So you mean it's not that creepy, but I make it sound like it is?

Yeah maybe I am, I just feel a little creepy. Other guys in my class have tried to plait her hair before and she got super pissed, so maybe they're the creepy ones :P

Do you like subconsciously lean forward to, or only when their hair is like near you or whatever? (like my situation)

She saw me throwing her hair over her shoulder once, because I couldn't see my book. She gave me a cheeky smile and lay her head down on the table and completely covered my table and hands in it. ...

What types of situations do you do it in? I had a friend come sit next to me, and he started twirling the ends of her hair around his finger sort of subconsciously too. I do it very consciously