Is it normal that i don’t like ‘romantic gestures’

I’m a girl and I’m attracted to manly men so I don’t like it when guys do things such as give me over the top compliments, tell me they love me and expect me to say it back, makes a big fuss out of Valentine's Day and especially if he cries in front of me.

To me, these things come across as girly and I’ve always assumed it was the girl in the relationship that would usually push for this kind of behaviour. But all of my exes (despite being relatively manly) have expected me to tell them I love them and send them long love messages and things like that.

It makes me cringe so much. I’m immediately turned off when the guy starts getting emotional and acting like a girl. Is this really normal behaviour for guys or do I just keep picking sissies?

Voting Results
53% Normal
Based on 17 votes (9 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 15 )
  • Boojum

    I've gotta wonder what your family life was like when you were growing up.

    We all learn a set of rules for relationships, gender roles and the amount of emotions it's acceptable to express from our parents. If we're lucky and our parents had a respectful, emotionally honest and mutually supportive relationship, then it's possible for us to easily move into a similar relationship when we're adults. If someone grows up in a family where emotions are viewed as dangerous and something to be kept locked away, then it can be difficult to deal with them in a positive way when we're adults, and we need to learn how to do so on our own.

    You seem to be suffering under the delusion that real men are incapable of feeling strong emotional attachment, or if they do, they never express it. That makes me wonder if your father was either emotionally cold, or if he expressed such emotions often and you came to see that as manipulative or negative for some other reason.

    You're obviously free to continue to believe that expressing affection and complimenting you is "girly", but I'd suggest that if your mental model of the ideal man remains a guy who keeps his emotions under tight control at all times, then you're very likely heading for problems. A healthy relationship requires that both people be capable of expressing their feelings and understanding and empathising with the feelings of the other. If one or both of the people keep their true feelings concealed, the most likely result is that one day everything suddenly blows up with no warning at all.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • RoseIsabella

      I wish I could give you more than one thumbs up on this one, Boojum! 👍🏻

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • NormalAdventure

      Fantastic reply and I'm pleasantly surprised by all the comments in this thread. Not sure I can add anything constructive and "likely headed for problems" is the unfortunate truth here. Why? because there ARE men that are like the OP described wanting and the resultant relationship is "very likely" to become a disaster. All of that said... both the type of man she wants and doesn't want are "normal" but somehow the ones she is attracting seem to be somewhat more advanced emotionally.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • SunSnow

      So big explanation..

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • CozmoWank

    So you're saying you like to express your emotions but don't like it when guys do?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Not at all, I don’t like to express my emotions and I find it weird when guys are acting more girly and emotional than I do

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • CozmoWank

        What about when your guy is horny? Do you prefer he just keep it to himself, or would you like for him to express it?
        :b...

        Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ellnell

    I think that manly men are the ones who do gestures and dares to show emotion. I've dated a few inexperienced, immature guys and they never did romantic gestures of any kind and was terrified of displaying emotions and avoided it to every degree. Of course men who cry all the time are quite obnoxious and probably a bit unstable, but that goes for women as well.
    Romantic gestures can get out of hand, it's cringy if it gets too cheesy, but once in a while it's sweet and shows he cares.
    If you want someone who never lets you know he loves you though, it sounds like you want someone emotionally unavailable and there's plenty of those guys... Just go right ahead and pick one. They're almost the easiest ones to find because they're easy in general except when it comes to any real deep relationship.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • SunSnow

      So agree

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RoseIsabella

    I don't care for the way you define masculinity. Shit, every one of my exes said, "I love you", to me first. The biggest badasses, the most masculine ones were usually comfortable being emotional, and I remember this one who cried the first time he told me he loved me.

    I don't care for archaic, two dimensional stereotypes about masculinity, it's stupid.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Inkmaster

    There are five love languages. It would seem that words of affirmation just isn't one of yours.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Boojum

      Thanks for posting that. I'd never heard of the 'five love languages' model of relationships before.

      The Wikipedia summary of Gary Chapman's book says the languages are receiving gifts, quality time, words of affirmation, acts of service and physical touch, and problems occur when there's a mismatch between people's primary method of showing affection.

      I've never thought about it in those terms, but that makes a lot of sense to me.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Bazinga

    For perspective, you should take a break from sissies. Make friends with this guy. Then you will discover the detriments of excessive masculinity.

    https://66.media.tumblr.com/0dc3d0f26cdca61d0b2d91778b31a936/tumblr_psqy13k1Sq1u2zvau_540.jpg

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • SunSnow

    How about melodramatic...
    It's me not with everyone just ppl in comfort zone

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • JellyBeanBandit

    That's really unhealthy for society.

    Comment Hidden ( show )