) and we hit it off personality-wise from the very start. He expressed a romantic interest in me, but I wasn't physically drawn to him...yet there was clearly chemistry. Sexual chemistry can exist without a physical attraction. Anyway, we've spent a lot of time together over the last 3 months and are now dating. I don't care that he isn't "hot" by popular standards, because he is incredibly talented, smart, funny, romantic, and amazing in bed. Because of these things, he's *become* more physically attractive to me. He tells me every day that I'm the most beautiful woman he's ever met and that he's the luckiest man alive. I know he will always treat me well.

    Moral, ladies: give the underdog a chance. Happiness could be just around the corner for you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Satanic_Cereal

      The trouble is, your last statement "ladies: give the underdog a chance." I've never heard the reverse-"Guys, give unattractive girls a chance." Though it's good that you're happy with your personal relationship. But the pressure to see past someone's looks, seems to be mostly on women. Which you reflect by directing your comment toward ladies.

      I think people enjoy it both ways: Sometimes we enjoy our desire of a person's looks (along with his/her personality). And sometimes, we enjoy seeing past the looks, enjoying other things about a person.
      ----Some people enjoy the prior, more than the latter (and vice versa). Perhaps many folk want to experience both... and explore/ experiment.

      It's unfair to women, to cut off half their experience, and expect them to rarely/never enjoy male beauty (visual)- while men are free to enjoy their sexuality either way.... Even if an agreed-on morale is posed as the reason; that it's honorable to see past a person's looks.

      Also, society cultures women to appeal to men, visually. But not vice versa. Most men are not attractive (they cut their hair too short, grow lots of facial hair, etc). So there's an imbalance that forces women to settle for less. (I can rarely find a guy I'm attracted to, no matter how often I search). Whether we're attracted more to personality, looks, or both-- is more about each person exploring what they enjoy. Rather than a set of rules telling us how we're supposed to feel.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • green_boogers

        For the record, I'm a tactile guy. Attractiveness is secondary. I want a woman with a wonderful sense of touch. This includes kissing. And, I have found that a few of you (<10%) are so good that you light up the night.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • worriedgirlhere

    Dude. Making friends with anyone who is nice/awesome is the best.

    A rule or saying I go by is: "We can be friends, as long as you do not act better than anyone else."

    Who's to say anyone is better? Fuck that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Razaa

    Whenever ugly guys hit on me I just tell them I have a BF then leave so I don't hurt their feelings.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Shrunk

    i'm not picky when it comes to appearance. if they have a good personality it can make up for a lot, from my experience. i would definitely listen to what he has to say, as i do with any person.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Satanic_Cereal

    Op, I know what makes guys attractive, if you'd like me to share:

    Almost all (*ALL*) guys need to grow their hair out a few inches, in order to be attractive. People desire eachother visually- based on our instincts, which tell how healthy a person looks. We see signs of a health in the skin, teeth, hair, etc. 99% of guys eliminate this by cutting their hair too short. Instead, grow your hair down to your ears at least. Or longer.

    Keep long hair neat, not messy. Don't grow too much facial hair (or any. It looks messy & hides the face. Thin goatee at most). Long hair looks good with every clothing fashion, and every personality. A few other things help in being attractive, but long hair is the biggest factor.

    Being rejected is no big deal, either. If I'm not attracted to a guy who approaches me--- I would chat with him politely, or view him as a friend. If one person is not interested in you, then somebody else might be (trial and error). Except some people do make it awkward/ respond rudely. I've hit on guys, and I've been rejected. I usually hit on strangers at bars- though not everyone likes doing that. In such case, if they're rude, or I embarrass myself, I may not have to see them again.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • DumBelle

      What? I find this comment incredibly relative. As "long hair" and facial hair are not entirely going to make any guy more attractive to me. My personal taste is short hair, spiked and no facial hair. But even then, the most attractive guys I have dated, could have had long hair and some facial hair OR short hair and fully shaved, they would still look great, because physically, they were just incredibly attractive and there wasn't any specific look they needed to abide by. As someone who did modeling for a long time, I dated plenty of my peers from a shoot, so yes they were attractive to me and my "type", but it doesn't mean an unattractive guy somehow would be just as good looking, lacking the built bodies, great physical features etc that they did. Of course beauty is relative, but there are groups of people who the majority find attractive. No matter what. Good genetic build, is simply good genetics and the efforts people with them impose is also effective.

      Not to say my 3 longest relationships were with the attractive men. My longest relationships were all with people who were my type personality wise, smart, could make me laugh and we had a multitude of things in common. All of the guys I chose to date were deemed "not good enough" for me, which enraged me, because people, my friends etc based this fact they conjured up, on looks alone. Even though I loved the relationships, the person, their personalities and intelligence more and really didn't, and still do not, hold looks to some higher standard of someone's worth. I always give everyone a chance if there are base things we have in common and personality traits I adore. Had the "less attractive" men NOT had been as funny, confident, intelligent, fun to be around, had things in common with me, or simply were awkward, there's no way I would have ever dated them. It all comes down to how you present yourself and how enjoyable of a time one can have with you. The best looking guys were NOT "assholes, douchebags", they were just boring, or not my type, intellectually/personality wise. That holds a ton on weight for me. Ultimately, I want to be happy with who I am with.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • I appreciate your advice, but there's only so far a long, flowing mane can take you. My hair is pretty long by today's standards anyway. I have never really considered approaching complete strangers for the purpose of flirting. As you said, though, it does limit the potential damage inflicted by rejection.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Satanic_Cereal

        Ok. Well, good luck either way. (yeah I guess long hair is not the only good quality. It's just what most guys lack, so I made assumptions, sorry) Hope it goes well.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KeddersPrincess

    I'd be nice to him but let him know I'm not interested.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • smallboobies:(

    It makes me feel like im ugly if the guy may think im the only girl in he's league. Yeah thats a pretty messed up way of thinking, I know, still thats how I view it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Fair enough. I'd probably feel the same to be honest.
      Would you say that the unofficial hierarchy of 'leagues' is based entirely on appearance, or do other factors come into play?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • (s)aint

    I turn them down by replying shortly/disinterested. They probably approach me because they fancy me and I am sorry to say that looks matters a lot to me, then I have different types that I'm attracted to, of course.

    But say a less attractive guy approached me and commented on my band merchandise, OF COURSE I talk to him because he started to talk about something that actually interests me.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

      You like my merch? I got it a hot topic. I am so unique and cool.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • (s)aint

        ... I meant music related-merch.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

          That's what they sell.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • (s)aint

            How should I know? I'm Swedsh!

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

              Ignorance of the law isn't an excuse to break the law young lady.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
    • cuppycake1228

      I hope none of my male friends ever run into you, because I would feel sorry for them. Looks aren't everything, and hot guys tend to be assholes because they *know* they look good and therefore think they don't have to try as hard.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Satanic_Cereal

        I disagree. She can prefer guys based on their looks, if she wants to. Nobody tells guys they'd better not desire pretty girls. Since guys do like pretty girls, why can't girls like guys the same? According to what (s)aint said, her theoretical response is not rude or mean. She simply wants them to know she's not interested.

        Nobody should pressure a gal (nor guy) to be attracted to someone (who she's not attracted to). That's like pressuring a gay man to date women. People cannot help what turns them on and what does not. There isn't really a "right" or "wrong" for what attracts a person. Especially for women, who often have such pressure on their sexuality. You say hot guys tend to be assholes, but why is that a girl's fault? Just for being attracted to a good-looking guy? I hear many guys want girls who are *both* attractive, and nice. Why can't girls want guys the same?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • (s)aint

          Thanks! You nailed it. I would of course not date a hot guy if he was an ass and I obviously do have some different types. I would actually say that I have MORE requirements for their personality and sexual preferences than their looks. If a guy isn't into the same thing that I am, that is a dealbreaker.

          I also think that it's bullshit to say that all good looking guys are ass-holes ...

          Comment Hidden ( show )
      • (s)aint

        So? I'm a REALLY tall girl and I sometimes meet guys that reaches BENEATH my breasts ... I'm sorry, but I can't deal with that. Neither am I interested in obese/well built men because I know that I look good and if someone approaches me because they think that I look good ... why Can't I reject them for not liking their appearance?

        I was with an obese guy for over four years because I fell for his personality and not his looks ... I felt nothing when I saw him naked .... But my current BF looks AMAZING naked. Knowing how ... wondrous I feel inside when I see him naked I'd never date someone who couldn't take care of their looks again.

        This said, I would NOT have dated him if I had not loved his personality too ...

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • shuggy-chan

          pfft your not tall to everyone. Humph

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • (s)aint

            Haha :P 185 cm , taller than a lot of guys and to many short guys I'm their wet dream >>

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • shuggy-chan

              m like 191cm i think, or whatever 6'3" is. but wet dreams huh, im sure you are. but wet from what is the question lol =P

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • LizardSkin

    Lol at the top answer. Liars. Unless you aren't very easy on the eyes yourself.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • wistfulmaiden

    You can be attractive or even sexy without being good looking.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • MissDethstar

    Of course I would talk to him. When people talk to me either because they think i'm pretty or have an interesting personality I am flattered. It doesn't mean I have to end up in hes bed or even dating him. Why would I refuse having a conversation with somebody because hes not my type ? Might be a great friend at least.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • loopoo

    I'd chat to him.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

    You sad people, summing people up on physical appearance. How about getting to know someone for who they really are?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Satanic_Cereal

      Is this a reaction to my comment? You ought to read my other two comments above, for explanation.

      I'll cheer, as well, for people who prefer to appreciate their lovers' personality, more than appearance. But that does not mean it's fair to pressure women to never desire male (visual) beauty. Read my reply to cuppycake1228.
      I said people enjoy both appearance, *and* personality. But rules don't dictate which one a person must enjoy more- (people cannot help what they're attracted to. Romance/sexuality is for enjoyment, not rules).

      And I gave OP advice on appearance, in case he (or any other reader) wanted it. With too many gals making themselves pretty for guys, there ought to be guys who do the same. Even if you think it's superficial, it's still sexist. But my advice was not to pressure OP specifically. I don't socially outcast people for not being pretty. But, just because a girl can't help be unattracted to certain guys, does not mean she's "summing him up on physical appearance." Just like a gay man who's not attracted to a woman, does not mean he's rude for making assumptions about her gender.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

        If it was for you specifically, I would have replied to you directly. I understand the basics of a comment section.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Satanic_Cereal

          Ok, I'll stop bitching at you. Pretend my comment was somewhere else, rather than in your thread.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

            I'm not much for pretending.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
    • shortandtothepoint

      It's in human nature to search for the genetically strongest partner. Pleasant facial features are percieved as being a sign of good health, so it makes sense that they matter to most people.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • WokeUpScreamingFilmNoir

        Evolve your mind. We are not cavemen.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • DumBelle

          This is pretty much a moronic statement. Evolve your mind, we are not cavemen? Contrary to what people would like believe, we will always be "human" with innate responses/desire for the best possible person to "mate" with. Being attracted to another person will always be uncontrollable, as to who/why you're attracted to someone. Based on first impressions, lacking any knowledge as to what someone's personality entails.
          But attraction in terms of "dating", who you choose to engage in longer term commitments with, is much different. There are plenty of people the majority will always have an uncontrollable desire for, based on looks alone, but for most, the attraction and desire can subside, given the person can not be your type emotionally/personality wise, or just have generally unappealing factors, to them. Yet that still doesn't change the fact that this "type" of person would have a good majority's attention based on a first glance/receive the first pick in terms of opportunity, to get to know them better etc.

          Attraction is human nature, it will always be. This doesn't mean one is living like a caveman, so to speak, or not evolved, mentally. It just makes one human. It's funny when looks comes into play, online, because everyone wants to simply sound the most righteous in their responses, with a "Look past looks, like I do", attitude. Which is not only a sanctimonious attitude (as everyone is "guilty", if you want to call it that) of being attracted to someone incredibly good looking, sexually. Of course factors can change the outlook, ultimately, if the person has internally unappealing traits, but it doesn't change the fact that given the opportunity, most would attempt to court this "type" of person, whether sexually or engage in conversation. Based on looks alone.
          It's easy to sound like a incredibly moral/appropriate person online, or if one only has the means of dating unconventionally attractive people, only, due to their own looks. But it does not make it true or correct, everyone wants the BEST they can possibly attain. Everyone. If THEY claim otherwise, they are the ones' lying. Nobody wants 30% or less, looks, 70% compatible. Even 10% looks, 90% compatible. Everyone would like the best of both worlds, if they can attain that. 100% in the "looks" department, 100% compatible with you. It's not as complex as people like to make it, for the sake of debate or sounding so incredibly moral/having the best responses or attitude.

          Comment Hidden ( show )