This is a touchy subject. I would consider them a woman by physical design, but I would still think of them as a man mentally, spiritually, and internally.
The example I'm thinking of is a Potato. You skin it, slice it into fries and fry them. At this point they're called French Fries because of their physical state, but internally and from a logical standpoint they're still Potatoes.
Well... that makes sense, and I get it to some degree, but I don't really understand how you wouldn't just see them as whatever they looked / acted like. Or just as a person first, and their gender / gender traits as unimportantly secondary.
I just don't understand the steadfast clinging to the notion that their birth gender MUST be "what" they are. Unless it's a matter of sticking by the principles of science, from a logical standpoint. That I would understand.
But you said "mentally, spiritually, and internally" and that just utterly blows my mind.
Especially "internally"! You have zero idea what it's like for them internally, so it's confusing how you would sit there and think "They're probably a man, deep down inside".
Like, you'll treat them as the gender they choose to represent, but you don't buy into a single ounce of it? (mentally, spiritually, and internally is pretty all-encompassing) So... what happens if they ask you how you think about them? Is it really "respect" if you treat them nice, but don't believe anything about their gender identity is correct?
I'm not trying to be overly argumentative or defensive here, (I know I have been) so I apologize... but I'm really curious as to why you look at it the way you do, because it's different than the way I do, and I find that curious and think that if I understood it, I'd have grown some.
You're right when you say that I don't comprehend Transexuality, but you know what? Just because I can't stomach an idea it doesn't mean I have to act upon that.
I can see where you're confused. You're saying that I respect them but don't acknowledge their gender identity, and this is true. I don't acknowledge their gender identity because it's something that I don't understand too well. You can't blame people for reacting this way with something that is really unusual to them. It's just human nature.
I'm not going to be able to explain myself too well on the subject matter, but all I can tell you is that even though this kind of thing is really strange to me, I don't let it get to my head because it's not in the best interests for me and my friends.
Do you consider a post OP tranny a woman?
← View full post
This is a touchy subject. I would consider them a woman by physical design, but I would still think of them as a man mentally, spiritually, and internally.
The example I'm thinking of is a Potato. You skin it, slice it into fries and fry them. At this point they're called French Fries because of their physical state, but internally and from a logical standpoint they're still Potatoes.
--
PumpkinKate
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
How many transgender people have you actually interacted with?
I'm willing to bet that you would most likely consider them the gender that they display the most traits of, physically and otherwise.
I'd also bet you HAVE interacted with some trans folk and already done as such.
--
ItDuzzy
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
I have 5 friends who are transgendered.
And no, I treat them however they view themselves as. If they see themselves as a man/woman, that's exactly how I'll approach them as.
Just because I see it differently then they do it doesn't mean I'll put that view into action.
--
PumpkinKate
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
-1
-1
So it's more like patronizing them for the sake of saving face?
--
ItDuzzy
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
1
1
I don't patronize them. It's just a matter of respecting people's belief system.
--
PumpkinKate
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
Well... that makes sense, and I get it to some degree, but I don't really understand how you wouldn't just see them as whatever they looked / acted like. Or just as a person first, and their gender / gender traits as unimportantly secondary.
I just don't understand the steadfast clinging to the notion that their birth gender MUST be "what" they are. Unless it's a matter of sticking by the principles of science, from a logical standpoint. That I would understand.
But you said "mentally, spiritually, and internally" and that just utterly blows my mind.
Especially "internally"! You have zero idea what it's like for them internally, so it's confusing how you would sit there and think "They're probably a man, deep down inside".
Like, you'll treat them as the gender they choose to represent, but you don't buy into a single ounce of it? (mentally, spiritually, and internally is pretty all-encompassing) So... what happens if they ask you how you think about them? Is it really "respect" if you treat them nice, but don't believe anything about their gender identity is correct?
I'm not trying to be overly argumentative or defensive here, (I know I have been) so I apologize... but I'm really curious as to why you look at it the way you do, because it's different than the way I do, and I find that curious and think that if I understood it, I'd have grown some.
--
ItDuzzy
11 years ago
|
pl
Comment Hidden (
show
)
Report
0
0
See More Comments =>
You're right when you say that I don't comprehend Transexuality, but you know what? Just because I can't stomach an idea it doesn't mean I have to act upon that.
I can see where you're confused. You're saying that I respect them but don't acknowledge their gender identity, and this is true. I don't acknowledge their gender identity because it's something that I don't understand too well. You can't blame people for reacting this way with something that is really unusual to them. It's just human nature.
I'm not going to be able to explain myself too well on the subject matter, but all I can tell you is that even though this kind of thing is really strange to me, I don't let it get to my head because it's not in the best interests for me and my friends.
You don't have to apologize, it's fine.