Should i forgive him?

I have been seeing this guy for about a month- he is very well read and I am very impressed in how much he knows about people and life. However, he is very emotionally unstable, and emotionally somewhat traumatized, from seeing his father beat his mother when he was little (and later leaving her when he was very young).

He recently admitted in hitting his past girlfriend twice, once giving her a black eye. I could see from the way he told me that he deeply regretted it and suffered greatly for what he had done.

Just a few days ago, we sat down to eat and there were two pieces of food left, and I asked him if he wanted to have some first, and spilled a bit of tea on my hands. He started yelling at me for not using my pants to wipe the tea on, and for asking him if he wanted the food rather than acting all assertive and taking it myself first. He took the pieces of sushi and stuffed them in my face, rubbing it on top of my mouth, yelling eat it! eat it! I was in total shock. It fell on the ground where we were sitting and then he pointed to it and asked if I was going to eat it. I couldn't even respond, I was too tired to think. I remember hugging him and then I kissed him on his head. Then I went home. During the night he messaged me many times, apologizing, and tried calling me the next day, and then telling me I should think about his feelings and call. I replied yesterday, that we should not see each other- have a nice life. At first he just said ok, i'll have a nice life, but then again is begging for me to see him.

I feel like a total fool, why does it hurt so much? When he is warm and nice, we get along so well, but he does not know how to treat women, and can say very mean things. I don't know which side to judge him by. Or if I should forgive him. I have never met any guy I connected with this closely, and was kind of in love with- it really really stings....

Is It Normal?
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 18 ) Sort: best | oldest
  • I know you, I am you. And you aren't going to listen to anyones advice, especially ifyou feel a real connection to this guy, dispite all the horrible thing people say about him and how you should Handel it and dispite what this guy has done.. I know you won't leave him, just from you asking for advice. I know because Im with this type of guy and I did the same just to hear what people thought, you probably feel you need to help or that somebody has to love him. I've been with my boyfriend for three years and his mother abused him and his sisters, he is verbally abusive and has spit in my face before.. My point is, he's had his bad episodes inthe past years and no it hasn't completely stopped but it has gotten so much better.
    My guess is that they act out and push us to see if we really are going to be there through the worst. I know you are going to do what you think is best and if you think it's best to stay that is your decision and there is nothing wrong with it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • I'm one of those... so, as the mother fucker I am... I can suggest to you... start something bad... and then leave... make him feel it was you both's fault... and show yourself intolerant to the fact that you can't get things done with problems like that... if you do it right... maybe he will feel like it's his fault too... but cut it clear! maybe the trauma has some hidden obsessive characteristics you don't want to meet :1 "why the fuck do I have sore ears?"

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Talking to a women like that is a complete disgrace. Please stay away from this man.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • and its only been one month? Get out of there!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Went through what you went through. Exactly what you went through. And FYI it WILL end badly. So get away from him now. He's emotionally unstable and you can't fix him so don't try to.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Leave him, u will find someone who will treat u properly!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Tl;dr

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • I think u should move on that's not ok what he did
    You don't want to end up having a black eye like his last girl do you?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Stop being his lover. He is dangerous. But be a friend for him, by giving him advises and trying to convince him to see someone. It is the best thing to do. But something is sure, you should stop your relationship with him.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • So she disappears, and the next poor girl he stumbles across gets abused as well and the cycle goes on. The nonchalant-save-myself attitude will save her; yes, but will not do anything about the issue here. So in a month, another lady will log on here with the same problem. You see? I bet that if she later finds out that some other victim of his is hurt far worse than she was, she will wish she could have done more to break the cycle.

    What I suggested earlier is a reasoned way to avoid that regret and guilt and to do some real good to the situation instead of just fleeing. She will not be exposing herself to even the most minimum amount of risk as she will be connecting him with professionals who can help him with his issues.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • As I have already said, this man does need help, but he needs PROFESSIONAL help, not the help of some naive young girl. The goal of this girl, or any other girl/woman involved in an abusive relationship, should be to save themselves. She has no moral obligation to remain in contact with this abuser and place herself in danger.

      As for his possibly hurting someone else, that is a certainty and that is why he needs professional help. The only way this girl could possibly have helped him would have been to call the police when he smeared the sushi on her face, but she chose not to do that. Now, there is really nothing she can do but help herself by staying away from him.

      Even if she remained in contact with him and suggested he get professional help, he would ignore her. An abuser, who has abused other women, isn't going to listen to someone he considers his inferior, i.e., a woman. The only way a woman will ever be able to help this animal is if she reports his abusive acts to the police and he is arrested and charged.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • It's tru that you would be putting yourself at great risk by being in a relationship with someone who you determine (and stated) is emotionally unstable. His actions are reprehensible and cannot go without some action to ensure that they go no further.

    I disagree however that your best course of action is to turn tail and bail. For most people with emotional/psychological disorders, the ostracizing they get from the "normals" can be so frustrating that opportunities like the one you have given him can cause a large amount of self-sabotaging.

    My suggestion would be that you let him know first and foremost how unacceptable his behavior was, and make it clear to him that you will not tolerate such behavior from him ever again. Make it clear that you feel for him, and are worried about him. Encourage him to seek some help with dealing with his issues. Offer to accompany him to a clinic or counselor if he needs the support (if he wants this, meet him at the location, as opposed to his place or yours). If he takes this seriously, then you know he is reaching out for help and will take you seriously. If he blows this off, makes excuses or gets aggressive or violent when you make these suggestions, then take him off your phone/facebook and move on with your life.

    best of luck to you!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Dump this guy NOW!!! A man who would do something like that in public will do a hundred times worse in private.

    Another thing, I wouldn't put too much stock in that tale he told about seeing his father beat his mother. You say that he is "very well read" and that means that he knows what to say to gain sympathy for his actions. I'll bet if you asked his mother, you would get a different story. Men who abuse women, even the dumb ones, can always come up with sob stories about how they were abused, or how their fathers abused their mothers, or whatever, and most of the time, it's all a lie. But even if true, it's no excuse.

    Don't see him anymore, or text him or have any communication with him whatsoever. If he does what he did to someone he has known for only a month, think of what he would do to a wife or children.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • You should leave this exploiter, SweetAdeline is right this man is obviously lying about the his mother being abused.

      He is also begging to get your sympathy so he can control you. Show this hound no sympathy and give him no mercy.

      This man deserves a one way trip to the Gulags were he can rot.

      "Unite and take part in production and political activity to improve the economic and political status of women." Mao Zedong.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • i realize that you've connected with this guy, but, it's only been one month, therefore, as much as you think you feel for him, it really is time to let it go.

    during the beginning of a relationship, everyone is on their best behavior, and if this is his best, think of what your future will be.

    he obviously is a damaged man, and being there for him, and forgiving him etc., doesn't help him heal, in fact, it enables him to do more.

    what do you think he will do to you if you ever make a real mistake?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dump him. Have him killed if he tries to get back with you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Tell him that you'll help find him a councelor & get him into anger management.

    Break up.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • he will end up beating you.run like hell.

    Comment Hidden ( show )