Eating dirty pie made by the dirty pie man

I had a hypothetical conversation with a friend the other day about what either one of us would or would not eat. My friend called me a germaphobe and said that he would not place a bunch of restrictions on what he would or would not eat like I do. So I posed a question for him. What if he had a car mechanic friend who loved to bake as a hobby. Every time he came across his mechanic friend at the shop, the guy would smell like piss, have pitch black dirt under his fingernails and a least a week's worth of beard stubble on his face. He would also have other funky body odors attached to him. Let's say that my friend loves pie. Especially apple! His mechanic friend knows this. One day, when my friend visits the garage to drop off his car to be repaired, this mechanic/baker has a surprise for him. He has baked him an apple pie! My question for my friend was: "Would you really eat that pie or would you throw it into the trash can at your first opportunity?" He responded that he would eat it because he was sure that his friend would wash his hands and use common sense sanitary measures when baking the pie. He also stated that all the germs would have been killed off during the baking process anyway. What do you think? Would you eat that pie if it were gifted to you? My answer, if you haven't guessed already, is HELL NO.

I would love to eat that pie!! 22
I would eat the pie if I didn't have dietary restrictions about it. 12
I don't know. 15
Are you fucking kidding me? Of course I would not eat that pie!! 34
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 14 )
  • honestlyweird

    ITS FREAKING PIE AND THERES FREAKING KIDS STARVING IN NICARAGUA. EAT DAT SHIT.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • disthing

      Or mail that shit.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Hmmaybe

    He clearly touched the pie after baking so it if his hands were dirty then that's bacteria and viruses straight back on that pie.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • thatsfunnyshit

    I live by the "never eat another mans pie" rule. It has served me well thus far, except that one time.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • casualcrow

    Seriously, you're assuming that he was dirty while baking the pie at home. All those things you added about smelling bad, and grease on his shirt and all that, has nothing to do with his baking habits at home.

    Also, how would he hand you the pie? is it covered in plastic or at least in a box or something? obviously if he touched the actual pie with his bare hands then no, i wouldn't eat it. But if its covered in foil or plastic, i would assume he made it at home and covered it before bringing it to work with him, which is fine.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Jweezee

      Just a handfull of pie

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • disthing

    I'd want to know what the dirty man expected in return for the pie...

    My body can't be bought with pastry treats, my friend.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • derpyderp

    I'm a mechanic & if you came past my shop you would most likely find me covered in grease, dirt, etc with a weeks worth of stubble (by the way what does that have to do with ANYTHING?)& probably smelling SLIGHTLY of BO (but not piss) if I've been working hard enough or it's hot weather. Believe it or not but, when I'm at home (which is where I assume the above hypothetical mechanic baked the pie...) I am generally clean unless working around the house.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Narutofan

    Maybe if he cleaned up before baking the pie and was clean when giving the pie.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • bubber

    I'd feed it to a cat.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • I don't want to get sick so,'No'.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • wigsplitz

    If people only knew what they consumed....

    No sense getting worked up over it. The mechanic would've driven your car around thereby touching the steering wheel, gearshift and doorhandles at the very least....so, say you pick up the car and then stop at a drive thru and grab something to eat? You're eating his germs.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • If people only knew what they consumed....

      What 'are' people consuming?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • wigsplitz

        google it.

        Comment Hidden ( show )