What the fuck is wrong with people? Why can't things be resolved without instantaneous judgement and violence (regardless of people's mental condition)? Why does everyone here think it's okay to hit strangers? How does that make anything better?
When faced with crises situations it's not in human nature to just stop everything and attempt to approach the situation in a diplomatic manner.
If someone is physically assaulting a loved one (yes, the mentally handicapped man was assaulting her by law, regardless of his condition) what you see is a loved one in danger, and you must react.
It's not a matter of sitting there, thinking it over, and WILLFULLY going "You know what, upon deep consideration, I've decided to be a douche and will proceed to punch this guy in the face."
We are programmed to react like this. It's part of the reason our species has survived for so long. We are social animals and we are driven to protect our "pack" so to speak. Gut reactions and instinct are not indicators of poor judgement or violent dispositions. They are indicators of being human.
I wasn't strictly proscribing reaction. But why jump immediately to fists or (as the poster below me says: knocked the fuk out). Why can't the first reaction be to demand verbally that he puts her down, and the second reaction be to drag him off her?
You imply that the reaction is spontaneous and in no way considered. I don't believe that. If it was true, the reaction would as likely be murderous (a knife in a throat, say). But people have enough self-control not to do that, so why not enough not to immediately for physical violence?
You obviously don't have a younger sister then, and if you do, I feel sorry for her. I'm a girl and if a grown man groped her (15 years old), I'd lose my shit and see red. Maybe its different because I raised her so then is a little maternal inscint mixed in, but never the less. If it was your younger sibling, why would you want to let them in harms way any longer then you had to? And even though he did react quickly, his sister is now tramatized, how much worse would that have been if he just stood there trying to negotiate with the guy to let her go?
People seem to be missing my point. Of course I'd try to stop the situation (even by forcefully removing the attacker from my sister). What I don't understand is instantaneous violence. If everybody thought like this, we'd be out committing manslaughter every day. People CAN control themselves and not kill others.
He didn't kill him... He hit him. And sorry, but as a girl, maybe if perverts were punched more often, the world would actually be a little safer. I'm personally sick of men who think its okay to grab strange women and do what they want with them.
Must have missed the part where the OP wrote "So I murdered the guy instantaneously on the spot"
My bad. I was under the mistaken impression the person sexually assaulting his sister got punched, a relatively non-lethal method with plenty of stopping power that's a normal reaction.
Fuck you your an idiot the autistic man inititiated the violence what the op did was in self defense if your a woman how would u feel if you were being forcibly groped by someone much stronger than you you are so politically correct I want to vomit on you. Retards are strong. Guerillas are really strong so if you see a retarded guerilla run for your life
If you saw a blind person about to get hit by a car you're noting to going to calmly explain to him what is about to transpire, you will violently pull him out of the way so he doesn't get hit.
Retard or not, if any scumbag ever puts a finger on any of my family members then it's already way past diplomacy, he is going to get knocked the fuk out.
and you're an idiot not to realize that the retard assaulted her. The brother was right to intervene as he did.
Is it normal that I punched a mentally disabled person in the face?
← View full post
What the fuck is wrong with people? Why can't things be resolved without instantaneous judgement and violence (regardless of people's mental condition)? Why does everyone here think it's okay to hit strangers? How does that make anything better?
--
PumpkinKate
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
3
3
-
Satchmo
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
1
1
-
lufa
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
-1
-1
When faced with crises situations it's not in human nature to just stop everything and attempt to approach the situation in a diplomatic manner.
If someone is physically assaulting a loved one (yes, the mentally handicapped man was assaulting her by law, regardless of his condition) what you see is a loved one in danger, and you must react.
It's not a matter of sitting there, thinking it over, and WILLFULLY going "You know what, upon deep consideration, I've decided to be a douche and will proceed to punch this guy in the face."
We are programmed to react like this. It's part of the reason our species has survived for so long. We are social animals and we are driven to protect our "pack" so to speak. Gut reactions and instinct are not indicators of poor judgement or violent dispositions. They are indicators of being human.
--
hundredthousand
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
I wasn't strictly proscribing reaction. But why jump immediately to fists or (as the poster below me says: knocked the fuk out). Why can't the first reaction be to demand verbally that he puts her down, and the second reaction be to drag him off her?
You imply that the reaction is spontaneous and in no way considered. I don't believe that. If it was true, the reaction would as likely be murderous (a knife in a throat, say). But people have enough self-control not to do that, so why not enough not to immediately for physical violence?
--
Its_Called_Love
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
3
3
You obviously don't have a younger sister then, and if you do, I feel sorry for her. I'm a girl and if a grown man groped her (15 years old), I'd lose my shit and see red. Maybe its different because I raised her so then is a little maternal inscint mixed in, but never the less. If it was your younger sibling, why would you want to let them in harms way any longer then you had to? And even though he did react quickly, his sister is now tramatized, how much worse would that have been if he just stood there trying to negotiate with the guy to let her go?
--
hundredthousand
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
People seem to be missing my point. Of course I'd try to stop the situation (even by forcefully removing the attacker from my sister). What I don't understand is instantaneous violence. If everybody thought like this, we'd be out committing manslaughter every day. People CAN control themselves and not kill others.
--
Its_Called_Love
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
1
1
-
PumpkinKate
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
He didn't kill him... He hit him. And sorry, but as a girl, maybe if perverts were punched more often, the world would actually be a little safer. I'm personally sick of men who think its okay to grab strange women and do what they want with them.
Must have missed the part where the OP wrote "So I murdered the guy instantaneously on the spot"
My bad. I was under the mistaken impression the person sexually assaulting his sister got punched, a relatively non-lethal method with plenty of stopping power that's a normal reaction.
I guess murder was a bit extreme... ~sarcasm~
Fuck you your an idiot the autistic man inititiated the violence what the op did was in self defense if your a woman how would u feel if you were being forcibly groped by someone much stronger than you you are so politically correct I want to vomit on you. Retards are strong. Guerillas are really strong so if you see a retarded guerilla run for your life
Sometimes immediate reaction is called for.
If you saw a blind person about to get hit by a car you're noting to going to calmly explain to him what is about to transpire, you will violently pull him out of the way so he doesn't get hit.
Retard or not, if any scumbag ever puts a finger on any of my family members then it's already way past diplomacy, he is going to get knocked the fuk out.
and you're an idiot not to realize that the retard assaulted her. The brother was right to intervene as he did.