My daughter is depressed ,is it normal to do this to help her ?

my daughter is in high school, I think she is depressed, she doesn't leave the house on weekends and doesn't take care of her looks although shes very pretty.

I know she has a crush on a boy in school, is it too weird if I messaged him from my social media account and tell him my daughter's problem and ask him to go out with her on a "pity date" just to help her.
I would like to hear opinions from parents and teenagers about this

Edit : maybe it may be a stupid idea but what about talking with his mother ?

Voting Results
20% Normal
Based on 49 votes (10 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 65 )
  • GenderConfused

    NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!!
    No.
    I see where you're coming from but i do not recommend this.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Fetiza000

      Why dont you recommend this? (just wondering).

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • GenderConfused

        Several reasons i dont agree.
        The daughter will feel like you are interfering should this idea go wrong.
        The daughter may think this guyis cute or whatever but that doesn't mean she likes him like that.
        The daughter may hav something she wants to express but is unsure of the outcome (she may be lesbian)
        This guy, while im sure his public record is sparkling (volunteering and such) but experience should have taught the mother that this is only the face he presents to the public. Such ppl usually have an unhealthy way of dealing with the stress of presenting a perfect life to the public.
        And finally, we've all seen the movies where this idea goes bad bu eventually ends happily ever after.. This is not a movie. Should it go bad thismother will have ruined her kids self esteem, such as it is. And bring something between them that may not be fixed.
        Finally, you just dont do this sort of thing. How would you have felt if your mother had done this to you.. Be honest, you would probably have freaked.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • yes I would, you're right, but that's exactly why I'm asking for opinions on the internet

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Fetiza000

            Jesus fucking Christ what a mother of the year everyone -_-

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • why dont you stop trying to be funny and start giving valuable advice or just go away ?

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • thecatcherintherye

    No, that is a really bad idea... If she finds out that the guy only asked her out because you asked him to - out of pity... She will be heartbroken and laughed at by others. She might even not trust you or other guys anymore. Long story short: she'll feel even worse...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    No, that's a bad idea.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • have any good ideas?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • RoseIsabella

        It's a good idea to not mess with the guy or guys she crushes on, because that would be super weird and awkward.

        Some of my good idea suggestions would be to invite her out for mother and daughter days. Invite her to the gym, to the park for a run or bike ride. Ask your daughter to come along with you to the salon or spa for a makeover(ya'll can do this together), invite her to mall and take her to her favorite makeup counter to hook her up with the right skincare, base & color palette, invite her out to lunch with you. Ask your daughter to join you for a yoga class sometime. Invite your daughter to pray and meditate with you. Remind your daughter that she is a beautiful person inside and out everyday. Tell your daughter that it's normal to go through an awkward stage, and that you yourself have gone through an awkward stage in your youth as well.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • thank you so much RoleIsabella!!!!, may I ask how old are you and if you have any kids?

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • rayb12

            Rose is in her 40s but has the youthful glow of a young 20 something. She does not have children.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
          • RoseIsabella

            I'm 47, but I don't have any kids. I still feel like a kid inside I suppose.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
        • Mysticphoenix79

          See now this is a great idea but don't forget about medical help as well!!!

          If you truly believe that she is depressed did it takes a doctor to diagnose it!!!!
          Don't want it to go untreated that's where the danger comes into place!!!!!

          So do both make sure she gets some medical help that she needs and take her out on the mom and daughter days anything that's positive and energetic healthy!!!!

          Start doing some research on it!!!
          But by no means bring a boy into the situation!!!

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • RoseIsabella

            Excellent point!

            Comment Hidden ( show )
        • Happyyoungling

          Gold. ^

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • RoseIsabella

            Time to jam out to some old Spandau Ballet.

            https://youtu.be/ntG50eXbBtc

            Comment Hidden ( show )
  • mia500

    Come on, really? That's so embarrassing

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • I know , im not really proud of thinking of this , but a boyfriend can fix a girls depression

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Ellenna

        I'd be depressed if I had a mother as stupid as you seem to be: if you think your daughter is depressed LISTEN TO HER and if necessary get her to therapy. If you've brought her up to believe nothing other than a boyfriend can fix depression, you also need therapy

        Comment Hidden ( show )
      • Mysticphoenix79

        Are you fucking serious!!! A boy is not a fix to depression!!! If fact it can very well worsened things! And make things even more complicated! I'm sure that you're not thinking with your right head which means that your daughter especially is not being guided in the right direction right now. so therefore that opens the door for teen pregnancy as well as heartbreak!!!!

        Why don't you try what normal people do and get a therapist!!!
        If she's truly depressed the last thing she needs is boy right now!!!

        Take it from someone that is suffering from depression you don't want to mix boys with that situation!!!! It's nothing but a heartache confusion and more devastation!!!!!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • you have depression ? how old are you? and how are you dealing with it ?

          Comment Hidden ( show )
      • insanebotv21

        Dunno... might not even be depressed, just tired/lazy/exhausted, etc. People sometimes need breaks. Depression is very very hard to gauge from an outside perspective, and being sad does not mean you are depressed either.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • rayb12

    Lol good god almighty, you may as well snap some nude photos of her and post them around the school... No your idea is worse!

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • snorlax

    no don't do that, there's no good will come out from this date and if you concern about your daughter, you can reconnect with her find something she loves and doing it together

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • sissycakes

    Leave this poor girl alone. You have destroyed her life.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • sosr2

    As a teenager who has struggled with depression, i can confidently say that bringing the boy into this is the last thing that you should do! Talk to her doctor about it or take her to a therapist. Most of all, listen when she talks, bring up your concerns and explain that is why you want her to see a therapist, just to make sure that nothing is wrong, because she may not know that she is depressed (she very well might though). However, it is very possible that she is not depressed, so just listen to her and the doctor. And also support her, if she does not want to go out or ask out the boy, that is her decision, do not try to undermine her or her wishes. She will do it when she is ready, and the worst thing to do if she is depressed is to bring a boy into it, you need to be happy before you can truly commit to a relationship. So PLEASE just take her to a doctor and listen to the BOTH of them (her doctor and your daughter).

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Lovelvforever1998

    Some people just like having their own company. That doesn't mean they are depressed. I have so many friends, but only three of them are my actual friends. But they are not in my class, they are in a different section. But every recess I wait for them and we all go for a walk around the school.

    I sit at the back of my class, even tho my other friends beckon me to sit with them. I don't want to. I like my own company.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Britneywolf

    Don't do it! Putting her on a pity date would just be terrible. Perhaps try talking to her and see if she will open up at all about her issues.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Blabla123

    No, its not normal its the worst thing you can possibly do...most of depressed people have horrible self esteem...and if she finds out someone pretended to like her becouse you told him she will hate you both..and you dont know what kind of person is he...What if he tells that to whole school..you could openly talk with her about it or take her to the places she likes, try to make her happy with her favourite activities..etc

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • xfg56

    You might want to send naked pics of your daughter to entice him, maybe throw a few potty training videos in as well. He may not even know how hot she is if she's constantly covered up.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • CapriSun

    Dude. Do not fucking do that.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • rayb12

    Lol and your asking for advice from PARENTS?! You fucking imbecile. I swear mothers of teens are the most arrogant bunch ever. Did it ever occur to you that perhaps YOU are a contributing factor to your daughters suffering??? That the pressure of "letting down your mom" is an unnecessary added weight atop everything she is already dealing with? That if you truly cared you would back the fuck off? That every teen goes through a depression nowadays? No. Because this has 0 to do with your daughter the human being and everything to do with your ego and feeling like you were the one that was able to cure her. That you would go to the lengths of humiliating her and ruining her chances with a boy that she trusted you by telling you she likes. How about you focus instead on yourself?? Are you so perfect? The only person in need of pity here is you. I doubt you even know who your daughter actually is. The single best thing you can do is establish a relationship like 2 adults and let her feel like she has the agency to fix her own issues and that her depression is not an imposition on you. Get to know her as you would another adult without judgement and for god sakes back the fuck off. Becoming a mom did not solve your personal issues you still have to fix them let your daughter do things herself.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Im her best friend , i never commented on her appearance or grades or anything bad about her , i always compliment her and encourage her , why the hell would you think her depression has anything to do with me , and you start attacking me based on your assumption ?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • rayb12

        I am glad to hear those things and that makes you better than most parents. However your complete naïveté that you would play any role shows a profound ignorance for what EVERY teen goes through today, and gives me more confidence in my assumption.

        Again "attack" you are such a textbook mom. Listen, you are not the victim, not in your life, not in out conversation, not in your relationship with your daughters depression.

        What you are experiencing is a point of view that doesn't paint you as a mom who doesn't harm her daughter in any way, that isn't an attack.

        Teens need space from their parents. And when mom's can't give them that it depresses them. I'm not asserting you've harmed your daughter in any other way.

        I am simply informing you of what a teen girl needs. If your role as a parent is not changing as she gets older there is a problem. You need to give her space.

        It has nothing to do with how nice you are, the only actual nice thing you can do is give her space.

        You are not seeing the situation from her perspective.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • rayb12

          I don't doubt for a minute that you love your daughter and she 100% knows this as well, but your plan of action is the polar opposite of what you should be doing at this stage in her life. If you want to arrange a play date have another baby.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • You have a true point of view , but i dont think youre a mom , i cant just give her space and watch her go downhill

            I have read stories about teen suicide and just the thought of that makes me sick and makes my eyes water

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • rayb12

              Hey think about it like this. When you have such strong emotional reactions to your daughters behavior, she then is forced to make choices manage not only her own emotions but yours as well. This is selfish and unfair, and a big way to ask your daughter to push you out of her life. I don't think you see how I am trying to help you here. There are 2 things that can take place either you will take the initiative to step back and show her respect and that you trust her or she will have no choice to push you far away. Go ahead and message that boy if you really want to see what I mean.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
            • rayb12

              I am not a mom this is true. I am however the child of a mom, who was just as stubborn and arrogant as you. She never gave me enough space and constantly worried I was suicidal. Like you she was very "nice". And she prided herself and derived lots of joy from her role as a mother. I can tell you no other external force has given me as much hardship as my relationship with my mother. Her over dramatic reaction to my depression made it so much longer and worse than if she just paid attention to her damn self. If your daughter is going to kill herself and you're not abusing her there is nothing you can do. However now I can barely look at my mom and don't respond to her emails. I'm about to be 25 years old. If this is the outcome you'd like with your daughter, keep doing what you're doing.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
      • Mysticphoenix79

        First of all your her mother not her best friend!!!!

        And you need to starting thinking about this like a protective mother would!!!!

        Not how how a best friend would try to set up their friend to make the feel better!!! That teenager shit!!

        And having your mom do that for you is extremely embarrassing for a teenager she'll never trust you with any information ever again so close up to you and you'll lose your daughter!!!

        Your a grown ass adult!!!! Start acting like one!!!

        You need to start by finding her some medical help!!!! And some therapy as well as yourself!!!! Cuz it seems like you got some co-dependent issues!!!!

        A little word of advice to if you do end up going to therapy live therapy in therapy don't bring it home with you meaning whatever is spoken about during the therapy sessions that's where it's left at you don't bring that s*** home with you!!!

        And You need to stop trying to get your teenage daughter the go ahead with boys!!! Your opening up the door for teen pregnancy!!! Because exactly what's going to happen!!!!
        Or she gonna wind up with a man that's abusive!!!!

        Comment Hidden ( show )
      • Fetiza000

        ''im her best friend''

        Comment Hidden ( show )
      • Ellenna

        If you're her "best friend" you have a problem: you're her MOTHER so act like one and back off

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • its just a thought holy shit, calm down and stop being so rude

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Ellenna

            Your attitude to your daughter isn't "just a thought" and I don't see how I was rude

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • i don't reflect any of my attitude on my daughter, thanks for ur assumption

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • paramore93

    DO NOT DO THIS, PLEASE DO NOT DO THIS
    Oops caps .. but yeah if he says no she's going to be a laughing stock that her mum asked a guy out for her ..
    If he agreed to go on this one date she's going to be heartbroken if he doesn't want to do it again ..
    Even if he said yeah and they got on well if she found out it was a 'pity date' that would knock her confidence and she would not be happy with you ..
    Just encourage her and she'll do if and when she's ready :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Hes a nice kid , he does some volunteering that i see on his page , i dont think he will tell others and make fun of her

      what about not mentioning im her mother when asking him?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Ellenna

        Oh for goodness sake, turn your brain on: so you're going to contact him anonymously and get him to ask your daughter out to cure her depression? Good idea NOT

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • you are either 70 years old or 10 years old, please read the other comments and learn how to be mature and respectful

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Ellenna

            Actually I'm 70 and if I'm being too direct for you it's because you don't seem to be able to take any notice of the responses you're getting, you just keep making silly excuses for what you want to do regardless of the effect on your daughter.

            If you think she's depressed ASK HER AND THEN LISTEN TO HER rather than hatching silly plots to "fix" her.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • rayb12

              preach!

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dicka912

    I think your daughter is afraid doing sexual things with boys. She would rather stay at home than take the chance of having sexual contact with males. Unless, she is being sexually satisfied at home.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Who mentioned anything sexual ?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • dicka912

        Her hormones are probably going crazy. She is probably having a difficult time handling these issues. She would rather hide than go and experience what is natural and normal. My guess is that she has had a sheltered life so far.

        Comment Hidden ( show )