Do you think that if religion...

...wasn't forced upon people during childhood, that it'd still be as common as it is today?

Yes 28
No 99
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 11 )
  • Silivrin1

    As much as it is a thing as old as history and a fundamental part of humanity, it cannot be denied that a majority of our personality and beliefs are dependent on how we were raised. Children are completely malleable, so they are subject to a conditioning to whatever their parents and family believes.

    Of course when you grow up and interact with more people and learn new things you start to develop an opinion of your own, which may or may not stick to what you've been taught as a child. Some people will stick to their beliefs out of tradition, because it's been such a big part of their lives and their families.

    But then again if no one exposed children to religion in their childhood, then they would only be imposing atheism. Because other than taking your children to church or making them say prayers (or other religious rituals), a majority of the teaching at that age comes from the explanations of the more difficult aspects in life, such as death and love and bad people. If you tell your children the scientific truth from the very beginning, that death is in fact death and nothing more, then they'll merely believe that there is no omniscient being and no greater truth than what the world around us presents; which is essentially atheism.

    For that reason this is a difficult question, because you can either be comforting, or you can be harsh. It seems almost necessary to impose a certain religion on children, doesn't it, because you would rather tell them a blissful lie: that there is something better for them and the people they love beyond this world, rather than to make them try to grasp the terrifying emptiness of mortality.

    Sorry for writing an essay but this is a really interesting question.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Dad

      There are some inconsistencies with that.

      Firstly, be perfectly aware that if you are born in the US then you are more likely going to follow Christian beliefs, and if in the Middle East, you will follow Islamic beliefs.
      Therefore, 'belief' is now subject to where you are born more so than your parent's belief. Which makes 'belief' even more ridiculous.

      Although by not 'praising the lord' throughout life you will be brought to judgement by god if you are going to hell or not (this according to Christians peculiar senseless ideas) By praising jesus in an islam belief society you may be killed on the spot!

      By not being instructed to follow any deity, does not denote atheism.
      Atheism is the lack of belief based on facts, reason and rational thinking. None of which a young child could be expected to understand!

      It would be best not to inform the child of either/any belief/non belief, UNTIL they are old enough to decide for themselves and LEARN about what it really means to believe/not believe.

      In doing so (answering the OPs question)
      It is extremely unlikely an 'adult' would take on any religion, especially since science; evolution; space exploration and rational thinking is presently taught in all public schools. Religion has been officially removed, thankfully.

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • howaminotmyself

    If a family is religious, the children will be exposed. You cannot shelter them from that reality. And they are naturally curious so they will ask questions.

    If you could magically prevent kids from being exposed, of course it woul be less common. But that isn't going to happen.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • anti-hero

    No, I don't think it would be as common.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KnightNigelWellingtonXXI

    There are no atheists in foxholes.

    Signed,
    Knight Nigel Wellington XXI

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • KeddersPrincess

    Well, maybe not Christianity, but people have always been religious, and even if the parents did not raise their children by a religion, you will still have children finding a religion on there own. I think people would still be religious. Perhaps there would be religious by their own will. I myself am religious not because someone wants me to be, but because I have chosen faith on my own and I find it hard to believe that we are all an accident. I would believe this whether I had come from a religious family or not.

    In other words, I think people would find some kind fo religion of their own. Not everyone, of course, and it may not be Christianity, but I do believe people find their own way to religion.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • WordWizard

    Adults turn to religion all the time. That is a yes.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • TravaIanche

    Religion would pretty much wither and die out if this were the case, thankfully we have parent's brainwashing their children at a young age so the pope has job security.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Bonnabell

    Yes it would since mny people choose follow it later in life aswell.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • nAt2017

    Probably, yes. But I wouldn't say that upbringing is the only cause of religious belief. I was raised Jewish, but at both a young age and as I got older, I started to become attracted to Christian ideas. Now, I take values from both. Regardless of what their parents teach them, children find a way to make their own religions.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • RapidlyRotatingPanda

    Indoctrination!

    Comment Hidden ( show )