Disclosing sexual partners

I am a 21-year-old male who lives with his 22-year-old girlfriend who happens to be far more sexually experienced than I. I often find myself wondering how many partners she has had, but when ever I bring it up she becomes extremely defensive and tells me that it is,"Non of my business." I disagree, mostly because we are so close and have even discussed marriage. I am posting this because I would like to know if it is normal for couples to disclose their "Numbers?"

Voting Results
69% Normal
Based on 337 votes (232 yes)
Help us keep this site organized and clean. Thanks!
[ Report Post ]
Comments ( 40 )
  • Crlmson

    I do not think it is normal, normal means that it is done by the majority of people. My opinion is it is only done by immature people who have not learned about trust. What you or who you in this case did in the past is not anyones business but yours and the person you were with unless you choose for it to be. You are responsible for your health and your CURRENT status in regards to std's, not if you had them or a past partner had them. IN fact that would be a breach of your past partners medical privacy which in our country is considered sacred. If you love her and trust her then why would you even want to know, what if she was the horniest slut off high school an now she isn't? Do you really want to ruin your relationship, it will. I had to grow out or that petty kind of possessivness and I feel that it is the first step towards trying to control something that you shouldn't be controlling such as someones past. It will not change whether you know about it or not it will be the same. What will not be the same is her respect for you, she will lose quite a bit for your lack of strength and insecurity. The other issue I have with it is our wonderful double standard. I freely admit I was. ok am a complete slut but as a man I get to be a stud, as a woman if they said that they would be shunned by many and approached by asses who don't reaize that being a slut doesn't mean it has to be with multiple people. I love my slut :-) she is horny and wants me all the time and she is such a slut I love her to death. OH and some of the things she does that I'm sure someone in her past taught her....I have no wish to know who but I do wish her to keep doing it to me!!! I'm just saying

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • jaibabii

    I said normal... but I don't think its wise. While you may want to know, and she may want to be honest... it probably isn't a good idea. Lol Seriously, no one wants to be judged and that's usually the reason behind her being secretive. I've only experienced my current bf asking this question. I felt like my number was high.. not that I was embarrased or ashamed... but sometimes (depending on ur upbringing and other things) shit happens lol.

    I lost my virginity at 15... peer pressure was a big part of it. And at that age I didn't value my body, didn't know what it meant to share my body with a guy... and then as I got older I still didn't get it... I wasn't "loose", I didn't have sex with everyone I dated... but there were times that I really didn't have a relationship with that person, it just felt right. But a month or two later we weren't dating anymore... happens to ppl all the time. Its not a one night stand, but who wants to keep adding notches to their belt with no meaning/feelings...

    When asked about the number of ppl I've been with I was offended and didn't answer for a long time... although I have answered him since... I needed him to know that I didn't want to be judged for things done in the past and if the number of partners had any influence on our relationship id rather be single. I never asked him, because it isn't important.

    What's important is that I've never had a STD *
    Knock on wood* and he and I get tested together twice a yr. I'm only sleeping with him and I expect the same. I mean, when you find out her number, what will you do with the information?

    Everyone has a past. If she lied how would you ever know? Just asking...

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • bands

    This is Mr Bands. The Mrs and I have discussed our previous lovers/experiences over time and have enjoyed learning about them. If your reasons for wanting to know are not based in jealousy or distrust, she may be willing to open up. Our sharing is based on an interest in knowing how our past has shaped our present and relationship together.

    You should never want more than the other is willing to give.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • JuliusE

    She was a slut. Modern "standards" as if there were any, are a goddamn joke. I am soooo happy to have found a beautiful virgin (non-Christian) wife. I couldn't stand knowing some other guy plowed my wife. I have slept with plenty of women who were not virgins but I would NEVER marry one.

    WHO WANTS DAMAGED GOODS?

    It used to be you expected your wife to be a virgin. That existed for a reason.

    I don't want to stick my dick where some other guys cock has been when that woman is supposed to be mine. That's degrading.

    Diode the slut. You can do better. Find a girl who had respect for herself (one who's dad payed attention to her or something).

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • jesusdiedlol

      You make yourself look like a complete idiot on every single comment. I thought it was just the racist thing but you're a moron in every aspect of life lol for humanity's sake I really hope you're just trolling on these comments

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • milkymum

      jesus have you ever read what you have said.

      It doesnt matter if shes laid on her back for loads of guys, you are as you have said " I have slept with plenty of women" which makes you a male slut.

      How would you feel if your now wife turned around and said " i love you" but I dont want to marry you cos you have slept with loads of women and your damaged goods!!

      This is typical male shovenes, aragence,double standards, etc, etc.

      Typical male stuck in the dark ages where its OK for a guy to sleep with laods of girls but when a girl does shes a slut or as you say damaged goods

      Comment Hidden ( show )
    • So its okay for you to have slept with a bunch of slutty women but if your "wife" had done it you wouldnt have married her??

      She probably lied to you about being a virgin anyway unless she is real ugly. So which one is it? Is she real ugly and couldnt attract anyone until you came along OR did she just lie to you about being a virgin?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • different92

    I feel like when you know, your feelings will change and of course you wont like her anymore.
    So just drop it and try experimenting with her to get better.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • If she is dating you you have a right to know. i mean seriously std's, reputation, theres all sorts of things to consider

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • milkymum

      why if they love each other the past doesnt count

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • Thats right it dosnt count. SO THERE SHOULDN'T BE A PROBLEM REVEALING IT!!!! If they love each other one shouldn't be keeping secrets.

        Comment Hidden ( show )
          -
        • milkymum

          why not maybe something happened to her in her past which she finds embarressing or hurts her and might take time for her to say what it is

          Comment Hidden ( show )
            -
          • Then take the time or say something that hints at it so they know but you dont have to discuss it. But this is about someone not saying it at all. Keeping the past hidden and refusing to say anything about it just shows you cant be trusted to tell the truth. Not good for love.

            Comment Hidden ( show )
              -
            • milkymum

              maybe she was abused or raped and finds it hard to tell someone, also if the guy is asking her all the time she might just not tell him cos hes always going on about it or how he is asking her or if its none stop asking, that would put anyone off.

              Also maybe shes scared of telling him cos he will leave her.

              She will tell him when she wants to.

              Comment Hidden ( show )
        • "Oh i love you but i cant tell you" people like that are fuck heads full stop.

          Comment Hidden ( show )
    • JustDave

      I confess Tommythecat, I completly agree with you on this. To the OP...would you buy a car without knowing the mileage?

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • so*so*fly

    I think it's normal for guys to ask about girls' numbers but it's generally a bad idea to find out. I think the less you know about her sexual past, the better. You think you want to know..but do you really wana picture every sweaty dude that ever rolled off your lady? Probably not

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Satchmo

    I agree with the OP it is important and if she is not telling u the number is most likely high sorry but it probably is. The best indicator of future behavior is her past behavior I wouldn't dump her for not telling u. U sound like me I've dated girls who have been with a lot of guys and it sucks I much prefer to date someone who has few partners honestly now I always find out before I get invested in a girl and if she won't tell me I see that as indicative that she is secretive but since u are invested I would ask her in detail about how faithful she has been in previous relationships and if she won't even answer that then drop her

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • before you there is no one and after you there is no one

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Darrell-82

    Its prolly alot of guys but seriously your playing with fire and your going to get burned. Pick and choose your battles

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • squirtle

    of course you have the right to know if you're in a serious relationship..

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • AnalyticalAm

    I think she is worried you might view her differently, or that her number may consume you to the point you can't get it out of your head. Just think for a second. How will it impact you to learn she's had over 20 partners? You won't be able to unlearn it.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • volozi

    I'd certainly want to know. I wouldn't marry her if she isn't comfortable talking about that. Communication is key to a long lasting relationship.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • smitty217

    It's normal but if you guys are in love then the number your guys' past partners doesn't really matter. Don't focus on the past. Be happy you have someone you love and who loves you

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • JuliusE

    Drop* ...paid*

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • 72candou2

    when it can threaten your health sure be honest,These are things you will find as u go along that really dont matter. We all have paths we have taken to become who we are.I think it comes when u can find security in who u are and your self confidence matures.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • All these other idiots telling you that the past is the past blah blah blah is something you should ignore.

    If you didnt spend your past screwing every woman that you came across and being a man whore, then you have every right to want someone of the opposite sex who didnt spend every opportunity she had doing the same thing.

    It would be different if you did that and still judged her on it but if you didnt then there is no reason NOT to expect and want someone who held themselves to the same standard.

    Find out or get rid of her.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • petawawacouple69

    I know all about this, I can guarantee you she won't tell you because she's been gang banged over and over. Good for her

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • She doesnt want to let you know because she most likely was a huge closet whore in her past.

    Its probably something you should press her on, nobody wants to date/marry the town whore, they just want to use her for what every other guy used her for and move on.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • milkymum

      look reputation doesnt matter here as long as they are happy and in love.

      Also why does he need to know its like her asking who hes been with or what he jacks off to

      Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Pinkfluffy1

    I think that the past is the past, she is obviously not interested in sharing it... Perhaps she feels some shame about her previous sexual partners and experiences?

    Although, I do think it's important that you as a couple can talk about sexual history just concerning safety and STDs.

    I guess you have to think to yourself how much do you really want to know? Don't you think you would just obsess over the details and use them to hurt yourself or your relationship?

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ccjigsaw

    Well, it really depends on a couples preference. My boyfriend knows all about my past sexual partners and such. It was hard to talk about, but I felt he should know. I can undertsand why she doesn't want to tell you though. No matter what, even her telling you about one guy she slept with wouldn't feel good to know. If it did happen to be quite a few men, how would you react then? Would you dump her, judge her, dig into memorys that hurt her to remember? I understand why you would want to know, but try to understand why she doesn't want to tell you. It doesn't change who she is as a person :)

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • ashfordite

    Would you find it invasive if she asked you to detail your masturbatory history and practices? Would you comfortably describe what goes through your mind, what pictures you like to look at while you jerk off? That's none of her business for the same reason her sexual history is none of your business presuming you are both currently healthy. What you need to do is grow up and stop pestering her. It sounds like you find her history either titilating or ammunition to use against her in a future spat

    Comment Hidden ( show )
  • Alison89

    Yes, it's normal, but also normal to not want to tell, especially if you're the jealous type or the kind who would use the information in an argument later.

    I prefer to know the most general and basic details, who the major relationships were with, and those who made an impact, not every single one.

    Comment Hidden ( show )
      -
    • Crlmson

      It is dissapointing to me to see that you are int he minority. I wonder hwo tommythecat feels "reputation" plays into it.
      I thought perhaps my gender was evolving, not seeing it so far but I still have hope. I wonder if they have considered how it makes her feel to not trust her to tell you if there is anything important that they need to know in her past. TRUST TRUST TRUST if you do no trust her to have your back on this without getting a damn list, you are not ready for a fully commited relationship. Perhaps too you can trade lists of acceptable behavior for every situation. OH and you better find out how many times with each person, also their numbers and name so you can keep an eye on her phone and while at it get all the numbers out of her contact list and check them all out because she is too stupid and too unfaithful to be trusted to do the right thing you know ? TIE that bitch down quick and get all the info. I promise you that you will be standing alone and hurt in the near future I am trying to save you a painful lesson, and it took me many and a lot of pain...plops off his soap box

      Comment Hidden ( show )
        -
      • clwbeach17

        We are two entirely separate people. Yes, we are in love, but how can you expect us to have the exact same impressions of what is and is not important? I trust her, you have no idea how much I trust her. I want a list for my own personal reasons, namely so I do not have to wonder/worry how high the number is and so I am not asking my self if she has slept with every guy we see out that she knows. Maybe that wouldn't bother you, but I don't enjoy not knowing. It does occur to me that I am asking for a great deal of trust, for she is so clearly not proud of her past, but I also consider my piece of mind to be important.

        Comment Hidden ( show )