Girls could you ever see this guy the same way?

alright let me give a little background. your best friends with a guy for years like seven years. you and this guy are extremely close you can trust eachother and tell one another your deepest darkest secrets. your always there for one another if one of you has a problem or whatever. you spend most of your time hanging out together laughing and having fun you know normal best friend stuff. recently however the guy comes out tells you that he has very strong feelings for you. how would you react? would your friendship be altered by this?

im obviously the guy in this situation and even though i got shot down and my heart broken i still value my friendship with girl very much even knowing that we will never connect on the romantic level i desire so much. im just worried she feels awkward around me now and i ruined the most meaningful friendship i have ever had. its only been a few days and we still have been haning out together and having fun. i want to know how she feels on the inside though its all i can think about. does she feel awkward? does she think the only reason we were friends was because i feel this way about her? i love this girl both way as a man and as a friend. like i said i am so happy just being her friend but im worried she wont want to be.

Voting Results
86% Normal
Based on 22 votes (19 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 22 )
  • derpyderp

    Going to play devils advocate here but for good reason.
    I've been in a similar position, albeit a very long time ago now.

    I can see what you're saying about this being a meaningful friendship, especially after such a long time, but can you really just turn off your feelings for her?
    Personally I doubt it...

    Can you be around this girl often, as only a friend, without being eaten up inside when you see her date someone else, without feeling personally wronged when someone breaks her heart?

    To me the question is, is this friendship important enough that you're willing to die inside a little to continue it, knowing it will never become more?
    Very dramatic wording I know but anyone who's been there can probably relate.

    If you can turn off your feelings or you are willing to suffer for this girls friendship then more power to you...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • don't get me wrong during the course of our friendship i have been with girls and had feelings for them but whenever that would end i would find my self falling for my friend again.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • what did you do in your similar situation? do you regret your decision?

      actually i have had these feelings while she dated someone else it hurt more then anything at first! but we spent way less time together we remained just as close i didn't see her as often. that made me lose some of the feelings for her. but now i don't have as much of a reason not to see her and i don't want her to get the idea that i don't want to be friends i only wanted sex. does that make any sense?

      yes my friendship with her is worth more to me than anything else in the world. you just can't help who you love i guess?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • NeuroNeptunian

      Here's my question, having been the girl in this scenario albeit a very long time ago now :P

      What the fuck should I do if I recognize that going on? Try to build distance? Try to cut him off completely? Should I have just held out for his feelings to fade off? Because I built the distance...

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • derpyderp

        There's no easy answer to that unfortunately.
        The guy is likely to be hurt no matter what, the important thing is it isn't your fault as long as you haven't been leading the guy on.

        Really its up to him to get his shit straight but I'm guessing your situation either made things awkward or you didn't want him teasing himself, hence the distance?

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • thegypsysailor

    One of the first posts I responded to was similar to this. I responded that it's almost impossible for guys and gals to have and maintain a close friendship over time, as love almost always rears it's ugly head. You would have thought I was advocating the wholesale slaughter of cute little puppies.
    But here it is a year and some months later and this is almost word for word the same post, and there have been hundreds of others in the interim.
    So, I will say it again, at the risk of once again being castigated by one and all; guys and gals can rarely if ever maintain an extremely close friendship without one or the other falling in love. Isn't that actually a normal thing? Wouldn't you want your romantic involvement to be with your best friend?
    OP, you've been given good advice above. I would only add that I hope you have learned from this situation, and won't make the same mistakes again. Perhaps you can rekindle this friendship when you are both married, but until then, I believe things will not be terribly comfortable for either of you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • davesumba

    As long as you completely drop your feelings for her, and don't make it awkward yourself, there should be no difference in the friendship. Just talk to her like you always had.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KeepsakeDoll

    Have a similar situation to yours.

    I still think of him as a great guy and it didn't affect our friendship at all.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • thank you that really makes me happy

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • deepthought33

    I know this is very pessimistic of me and I hate going this route and I don't know either of you at all, but my concern is that she LIKES you in this role. You love her, she knows it, you'll have her back on her back-burner while she eats all the cake.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • i thought that to myself once before. knowing her as well as i do though i doubt she would do that shes not like that

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • deepthought33

        That's good. I'm glad and I hope the best for you.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • thank you very much

          Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Darkoil

    Rookie mistake pal. You have been in the friend zone for 7 years and you decide to tell her you have romantic feelings for her, what the fuck?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • better out then in! i didn't want to spend the rest of my life thinking what if. even though i kind of still knew what was gonna happen.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Darkoil

        Yeah you test the water first, not jump head first in, you silly Billy.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • trust me i tried i tested the water in every way i could think of she didn't seem to get the hint then it just slipped out in a moment of weakness i do feel stupid about it kind of wish i didn't tell her but so far so good were still talking and whatnot everything seems to be normal but i want her point of view

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Darkoil

            Does she have any girl friends you could secretly ask? they are the proverbial goldmine when it comes to finding out a girls true feelings.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • kelili

    I wonder how dark a secret can be? I always hear people talking about dark secrets/

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • more just an expression for embarrassing stuff and whatnot just away of making it sound a little bad ass

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • cumm_guzzlah

    awww I'm so sorry.. this kinda broke my heart. I'd say just be up front with her and let her know that you care about her on a deep level and it's so much more than superficial and THAT is why, but first and foremost you care about her for her, and if you only remain friends that's just fine, but that you just don't wanna lose her friendship that is the most meaningful you've ever had. THAT would be the true tragedy!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • sulli94

    i'd be ok with hanging out but i probably will avoid as much physical contact as possible, stop having deeper conversations with you, and avoid doing anything that would possibly make me look attractive in any way (such as bending down and my butt in full show). but that is all with the idea that i also want to keep the friendship. and this also depends on the girl... some girls are completely fine with it and will joke around about it later, some will wish it never happened and try to steadily make things go back to how they were. i advise you to never mention it again while the whole situation is still raw in your minds. i suggest you also do like the later example and just avoid any "sticky situations" and anything physical, or just you two being alone. If she hasn't talked about it though then she might still be thinking about what you said while trying to make things back to normal between you too. Honestly, I doubt she even expected that after you two being so close you would find anything attractive about her. You could very well have been bro-zoned, and the thought of being together could have made her feel gross, as if some sort of pseudo-insestual thing would happen. Or she could have had slight feelings of deeper affection for you too, and now that you were surprisingly the first one to admit it, she doesn't know how to react. You might just wanna tough it out and ask her how she feels if it's already been a whole week. But make sure your timing is appropriate, so not while you two are eating a dinner or something, because that could end pretty nasty. Just be casual man, casual. And don't cry about it if she says no. At least not until you get home. If she says no, ok then, just continue your day doing whatever you guys do when you hang out. yes? then good 4 u man. GOODLUCK!

    Comment Hidden ( show )