Is it normal that i think this way about people who like "50 shades of grey"?

I basically think women who actually like 50 Shades of Grey and think that it's a good piece of literature are lonely, sexually-starved stay at home moms who have no concept of the real world and how life works, and don't find any satisfaction with how their lives are. I think anyone who reads novels like 50 Shades are just sexually starved in general, and are completely pathetic because they can't control it.

is it normal that I think this way?

Voting Results
71% Normal
Based on 59 votes (42 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 31 )
  • bristexai

    I could say the same about pornography, couldn't I?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dappled

    It's not a book I'd appreciate because (what I've seen of) the writing is a bit sub-standard. And it's slightly laughable that it is (or was) Twilight fan-fiction before it was adapted. However, my thought processes run differently to most people, I think.

    I see some people's thought process may be: I don't like the book, therefore the book is bad, therefore the people who like it aren't very good either.

    I could challenge every element of that, but I'll leave it for another post because it's not my point here. My thought process was:

    It's not my taste but my taste is only my taste; it's neither right nor wrong. Perhaps people are reading it for the content as opposed to the style. If so, why are so many women expressing an interest in a more submissive type of sex (in the book portrayed with the master as a massively successful young tyro; the kind that feminism wants women to have the same opportunity as, not to lose their virginity to and then be the slave of). You usually find that fetishes move against the line of popular culture (bring in a smoking ban, people will fetishise smoking). Is the success of Fifty Shades of Grey, therefore, an indicator that the feminist movement is now seen as an established authority?

    I'm not suggesting your thought process is wrong. Just that mine is different.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • dom180

    I saw a stack of 50 Shades audiobooks in a shop yesterday. I wonder what accent the reader was, or if it was a man or a women reading the narration? If they had a sexy accent, or just read in a normal, conversational tone. I didn't spend my money on finding out, because I don't think I could make it though a chapter without cringing or laughing or getting angry about some part of it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Anime7

      There's actually a 50 shades of Gray audiobook read by Gilbert Godfried, so funny.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • dom180

        You've given me an idea; now I'm seriously considering the idea of recording a choice section of 50 Shades for this: http://iinvoice.elementfx.com/

        I don't know if that is a genius idea or a terrible one though o_O

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Anime7

          Sounds like it'd hilarious. Dude where did you find this website, it's interesting hearing how some of the users on here sound. I just voice one, should be up there in a couple of hours.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • dom180

            The site is basically an idea dappled and Shackleford had, I would guess about 6 months ago now; I'll try and find the original thread and come back in a minute. I bookmarked the site when they posted it and I check back sometimes to see if anyone new has done done a voice recording.

            It's great that you're doing a recording! I always wondered how you sounded :)

            EDIT: Original thread here: http://isitnormal.com/poll/is-it-normal-voiceaccent-comparison-129262/

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • Anime7

              I have to say you have a very thick accent, not that it's bad thing. It sounds nice, just thought I'd say.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • lc1988

    I bought it but haven't read it yet...and I do not fit your little stereotype you have dubbed the readers

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Grimlock2020

    My biggest problem with it is that it's considered "good" literature, while all it does is degrade women. Sure pornography isn't much better but you don't see porn being praised as quality cinema either.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • myweirdself16

    I've read some of it, and while I agree that the writing is bad, I don't see any problem with people reading it.

    I'm thinking that maybe those "housewives that have nothing better to do" finally get to read a bit or pornography in public that isn't exactly taboo, they take the chance. That's my feel of the whole situation, anyway.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • justsomekidfromcanada

    I think you you're putting way too much thought into this. Maybe they just like the book?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • There is no reason to like that book, except if you struggle to find your own pornography to read, and are so desperate, you'll willing to read shit like 50 Shades.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • scamps027

        Just wondering, have you actually read it? It seems like you have a lot to go on, but it also seems like you're a very prude person. You can't base a book off of what you've heard.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • Yes, I did read it. And it's not really solely the fact that's it's porn that makes me so judgmental of women who actually like it, it's the plot, the characters. It would be one thing if women just thought of this book as another porn novel to add to their collection, but to actually think the story is GOOD? To actually think that Christian Grey is romantic when he's really a controlling, abusive jerk? To not even care that Ana is just a self-insert Mary Sue? To actually think that it's a good piece of LITERATURE when it's really just poorly written porn?

          That is sad.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • anonymous9250

            It is not just porn have you really read the book all 3 of them Anna actually stands up for her self and christian only wants to keep her safe he doesn't want anything bad to happen to her and the only reason he's controlling is because he had an abusive child hood were he was a victim of neglect from his mother he suffered so much and felt sad that he could mot save his mother from killing her self and had no control over anything so he changed that and worked hard so that he could control his own life and not suffer threw anything like that again it was a time of defense mechanism.
            You really need to focus on the plot, story line not the porn/sex part of it

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • I still think you're a troll. The book is porn. Or erotica. Or whatever it is people like to call it. The reason it exists is to get you off. That is why it's there. Saying "you need to read the storyline" for something like 50 Shades is like saying you really need to read the articles for Playboy.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Energy

    I'm a guy who loves it. I like BDSM. So it turns me on. I imagine myself being Christian and doing those things to Anastasia. I am on the 3rd book now.

    I like it. It's neat.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Anime7

    I can understand where you're coming from and I kind of agree with you.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • anonymous9250

    Im 19 read all 3 books and in no way am i considering BDSM you need to read all 3 books its more than just the sex part its the story line and twilight is a pice of crap compared to the 50 Shades trilogy

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • la_la_la_la

    I knew 2 women who were obsessed with said series. It put me off. Fantasy to me meant (& will always mean) dragons, elves, the Fey etc. I'd never read erotica cos most chick lit bores me rigid, & after this I never will again.

    Thankfully said women have long been out of my life. I saw it at a book sharing place & picked it up after saying I wouldn't even recommend it if it was free, thinking I shouldn't knock it until I’d tried it; it couldn't be that bad if it was being read by so many. It was as bad as I imagined, possibly worse. I sat there praying it would get interesting. It didn't. I've read more graphic sexy stuff than this, but it is/was dressed up in flowery medieval language so it sounds nicer.

    There's no story (a story you have to wade through 3 books to find is not a good one, sorry) characters with nothing to them; no explanation of *why* all these women seem to be falling over themselves to be with Christian Grey (Hugh. G. Reckshun would've been a better name for him) He sounds horrible.

    I'm in love with a character who sounds nasty, but he actually isn't. He's got a great sense of humour, & were he real, he'd protect you to the last, even put his life on the line for you. & he'd never do what Grey does!

    Oh, well, back to reading about said dragons then.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • thecoldhardtruth

    Hahahahahha you took these thoughts out of my head.
    In all actuallity it's just a book, I'm 18 and all my friends are reading it.
    Ido find it a bit pitiful though

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • shade_ilmaendu

    Well I've never read it, but my problem with it is from talking to other people who are into BDSM the books apparently portray the lifestyle really badly and what worries me is a bunch of young girls (or middle aged horny women) now have this unrealistic idea of BDSM, probably aren't using safewords, and are going to end up in some awkward or even rapey situations because they decided to try this new fetish without knowing what they're doing.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Which is just ANOTHER reason on how it sucks; not only is the writing, the plot, and the characters terrible, but the author couldn't even make BDSM realistic? The one thing that the book SHOULD get right?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • bananaface

    I've never heard of anyone who thought it was good literature. I think a lot of people who read it are aware that it's badly written, but like it anyway. Although, maybe I shouldn't say it's badly written when I haven't even read it. I don't think your image is accurate of everyone (or even most of the people) who read the book. It's understandable why you'd feel that way, though. I just think that you're mainly wrong.

    Although, your post has made me wonder about how many men have read the book. Hmm, I've never heard of a man reading it, it's always seems to be linked to women.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Oh, I've seen people who've defended it as a naturally good book. I've seen people who got annoyed when other people call the book "just porn", and that the books are a "good love story". There are people out there who think that the writing is good, the story is romantic, and that the books shouldn't be classified as "porn".

      If the novel was written from a man's POV, then men would probably read it. Women are stereotypically the ones to read porn novels, while men just want the real thing and go on the internet and watch porn themselves. I'm not saying this is true with all men and women, but this is the stereotype that I've noticed.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • bananaface

        Yikes, that's pushing it. Although, again, I've only heard tiny snippets, which really isn't enough to base my judgement on, I guess.

        The main reason I disagree is because I know so many exceptions to your description. Also, I couldn't agree more with bristexai.

        Comment Hidden ( show )