Can you consider racism intelligent to any degree?

Please read carefully before responding!!

I am NOT taking ANY side as far as racism goes. I am merely posing a question, so please, avoid assuming I am condoning racism. This is not personal, I am just collecting opinions.

I am asking, do you think that racism can be intelligent to any degree. I'll elaborate....

-If a person is racist because of repeated bad experiences with a certain race, is that at all intelligent? Humans are not objects obviously, but I'm going to make this analogy anyway. If you go to a store and 9 times out of 10, the meat you buy is found to be rancid, you'd probably stop buying meat at that store, right? So can the same reasoning be applied to people in general? Perhaps not as an absolute, but as a general 'caution' when dealing with certain types of people you've had bad experiences with?

-Do you find a difference in racism that is taught and racism that is 'acquired'? Meaning, if two black parents teach their black child that white people are the devil...vs...a black child that is continuously abused by white people, is there a difference in your opinion? Is one OK and the other not OK? Is it even just remotely OK to have a reasonable acquired racism?

-Now, I'm not saying that these are absolute rules to be applied to everyone, I am just asking if a degree of racism, based on experiences with any given race, can be used as a cautionary measure when dealing (or NOT dealing) with certain people.

-Can racism be compared at all to something like a credit report?

-Have you ever had a racist feeling, and were either proven to be right about your assumption and were served well by being cautious, or proven wrong and felt like an ass? Please comment!!

No, it's NEVER right to be racist. 35
I don't know? 8
Yes, racism can be intelligent. 22
I'll just comment. 2
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 11 )
  • PumpkinKate

    Intelligent people would realize that the source of their frustration comes not from a certain race, but from a certain subculture or scenario.

    I don't think it's racist to have repeated bad encounters with say, black people wearing do-rags listening to hip-hop and hanging out around your parked car in a sketchy part of town while smoking pot, and then to avoid that situation as best as you can. That's common sense. I apologize if it *sounds* racist, but the point has nothing to do with race. If someone then were to see a black man in a suit with a briefcase typing on his PDA in the subway and think "Man! I better avoid that damn black person because I'm racist!" that would be utter stupidity.

    It's about pattern recognition, and anyone with a strong mind capable of objective rationalization would effortlessly be able to separate their "warning signs" from race, applying them instead to the scenario at hand.

    The same thing goes for seeing a bunch of bearded white guys wearing flannel and camo, drinking bud light, fiddling with shotguns, and shouting about how evil being gay is at random passerby, and then going on to assume the next white oxford professor you see is racist. It's not intelligent.

    The most noble thing to do is to use what intelligence you have, to notice "warning signs" (i.e., country accent, camo outfit), and give the benefit of the doubt and not assume that person is a bigoted redneck. From scenario to scenario one has to make judgment calls based on how much data they've collected. A gay man wearing neon colors and glitter on their face might do well to avoid a group of camo-wearing, gun-toting, country-accented men even without having collected the data that one would by hearing them talk about how evil gays are. That wouldn't be racist, that would be using deductive reasoning based on collected data at-hand to weigh risk.

    If I'm walking alone at 2am down a deserted street in a bad part of town and there are a bunch of black men in their teens / early 20's hanging out on one side and I hear aggressive sounding voices and gangster rap coming from them... I walk on the other side of the street and avoid them.

    If I'm walking through campus in broad daylight and see a classmate of mine hanging out in front of the dining hall wearing a do-rag, big gold chains, listening to hip-hop with some similarly attired friends, I go over and say hey and hang out for a bit.

    Personally, I don't consider those actions "racist" but I do take into account all relevant factors when making judgments about situations. I suppose it depends on what way you look at it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Whoisit

      I appreciate your thesis and it is correct to a point. However, as I explained in my own INN post I, a black female was attacked by two white men. Let it be noted that these two white men were wearing suits and looked otherwise respectable.

      The point being that connotations given by media about what a good person or bad person looks like should not affect our view point. I had a wrong sense of security before being attacked by these men because they were dressed in what we'd assume is respectable clothing. However, it was THEIR perception of me that caused the racist attack. I had recently stopped straightening my hair and so it was in it's natural afro-state. Any black people on here or even white people can understand the disdainful attitudes towards our hair. Never the less, I was still dressed respectably.

      In other words. They had their own views towards black, afro-haired women to be non-conformist. However, ironically, it was them who gave the wrong impression of their image by going against the respect we have for suits in their behavior.

      Simply put- they attacked me for how I look but betrayed how they looked with their behavior.

      So lets get out of the mentality that only track-suit wearing, weed-smoking, afro-head black people or shaven-headed white people, are the only people who have the capacity to hate or even hurt other people.

      Thanks. :)

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Eternal_Wisdom

    just doesn't make sense hating a few billion other people because of a few bad experiences with people that happen to be a particular colour. hating those individuals makes sense but not people that weren't even involved.

    the "i was brought up racist" line people use is WEAK. they need to form their own thoughts & opinions about life like everyone else. if you've never had a bad experience with another race would it be ok to still be racist because "i was brought up racist " no.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Frosties

    I'd find it difficult to argue "intelligent". Instinctive, maybe. Most species shun difference for self-interest. I remember seeing an albino gazelle forcibly ejected from the herd and effectively used as lion bait. While the albino was the target, the other gazelles lived another day.

    But humans have a level of intelligence which permits us to act against instinct for the sake of fairness. If I have an instinct to have sex (which I often do) and can't find anyone who'll agree to it, do I force them? No. If I am angry and have an instinct to hurt someone or maybe end their life, do I? No. Do vegetarians eat meat just because they have canine teeth? No.

    If you consider morality to be a kind of social intelligence (which I do) then it is more intelligent not to be racist even if, instinctively, we sometimes are. People should be more honest about stuff like this. Especially the PC brigade who imply they are instinctively non-racist. I think they are lying.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • wigz

    This is one of my old posts. Hello again.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • 12eahtsdrateri

    yes racism can be intelligent
    however a real intelligent person would have figured out that not all people from that ethnic back aground are like that.

    That people regardless of culture can be jerks.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • webjock

    I have had to deal with all kinds of bad people, but I have never said that ALL PEOPLE OF A CERTAIN CATEGORY act badly in the same manner.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Satchmo

    Good post this post demonstrates exactly why I haven't been on this website in months a legitimate sincere question that has to be prefaced and continuously interrupted with a disclaimer saying that he's not racist because of how absurdly politically correct everyone is on this site I can't stand those people also the 20 something male virgins who claim they are waiting for the right person. Everyone is capable of seeing the world as it is but so few people actually do religion politics and optimism has them lost in a maze of bull shit beliefs the sad thing is if they let go of these things they would realize at every turn there is a door that exits the maze and meaningful discussion would be abundant on any forum.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • myownopinions

    It's not intelligence, it's classical conditioning. Like Ivan Pavlov's experiments where a dog was classically conditioned to salivate after hearing a bell that came before meals, people (especially younger ones) can become classically conditioned to become racist after they are abused or whatever by the same race after countless times. Intelligence would be to realize what is happening and rise above their preconceived notions into not being racists. (I voted the first option)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Rhuarc

    I am not racist I am culturalist, I hate people who come from the black 'gang banging' culture. People who do dumb things rob, steal, kill and all that or ones who listen to bad music that promotes robbing, stealing, and killing. Those people I do hate, it just so happens that most people into that are black don't get me wrong there are a few whites and I hate them just as much.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • coolio75650932

    FUCK RACISM (exept in checkers i hate being black team)

    Comment Hidden ( show )