Am i cruel for not wanting to help my father?

When I was 5, my father got into drugs (mainly heroin). He lost his job and as a result, my Mom had to take a second job to pay the bills and I know that he beat her pretty badly when he was messed up. She tried everything in her power to try to help him off of the drugs but she never succeeded.

One day, when I was 8, my Dad came home messed up while I was trying to make myself some lunch in the kitchen and he babbled at me, turned me around and punched me in the jaw, which knocked me onto the ground. He broke my jaw and eye socket and I went unconcious for a little bit, I could hardly move. He rummaged through the house and the dog barked at him until a half an hour later, the neighbors called the cops and when I heard them knock on the door, I screamed as loud as I could and the last thing I remember was hearing them break down the door.

6 months later, my father was in prison and my Mother was divorcing him and we had moved into an apartment closer to my Grandma's house. I'm 24 now and every now and then when I drive into town I will see him. He is homeless and sometimes he holds up signs begging for "anything you can give", but he usually looks strung out.

The reason I ask is because of a girl I was dating a few weeks ago. She asked me about my father and I told her all of this and she said that I was cruel for not helping him because he is now just a weak, helpless homeless man. I personally don't give a rat's ass about how he has an "illness" or anything like that. I never even think about him. I no longer consider him my Dad. He's been gone for years. Am I really cruel for not trying to help him?

Yes 11
No 68
Other (comment) 3
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 21 )
  • Mando

    You have every right to protect yourself by keeping your distance and not getting involved with problems you can do nothing useful about. That there is also no bond between you is quite understandable but less important IMO because even if there was you still would need to protect yourself from him and would not be able to do anything. I think your date was quite insensitive.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Justsomejerk

    No one is helpless.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • he made his mistakes and he bears the repercussion now, you do whatever you please to make your life your own, people who have come from the bosom of a loving family with all the support that it brings would not understand, so dont worry what others say at all

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dinz

    It's the other way around, he is cruel for not thinking about the effects of his drug habit on the family. Considering how your Mother got herself a second job to try to support the family and tried to get your father off the drug, surely that was a wasted opportunity for him to try to clean up his act.

    It's not your fault for his current situation, he consciously made the decision to direct his life towards a cliff.

    A question, is he still on heroin? And if yes, have you tried helping him get off the drug?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Truth be told since his trial none of us had made any contact with him. I have a few friends in the PD in my hometown and last they told me of him was about a year ago and he was on SOMETHING.

      I don't see him every time I come to town but when I do he looks pretty bad but aside from that I don't pay much attention. That guy hangs around some dangerous characters.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • dinz

        Well it sounds like he's firmly made his choice to remain on the street. As I said earlier, the cruel one in your situation was him. I completely understand why your date said that, but I guess you need to clarify things with her and explain to her that cruelness plays both way.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Actually I quit seeing her. I frequently visit my family and I also have a full-time job during both of which I do not respond to text messages and I explained that to her but she found it offensive that I would take so long to respond.

          I tried explaining to her that it'd be stupid to get myself involved BECAUSE of the dangerous characters that he is involved with but she gave me some bullshit about how I should be willing to do anything for my father.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • dinz

            Oh well I guess it's how the cookie crumbled.

            Just don't be surprised if you got the same/similar reaction next time. People react to such a situation differently due to experience. I know one friend who would find anything like this (your story) offensive because he lost his father at a young age. There is must be a logical explanation behind what she said.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • Well, I actually get asked this occasionally and I get different reactions. My Mom re-married to an Indian and I am white as white gets, but my step-dad is my Dad. He came to all of my football games and took my cars keys when I stayed out too late, for all intents and purposes he is my Dad and my father is just a dark chapter in our history. But people see that my Dad is Indian and they have to ask.

              I know that I have pissed a few people off before, usually they say things like what that girl I was dating said but most of the time they just say "Oh that makes sense" or something like that. I once had a Professor get on my arse for it in college and say that people like me perpetuate homelessness and poverty for not taking care of our familial duties.

              I told her that men like him perpetuate the culture of drugs and violence within the household. I still ended up making an A in that class.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • bumblecreek

    it's not cruel. he hurt you and your mother, all due to drugs. that's not what a father husband should do. he deserves the ordeal he's got.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • anti-hero

    No way fuck your father he doesn't deserve your help.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • NotStrangeBird

    I'd say that if he ever attempted to make amends and turn himself around, your rejection of him would be debatable. As it stands though, fuck him. Your job in life is to not be like him.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Daisydo

    If he wants help he will seek it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Nogoodusernames

    Forgive me of this offends you but your father seems like a bad man. He doesnt seem like the dream father but yet he still is your father. I would try to find out if hes still on drugs and if he is, dont help him. Dont even give him a penny. But of he quit thats up to you, did he give u any times to remeber?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Cruelty for the cruel but helping to end someone's life is not fair recompense for a broken eye socket/jaw.

    I know that's a hard thing to hear, and you can still keep your distance from him, but the right paths in life to take are usually the hardest ones of all.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • I don't get it. How am I helping to end someone's life?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • Also- What can you do to help him exactly? If all the aid you can offer is a home to stay in then you should decline.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Just give him some spare change if you can spare it.Don't go out of you way to do it though,and don't bring him to where you live if you see him all fucked up.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • No, not at all. While he's strung out like that he's not even your father; he's a junkie. You are better off to keep your distance. Seeing you would bring him shame (because he knows he's a shitty father) and he'd struggle not to ask you for money, but because of his habit, he'd ask you anyway.

    But do try (I know it's tough) to keep your heart open, in case the day comes when he's cleaned himself up and actually needs some compassion. If he ever tries to make amends with you, try to let him.

    I'm sorry you suffered abuse, you have my sympathy.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RaNdOmPoPcOrN

    hi

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • alextsang08

      Why so much hate

      Comment Hidden ( show )